The winner is already known in the Democratic primary between incumbent U.S. Reps. Jason Altmire and Mark Critz. It's the Republican Party.

GOP mapmakers had to cut one of Pennsylvania's seats after the 2010 U.S. Census, so they smushed Mr. Altmire's 4th District into a new 12th District, stretching it from the Ohio border in Beaver County past Pittsburgh down to the borough of Somerset. In the process they forced the two incumbents into a tense battle that is draining Democratic campaign coffers, testing the might of the party's friends in organized labor and leaving the victor bloodied going into a competitive general election race in the fall.

The candidates are prime examples of Pennsylvania's socially conservative Democratic species, both of them pro-gun, anti-abortion and unafraid to keep their distance from their party's leader, Barack Obama. Even the biggest issue in their race -- Mr. Obama's 2010 health care reform bill -- is something they both opposed.

Mr. Altmire, 44, of McCandless, alienated organized labor with his health care vote, and its leaders are going all out to win the April 24 primary for Mr. Critz, 50, a Johnstown native and former aide to the late U.S. Rep. John Murtha in the 12th District. The United Steelworkers union alone has pledged to reach all 11,000 of its members and retirees in the district multiple times though phone calls, mail, rallies and work site visits extolling Mr. Critz's ties to blue-collar workers, and then follow up with a full-press, get-out-the-vote effort on primary day.

Advertise with us

Mr. Critz has nearly 20 other union groups working for him too, including the massive United Mine Workers, Service Employees International Union and the state's AFL-CIO.

"It's rare for there to be two [Democratic] incumbents like this. It's even rarer for an organization like ours to get in the middle," said Tim Waters, the Steelworkers' political director. "It's not normal, but this is where we find ourselves today. And we're doing it in a place where Mark Critz is the underdog."

Mr. Altmire has many advantages in the race. He has raised $1.5 million to Mr. Critz's $1.1 million during the cycle, and polling by both campaigns has shown him in the lead. He has been in Congress since beating incumbent Republican Melissa Hart in 2006, whereas Mr. Critz took office after a 2010 special election and is serving his first full term. About two-thirds of residents in the new 12th District reside in areas he has represented for six years, while Mr. Critz has to introduce himself to voters in the growing suburbs of Pittsburgh's North Hills.

Mr. Altmire has the support of Democratic committees in Beaver, Allegheny and Westmoreland counties -- which carry 75 percent of the district's Democratic voters -- and has also been deft at fighting off Republican challengers in an increasingly GOP-friendly area. In the Republican wave election year of 2010, when five other Pennsylvania Democrats lost their congressional seats, Mr. Altmire beat back his GOP challenger Keith Rothfus (by a spare 1.6 percentage points).

Mr. Rothfus is running again and will likely begin May with more money than either Democrat due to their late spending on the primary. The new GOP map filled the 12th District with 54 percent John McCain 2008 presidential voters, up from the 50 percent under the previous district lines. Whoever the Democratic primary winner is, he will have to be politically bilingual.

Advertise with us

Mr. Altmire is skilled at that. At a town hall last week in Beaver Falls, questions covered illegal immigration, welfare fraud, contraception and other topics that would have been at home on talk radio. "Obama is just ... socialist. I don't think he's much of a leader," said Pat Sasic of Beaver Falls, a lifelong Democrat and senior citizen who registered independent after the president's 2010 election. "I like [Mr. Altmire]. He listens to both sides. He decides on the issues rather than going along with the party."

After the meeting, Mr. Altmire stood outside the church hall in Beaver Falls, adjacent to an abandoned B&W steel mill that politicians of neither party have been able to resuscitate. The issues at town halls, he said, are the same no matter where he travels districtwide.

"The reason I have these is to hear back from people, to hear what they have to say. It's cumulative. You add all that up, and when I go back to Washington it colors the way I feel."

Mr. Critz is more conservative than Mr. Altmire on some issues, voting against Dodd-Frank Wall Street reform bill, federal funding for Planned Parenthood and repealing the "don't ask don't tell" policy on gays in the military. (He was not yet in Congress for the vote on Obama's Affordable Care Act, but has said he would have opposed it.)

He too has thrived despite GOP environments, having won twice over Republican Tim Burns in 2010 in nationally watched races. But he seems more comfortable in drawing on national Democratic support, such as that from former President Bill Clinton, a Murtha ally who endorsed his bids against Mr. Burns and the latest one versus Mr. Altmire.

Advertise with us

One of the biggest fights of the primary battle started deep in the weeds of Democratic politics. Last year Mr. Critz went along with Democratic leaders trying to embarrass Republicans by voting "present" on a tea party-supported budget that stood no chance of actually being approved. Mr. Altmire was one of 16 Democrats who didn't go along, and he released an ad last month stating Mr. Critz "didn't vote against the tea party budget that would dismantle health care and gut Social Security."

Mr. Critz responded with an ad explaining his position and rounded up Democratic Whip Steny Hoyer and other leaders to defend the vote. He has also hit Mr. Altmire for being one of 25 Democrats to vote in favor of a GOP effort to amend the Constitution to require balanced budgets, which Mr. Critz and most other Democrats say would endanger those same entitlements.

The campaign also grew bitter when the Critz campaign went to court to challenge Mr. Altmire's petition signatures -- many of them collected by a 23-year-old aide -- and came within 150 signatures of getting him tossed from the ballot. Mr. Altmire called the challenge "an inexcusable lack of respect."

Republicans got the tough battle they wanted. At a Plum senior citizen center last week Mr. Critz waited for a small group of seniors to turn down "The Price Is Right" before showing them the AARP card in his wallet. "I'm not going to stand there and let somebody sully my record on Social Security and Medicare when I'm one of the leaders in Congress on the issues," he said, referring to the ad war.

"I'm a Democrat and I'm proud to be a Democrat," he said. "I'm a working class guy. I'm not some slick politician, I'm just a guy. I'm not here to fluff over everything, I'm going to tell you what's on my mind."

Advertise with us

Labor leaders commonly repeat, in a refrain going back to the March 2010 vote on health care reform, that they do not know what's on Mr. Altmire's mind. Leaders from Steelworkers president Leo Gerard to Allegheny County Labor Council head Jack Shea said Mr. Altmire personally promised to vote for the cornerstone Obama measure, only to announce his opposition at the 11th hour, poisoning his relationship with the key Democratic constituency ever since. (Mr. Altmire has said the commitment was never "ironclad" and the conversations were months before the vote.)

"When we help elect people, we don't expect to tell them how to vote, but we sort of hope they listen to us," said Rick Bloomingdale, the head of the state AFL-CIO, who was not in the meetings with Mr. Altmire. "People felt Jason almost put his finger in the wind to see which way the wind was going, not on what was best for the retired steelworkers and other folks who helped him beat Melissa Hart. We felt he wasn't there for his constituents."

Mr. Altmire's opponents see him as having only one constituency -- himself. The McCandless man obviously portrays himself differently, as a hard worker who has cast more than 4,600 votes in Congress and never blinked under pressure.

"The reason I've been re-elected is because I represent the entire district," he said in a Tuesday debate. "I represent Western Pennsylvania and my number one priority is to fight for the constituents that sent me to Washington. I'm never going to sit silently by."