Allegheny County is modernizing its housing code for the first time in 25 years. But to some, meeting bare minimum standards isn’t enough.
Since 2019, community organizers have coalesced around the creation of a new committee under the Allegheny County Board of Health, one that would focus on making substantive revisions to outdated housing standards that affect thousands of renters in the county.
These efforts, delayed by the pandemic and the turnover of officials at the Allegheny County Health Department, are one step closer to becoming a reality. On Wednesday, Board of Health members unanimously voted, preliminarily, in favor of creating a Housing Advisory Committee.
The public will have a chance to provide feedback over the next 30 days before the board makes a final vote on the proposal and, if approved, sends it to County Council.
Kate Kleinle, a community organizer for Clean Water Action, a regional environmental justice organization, told board members the committee would give the community a seat at the table and help protect the county's most vulnerable from being forced to live in substandard housing.
“Safety at home is an inalienable right.” Ms. Kleinle said. “County residents need a permanent body in place to enforce that right.”
In March, the board approved a series of updates to the county’s Housing and Community Environment regulation, also known as Article VI.
The changes, awaiting approval from County Council, will add some key protections for renters, including requirements for carbon monoxide detectors, deadbolts and fall prevention devices on certain windows. Some advocates still see glaring gaps in the code.
One of them was Kevin Quisenberry, the Community Justice Project’s litigation director who drafted early versions of the proposal to create the committee. He said the recent updates to Article VI were “small, incremental tweaks” meant to bring the code in line with state and federal regulatory requirements.
A permanent, structured committee could go deeper, he said, and rectify Article VI’s shortcomings through community engagement. That’s why Wednesday’s preliminary approval is such a “big step” forward.
“It really is,” Mr. Quisenberry said. “It's a great permanent structure for direct community engagement with the housing division within the Health Department.”
The challenges of the pandemic and changes in the Health Department, which hasn’t had a director for more than a year, left the committee idea adrift without real momentum for years.
Last month, the board of health directors indicated an interest in exploring the concept but said they were not prepared to take it further at the time. What shifted the tide the last few weeks was a push from Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato’s administration, who engaged in conversations with the board and advocates like Mr. Quisenberry.
Ms. Innamorato would directly appoint the nine to 15 members of the Housing Advisory Committee, and they would also need to be approved by County Council. The members, who would serve for up to three years, would comprise rental housing owners, landlord organizations, academic experts, community organizations, tenant advocacy groups and residents. If approved, the committee would start its work in January 2025.
Community advocates say they already have some critical issues in mind that the committee should immediately explore, including addressing radon, mold and bedbug infestation.
Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis, executive director of Women for a Healthy Environment, is especially concerned about radon, the second-leading cause of lung cancer behind smoking. Despite the public health risk, radon is not regulated by Allegheny County public health codes or any municipal housing codes, she said.
And Pennsylvania has one of the most serious radon problems in the country, according to the state’s Department of Environmental Protection. Approximately 40% of Pennsylvania homes have radon levels above the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's action guideline.
“By having a committee work together collectively to discuss needs and look at solutions, we know that we will have better public health outcomes,” she said.
The county’s Health Department also currently relies on a complaint-driven approach, which asks renters to make the complaint and potentially risk eviction when their unit doesn’t meet minimum health and safety standards.
Mr. Quisenberry wants to see Article VI include protections from retaliation for renters.
“For particularly lower-income tenants who are having some serious health or safety issue, it puts them in a really precarious situation,” he said. “They're scared of losing their housing because they can't afford to pack up and move.”
Steve Hvozdovich, Pennsylvania campaigns director of Clean Water Action, said creating a committee isn’t starting from scratch. It’s modeled after the board’s already existing food safety committee and air quality committee, where he has served as a member for more than 10 years. He believes a dedicated group could make healthy housing more of a priority.
“There’s no doubt about it,” Mr. Hvozdovich said. “A housing advisory committee who meets on a regular basis will continue to drive policy ideas so that we’re not having such a massive gap in terms of when we update policy around housing in the county.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.