Renetta Ragin arrived at Second Avenue Commons homeless shelter on June 4, only to find the building on fire.
Ms. Ragin, 61, had never been to a homeless shelter, and the fire was the latest complication in a month that left her in a more precarious housing situation than ever before.
“I was doing fine,” she said, until the roof of her Highland Park apartment building started caving in the spring.
Three days after paying April rent, she received a text message from her landlord informing her that he would no longer renew her lease. All of the building’s tenants would need to relocate because of roof leakage.
Finding new housing proved impossible for Ms. Ragin who, as a Housing Choice Voucher recipient, had limited options due largely to overwhelming demand for units that accept the city-issued vouchers.
She ran out of time.
Read More
Her story is all too common, representing a growing demographic of individuals deemed “low needs” — defined in Allegheny County as people experiencing homelessness based exclusively on inability to pay — entering Pittsburgh’s shelter system. Many people who benefit from rental and income assistance programs like Ms. Ragin are perilously close to unstable housing situations.
The county estimated that these individuals used 75% of shelter bed days in 2023. And this summer, extreme heat and the closing of Second Avenue Commons in the wake of the fire has only increased the suffering for those who are already in difficult situations, according to community experts.
The Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) program allows individuals with low incomes to use a voucher to subsidize rent in the private housing market. The federal government provides funds to the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh, which covers any rental costs for voucher recipients that exceed 30% of their income.
Ms. Ragin’s search was exacerbated by the need for a deposit for a new apartment: She first had to wait for her monthly Supplemental Security Income check. Even with that in hand, she was competing with hundreds of other potential renters in the private market, and only found a handful of units that would accept her voucher. On May 31, she went to stay with her ex-boyfriend's mother until she could get herself Downtown to a shelter while she continued her search.
Ms. Ragin never got to check into Second Avenue Commons. On the day she went Downtown, a fire broke out in a fourth-floor air conditioning unit at the shelter, displacing approximately 180 people and leaving the building with significant damage. The shelter has yet to reopen, although plans are in the works to do so by November. In an effort to make up for the lost shelter, the County Department of Human Resources immediately opened a temporary shelter in the David L. Lawrence Convention Center. On June 15, Pittsburgh Mercy also opened one in the North Side.
Before she eventually found permanent housing, 38 days after showing up at Second Avenue Commons, Ms. Ragin moved between three temporary shelters: the Convention Center, Pittsburgh Mercy and Community Human Services’ Scattered Site Shelter in Oakland.
“It felt like God left me,” she said. “It felt like I was being punished for nothing. For something that wasn't my fault. That's how I felt. I mean I cried, because I really didn’t deserve that.”
Through the voucher program, the Housing Authority administers around 7,500 units. These subsidized units on the private market outnumber the Housing Authority’s other affordable housing programs, which include 3,150 public housing units and 134 units of local, non-traditional housing.
In recent years, a housing stock shortage, coupled with increasing demand, has sent housing and rental prices soaring in Pittsburgh and around the country.
The housing affordability crisis has an outsized effect on low-income people, and significantly contributes to homelessness, said Jerrel Gilliam, executive director at Light of Life Rescue Mission.
As the homeless population continues to grow, so have waitlists for affordable housing programs. Although Pittsburgh waitlists are currently closed, officials received nearly 12,000 applications when the HCV waitlist last opened in the spring, for the first time in six years.
Even when individuals obtain a housing voucher, finding a unit that will accept it is challenging, said Carol Hardeman, executive director for the Hill District Consensus Group. Landlords are not legally prevented from rejecting vouchers, but must have the same criteria for screening voucher recipients as they do for all other potential tenants.
In addition, Ms. Hardeman, who held a housing voucher in the 1980s and now helps people in her community navigate the program, said that many of the housing voucher recipients she works with struggle to find housing outside of low-income neighborhoods. A 2019 report by the Post-Gazette found that landlords were often only willing to accept housing choice vouchers for units in low-income neighborhoods in Pittsburgh.
“As with persons who do not hold a voucher, HCV participants reside in areas to be near family, friends, places of worship, familiar community,” Marsha Grayson, HACP Chief Operations Officer, said in an email.
HACP also offers programs, such as the Family Self-Sufficiency and the Community Choice Demonstration Program, “where residents may receive services in the form of counseling, budgeting and assistance in locating units in neighborhoods with a higher income base,” Ms. Grayson said.
