For much of his short life, Giovanni Aletriz was a funny, creative boy: a class clown "who could look at you and draw your picture while you were talking," his mother said.
By age 16, he was 6-foot-1, 250 pounds -- an oversized teddy bear to the ones he loved.
"He was big, but his heart was so much bigger," said his mother, Cynthia Allen of Bethlehem, Pa.
Giovanni started "getting out of character" as a teenager, she said. He smoked cigarettes, cut school, did "nutty kid things in the streets." After Giovanni was arrested -- and doctors diagnosed his bipolar disorder -- his probation officer suggested he enroll in Summit Quest Academy, a state-licensed institution in Ephrata.
"He knew that things were getting out of hand," Ms. Allen said. "And he agreed. He signed himself in."
Giovanni entered the residential facility in late fall 2005. By February 2006, he was dead, restrained face-down by staff members until he lost consciousness.
"It's overwhelming when I think about the last eight minutes of my son's life," Ms. Allen said.
That same year, the Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare began to consider banning "prone restraints," the type of face-down hold used on Giovanni. Experts say the technique is particularly dangerous for children, placing pressure on their respiratory system and risking brain damage or death. Private residential care providers had used prone restraints for years, though, and the idea of outlawing them was heavily debated.
"I was at a table for a lot of those debates," said Bernadette Bianchi, executive director of the Pennsylvania Council of Children, Youth and Family Services, a membership association of providers. "And some of them were very, very heated."
Providers resisted at first, DPW policy director Angela Logan said.
"But I think that's why we delayed it," Ms. Logan said. "We worked with providers. We went out, we did a lot of speaking engagements."
"When it finally came out ... we had no subsequent problems," she said.
In December 2009, the DPW issued a bulletin notifying providers that effective June 2010, prone restraints were prohibited in residential facilities for children. Pennsylvania was the fifth state to institute the ban, Ms. Logan said. Supine restraints, face-up holds on the floor, are still legal.
Three years after Giovanni's death, Summit Quest Academy closed, according to the Lancaster Intelligencer Journal.
Lancaster County District Attorney Donald Totaro declined to file charges against the staff members who restrained Giovanni, writing in a news release: "Although some may legitimately question the wisdom of using manual restraints on children, the evidence shows that these procedures were approved by the Department of Public Welfare and they were followed by employees of Summit Quest."
According to the news release, staff restrained Giovanni after he refused to follow instructions, threatened them and "acted as though he was going to assault a female staff member."
Ms. Allen said the confrontation started because her son was wearing a hooded sweatshirt. Staff told him to take it off, and he refused, she said.
"My son was like that: When it's right, it's right, and when it's wrong, it's wrong. There's no in between."
The county coroner listed Giovanni's cause of death as asphyxia and cardiac dysrhythmia. The autopsy found that he had an enlarged heart, and Mr. Totaro wrote that this "could have contributed" to his death.
Ms. Allen recalled that the funeral home could do little to conceal the bruises on her son's face.
"He was grown," she said. "But you have to remember, he was a boy."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.