After public pushback, legislation that will make sweeping updates to Pittsburgh’s zoning code is headed to City Council.
During Tuesday’s Planning Commission meeting, city leaders discussed what they say are necessary changes to the zoning law to ensure that it falls in line with the federal fair housing standards. The amendments, leaders argued, will provide much-needed flexibility to create more housing solutions, including those for homeless individuals, and simplify regulations around group housing.
But the intended goals seemed to fall short, as many community members voiced concerns that the legislation felt rushed and didn’t give the public enough time to fully review or understand it before going to a vote.
Planning Commission members ultimately voted to send the proposal to City Council, but with a condition — to offer more outreach and education on what these zoning code changes could mean for local neighborhoods.
“The city doesn't have a choice here in whether or not to comply with federal law,” zoning Administrator Corey Layman said during the meeting. “This is the right thing to do in my opinion.”
The amendment would significantly expand where shelters and congregate housing, such as halfway houses, can be permitted and would allow one group residential use to be changed to another kind of use, like converting a former hospital or convent into a shelter. It would also create a new category called “interim housing” to permit temporary housing structures.
Read More
That temporary housing could vary from tents used by homeless people, as Mr. Layman indicated during the meeting, or tiny homes, which council members were previously pushing through the Planning Commission. After months of deliberations, council withdrew its tiny home proposal last week to allow this fair housing legislation to move forward first.
The amendment would also allow other group housing types, such as single-room occupancies or halfway houses to be permitted “by right,” meaning no public or council approval would be required.
Carmen Brown, of the Lincoln-Lemington-Belmar neighborhood, said it feels like encoding a way for the city to circumvent public approval, allowing the development of homeless shelters wherever leaders see fit.
She said the process would not be “fair and equitable,” she said, especially to underserved communities, which she said would likely see most of these developments.
“Taxpayers have right to have conversations through the zoning process about what is being shoved in their community,” Ms. Brown said.
Others agreed, with William Anderson, chair of the Allegheny County Democratic Black Caucus, adding, “You're going to recommend something that the community has no idea about ... the city should have had public meetings about this before it even went before the zoning board.”
Pittsburgh resident Alison Keating provided the lone voice of support. She, too, acknowledged the confusion, but she said it’s about providing more options to vulnerable people and they wouldn’t just be offered up by just anyone.
“No one is jumping to provide these homes,” she said. “People are not going to set up shelters right next to you.”
At the end of the day, Mr. Layman told attendees that the Pittsburgh’s zoning code has been found to be not fully in compliance with the federal Fair Housing Act, so if the current legislation doesn’t move successfully through the Planning Commission and council, they would have to rework it and try again.
Commission members deliberated whether to push back the vote another two weeks to give community members more time with the proposal.
Commission member LaShawn Burton-Faulk emphasized that the Planning Commission’s vote of approval is just “one step” in the process. The public will have the opportunity to provide more feedback moving forward, and council members can still amend the legislation.
“This bill is bringing an ethical and moral balance to current federal fair housing laws,” she said. “Where there might be some challenge in terms of digesting, any time there’s something you’re just seeing, it presents a level of angst.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.