The program’s success rate is not where Pittsburgh’s Housing Authority wants it to be, said Chuck Rohrer, director of communications at HACP. Just 40% of people who receive vouchers are successful at leasing an apartment with them, he said, and rental units can be hard to come by because “hundreds of clients are looking at the same time for housing.”
Moving to a shelter was a last-resort option for Ms. Ragin. She struggled with the living conditions, particularly at the Convention Center temporary shelter.
“Every day there was an argument. Every night there was an argument. People barely got any sleep and I lost so much weight,” she said.
Homelessness is often “hard to quantify” for low-needs individuals who move between the shelter system and private homes, Ms. Hardeman said. She works with many people who, like Ms. Ragin, instead of immediately checking into a shelter, will stay in someone’s garage or on a couch while trying to find affordable units that take their vouchers.
Retired from her job at a laundromat and divorced, Ms. Ragin faced a kind of housing insecurity recurrent among older, single, low-income women, explained Andrea Sharam, an Australian researcher who writes about social and affordable housing.
“These are largely people who — the housing market “happened” to them,” Ms. Sharam said.
Those considered to be low-needs do not necessarily suffer from mental health or addiction issues, 46% have an income source and 76% have not previously experienced homelessness, according to the county.
“They were an innocent bystander in the scenario, so they don't know how to go from a person who sees themselves as very mainstream, to being someone in this thing called ‘the homelessness population,’” Ms. Sharam said.
Ms. Ragin started receiving more support looking for permanent housing when she moved to Community Human Services’ Scattered Site Shelter in Oakland on June 17, she said.
There, Ms. Ragin met Melissa Osburn, a social worker for Community Human Services, a local nonprofit dedicated to providing people with stable housing and food resources. Ms. Osburn helped Ms. Ragin search for an apartment that would accept her housing voucher. Ms. Ragin was prepared for the process: “I already had all my paperwork. I wasn't behind on rent or anything,” she said.
The Housing Authority does not offer resources to people who have housing vouchers but face housing insecurity while they look to the private market to apply their voucher to another lease.
Filling that gap are nonprofit organizations such as Community Human Services and Light of Life. Light of Life works with the Housing Authority to find available units, and also maintains relationships with individual landlords, Mr. Gilliam said. According to Ms. Hardeman, many community groups share housing lists with information for landlords that often accept housing vouchers.
Community Human Services declined to comment for this article.

Ms. Ragin, after some five weeks in shelters, landed in a new home that Ms. Osburn found through a landlord she collaborated with previously, Ms. Ragin explained.
And on July 11, Ms. Ragin moved into a one-bedroom apartment on a quiet, tree-lined street in Bloomfield.
That day, she went straight to Target to buy a queen-size inflatable bed, relieved to leave behind the shelter cots. Ms. Ragin thought to herself, “yes, thank you, I’m off of punishment now for something I didn’t do.”
Ms. Ragin made a makeshift address sign with a ripped piece of paper and blue marker, and taped it to her mailbox.
“It felt good just to have door keys,” she said.
She felt lucky to have met Ms. Osburn, and wished there were more advocates like her to help others in the shelter system. Many of the people Ms. Ragin met while moving between shelters were still searching for permanent housing, she said.
Two days after the Second Avenue Commons fire, the county announced its “500 in 500” initiative to help people exit homelessness and create more space in shelters by making 500 affordable housing units available in 500 days.
The initiative comes at a crucial time. Homelessness and housing insecurity continue to rise among “low needs” individuals, said Jackie Smith, a sociology professor at the University of Pittsburgh and co-coordinator of the Pittsburgh Human Rights City Alliance.
“It’s a problem affecting more and more people. And [in] each generation it's getting worse,” Ms. Smith said.
Ms. Ragin’s new apartment is filled with a few pieces of furniture left behind by a former tenant: a crushed velvet couch, a tall lamp and an old wooden dresser. She has plans to replace the couch with her own and to bring in her 50-inch TV, once she can move them out of a storage unit.
This is part of the looming precariousness in Ms. Ragin’s housing situation — she is still trying to get most of her belongings out of the storage locker where she placed them, back when the roof started caving at her Highland Park apartment. In addition, she is in the process of getting her voucher fully approved for the new apartment, and still worries how long she’ll be able to stay there, she said.
Still, Ms. Ragin appreciates what she has for the moment. She likes to sit on her new porch and watch the street, waving hello to the other apartment tenants — her new neighbors — as they walk in and out of the house.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.