As homelessness hit a record high nationwide last year, the highest court in the United States provides new leeway to penalize people for being homeless in public spaces.
But the question is which cities will turn to a punitive approach to tackle the growing crisis.
The Supreme Court ruled Friday that cities can enforce bans on homeless people from camping outdoors. In a 6-3 vote, the court sided with Grants Pass, a southwest Oregon city, that its ordinance prohibiting outdoor sleeping does not violate the Constitution’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment.
The ruling clears the way for municipalities across the country to arrest, fine and jail people for sleeping in public spaces, even if shelter space isn’t available. Pittsburgh leaders have said that the decision won’t change the way the city is handling homelessness, but local advocates still worry about the precedent it sets.
Emily Powell, director of nursing operations for Pitt Street Medicine and a clinician at Second Avenue Commons, doesn’t think the criminal justice system should be solving a public health problem.
“You've taken it out of the hands of health and human services and put it into judges,” she said. “Judges don't know much about homelessness. This has the massive capacity to get even worse.”
Read More
The Supreme Court case began when the city of Grants Pass passed ordinances barring people from sleeping outside in public using items like a blanket, pillow or a cardboard sheet to lie on. The city’s homeless population could face hundreds of dollars in fines, even jail time, for staying outside while the city’s shelter system had no openings.
Those who work with Pittsburgh’s homeless population don’t want to see that happen here. But Ms. Powell is feeling confident in the word of local officials who are promising that criminalization isn’t where the city is headed.
In a statement on the social media site X, Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato said that despite the ruling, the county’s work will remain the same – providing more affordable housing and opportunities that will help people experiencing homelessness live “stable, dignified lives.”
Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey shared a similar sentiment, turning attention to ongoing efforts to build up the region’s housing stock. Earlier this month, Ms. Innamorato announced “500 in 500,” an initiative that sets out to house 500 people in 500 days.
“Today serves as a reminder of the critical need for more transitional and affordable housing, and why we are proud to partner with the County on their 500 in 500 plan,” Mr. Gainey wrote on X on Friday.
As the demand for shelter and housing continues to outweigh the supply, an increasing number of cities are turning to drastic measures. From 2006 to 2019, the National Homelessness Law Center looked at nearly 200 cities and found that city-wide bans on camping have increased by 92%; on sitting or laying by 78%; on loitering by 103%; on panhandling by 103% and on living in vehicles by 213%.
Pittsburgh hasn’t implemented an outright ban, but the city tightened its rules around camping on public property last summer after facing the fallout of closing one of its longtime overnight shelters on Smithfield Avenue. The newly formalized rules permit the removal of tents if officials find accumulated trash or health hazards, as well as reported criminal activity.
The city has since decommissioned several encampments – one on an intersection near Fort Pitt Boulevard Downtown and another on First Avenue. When clearing tents, the new policy also requires the city to be able to provide “credible offers” for housing.
That’s the very crux of the issue, Ms. Powell said. Working in a shelter clinic and conducting street outreach across the city, she said people are just desperate for a place to stay.
“I could give you a beautiful line of people that would be more than happy to take housing ASAP, but there's just none to be had,” she said. “I mean, how can you criminalize somebody for something they can't afford?”
The collateral consequences of pursuing criminal convictions on homeless people will ultimately make it more difficult for people to exit their situations, she said. People can stay in jail for weeks if they cannot pay their bail or fines, losing property and employment in the process.
Once released, their criminal records add new barriers to getting a job, housing or public benefits. And the additional fines and court fees required to resolve their case can be hundreds to thousands of dollars. Not paying can mean even more jail time.
“You've just limited job choices and advancement choices and essentially crippled someone for just existing,” she said. “You've also now put a stigma on somebody for their whole entire life, and it's just devastating. It's tough enough being homeless.”
Lauren Brown, a spokesperson for Goodwill that serves southwestern Pa., called the ruling “troubling.” Ms. Brown and other advocates agree that the issue arises from an increasing lack of affordable housing in Pittsburgh over the past few years, citing the post-COVID spike in the real estate market and stagnant wages in Pennsylvania amidst inflation.
Ms. Brown said if the Supreme Court were looking for a way to address the issue, she thinks they should look to better mental health support services, education services and affordable housing opportunities.
“That's the solution to homelessness, not making it criminal for people to sleep on the street,” Ms. Brown said.
Theresa Kail-Smith, city council member who represents District 2 neighborhoods, doesn’t see Pittsburgh doing anything differently because of the ruling. She has pushed for creating affordable housing projects and finding city parcels on which to build them.
As council president, she convened a committee to evaluate homelessness and find new strategies to tackle the issue. But she thinks the government is too slow, at times, to move on those solutions. Only a few pieces of legislation, largely focusing on creating transitional housing, have come to fruition.
“I just don't understand why it's so difficult,” she said. “I’m not saying it has to be perfect, but it's better than a tent outside in freezing temperatures. I think other people make it more complex than it needs to be. I think I underestimate. I think they overestimate.”
While she doesn’t think law enforcement is the right way to handle homelessness, she also doesn’t think the street is the safest place for people to stay, especially long term. She said some encampments have posed public safety issues, but the law already addresses criminal behavior, separate from being homeless.
“I don't know if the ruling will make an impact locally, but I do think that we should be doing more,” she said. “There's a whole host of reasons why people are homeless. Criminalizing them and arresting them, I don't think that's the right avenue.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.