Dozens gathered in Enright Park in East Liberty Monday evening to commemorate the 10-year anniversary of the mass displacement of Penn Plaza residents and call for affordable housing solutions.
The rally comes after more than 200 residents of the former Penn Plaza apartments were evicted when developer LG Reality Advisers decided in 2015 to tear down the building and replace it with an office and retail space that includes a Whole Foods Market. Those displaced included several from low-income units.
Demonstrators at the rally held signs calling for housing solutions for the low-income residents in the city.
Mayor Ed Gainey and City Councilman Khari Mosley were in attendance alongside former Penn Plaza residents and advocates.
Randall Taylor, a former resident and organizer of the anniversary rally, said he remains devastated by the memory of what occurred a decade ago.
“It’s heartbreaking every time you think about the situation,” he said. “It was one of the worst things in my life watching that happen.”
Read More
Mr. Taylor, who hasn’t set foot in the Whole Foods Market that was built on the property, said he had to move numerous times following his eviction from Penn Plaza.
O’Harold Hoots, another former Penn Plaza resident, said he had to move three times before finding another place that was suitable to live.
“It was such an injustice that so many people were evicted from their homes … please don’t ever forget that housing matters,” he said.
During the rally, a moment of silence was held for former Penn Plaza residents Mabel Duffy and Myrtle Stern, who became prominent housing advocates in wake of the evictions at the building, but have since died.
The two former residents were notably photographed on a couch in the middle of Penn and Centre avenues during a “living room” protest, during which furniture was brought into the intersection.
“Ms. Mabel was never able to move back to the city, though she wanted to, but Ms. Mabel, we were able to find her nice housing her,” Mr. Taylor said. “People did die in this situation.”
For some, the rally brought back some difficult emotions, including for Crystal Jennings-Rivera, the daughter of a former Penn Plaza resident and director of stewardship and community engagement at the City of Bridges Community Land Trust.
Ms. Jennings-Rivera reached out to displaced residents to see if they would like to move back to the area into Mellon’s Orchard South on North Beatty Street after the developer agreed to reserve some of the apartment units created as part of the project in 2021.
“It’s not easy to mobilize people,” she said. “It’s not easy to move people. It’s hard work.”
Throughout the rally, demonstrators called for the City Council to pass inclusionary zoning, which requires larger developments to make a percentage of those units affordable to tenants who make less than 50% of the area median income, or about $40,500 for a family of two.
Inclusionary zoning already exists in certain parts of the city, including Lawrenceville and Bloomfield.
Earlier this month, City Council struck down legislation that would allow neighborhoods to decide whether they wanted inclusionary zoning added to new developments.
“We need zoning changes to make it easier to build the housing that we desperately need, especially smaller and more affordable homes,” Dave Breingan, co-chair of Pittsburgh United’s Housing Justice Table, said. “That includes adopting inclusionary zoning citywide to make sure that we’re creating housing for neighbors of all income levels.”
Mr. Gainey said the introduction of citywide inclusionary zoning could ultimately help attract more people to Pittsburgh.
“The more housing we have, the more the people can live in the community and be connected to their safety nets,” he said. “The more housing we have for our people, the more people move into the city. That’s how we repopulate our city … change doesn’t come easy, but it comes in time.”
Mr. Mosley credited the evictions at Penn Plaza as a “wake-up call” about the scarcity of affordable housing and pledged to work towards passing inclusionary zoning.
“That will grow the city and grow our economy, but most importantly, it lifts up the most vulnerable among us,” he said.
Mr. Taylor said Monday’s rally kicks off a year of events related to promoting housing solutions.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.