After a push from the Homeless Advisory Board, the Allegheny County Department of Human Services has decided it will open an emergency shelter for people experiencing homelessness when temperatures drop below 26 degrees.
In response to recommendations from the board earlier this week, DHS Director Erin Dalton and Pittsburgh Chief Operating and Administrative Officer Lisa Frank on Thursday indicated that the county will enact what is known as a “Code Blue Action Plan” when temperatures reach that point.
In an email Tuesday to the DHS, the board said it was concerned that no extended overnight shelter capacity would be open that evening, despite a “significant deficit” estimated at more than 130 beds needed to accommodate homeless people facing temperatures in the low 20s.
Such weather conditions in the past had triggered the opening of a severe weather shelter, the board said.
During a news conference last month, DHS officials emphasized its commitment to care for people in need during severe weather, but provided limited details about what factors, such as temperature, would determine when the county would activate emergency space. Ms. Dalton said the department wanted to maintain flexibility.
“What if the low was 33, but there was 2 feet of snow on the ground?” she said to reporters.
Read More
The board also expressed frustration that there was no plan to open additional overflow immediately, which “directly contradicts” the county’s publicly released plan. To keep the “most vulnerable” residents safe, the board recommended that emergency shelters be opened when the temperature falls to, or under, 32 degrees.
The DHS response Thursday was to open the emergency space when temperatures fall under 26 degrees between 4 p.m. and 8 a.m. The department did not provide further details about where the emergency space is located or how many people it can accommodate.
Pittsburgh will follow the same plan when it activates its Emergency Operations Center in the event of severe weather, Ms. Frank and Ms. Dalton said. Like in past winters, Pittsburgh Recreation and Healthy Active Living Centers will continue to open as warming locations should temperatures drop below 20 degrees.
Chase Archer Evans, a member of the Homeless Advisory Board, said he was disappointed that DHS is not implementing the board’s recommended 32-degree activation point for the emergency shelter.
“My first concern is the threshold,” Mr. Evans said. “I think it's pretty clear that 26 degrees can be deadly, 30 degrees can be deadly. It’s all arbitrary. . . .”
He also questions the continued “ambiguity” around the emergency shelter’s location and capacity.
“How can we advise if we don't even know the what, where or when?” he said.
People living outdoors are at risk at temperatures above 26, he said. The National Coalition for the Homeless has found that 700 people experiencing or at risk of homelessness die from hypothermia each year in the United States.
“If these people can't get into [the Second Avenue Commons] shelter, we're going to have people with hypothermia going to the emergency shelter,” he said. “The fact that it's not open prior to emergency weather means you're having people walk into an emergency. Are we trying to solve the problem or fix it afterward?”
Mr. Evans said he believes officials shouldn’t just look at air temperatures alone. Other aspects of the weather, such as wind and precipitation, lower the perceived temperature and cause the body to lose heat more quickly. That’s why Mr. Evans said he would have liked to see the emergency shelter open at 32 degrees in snowy, windy or icy conditions and 30 degrees if it’s cold but clear.
People experiencing homelessness are three to six times more likely to become ill than housed people, and the risk of developing hypothermia grows substantially with the use of alcohol, nicotine, drugs and some medications. With county officials deciding not to reopen a long-running winter shelter on Smithfield Street this year, Mr. Evans said Pittsburgh and Allegheny County aren’t meeting the needs of a growing homeless population during a vulnerable time.
“We’re making a plan for winter, and it's already winter,” he said. “We don't have the hygiene solutions. We don't have toilets. We don't have showers. We don't even have a warm place for people to go.”
DHS has reiterated that its shelters will be open 24 hours a day during a Code Blue event, and the county encourages people to go to Second Avenue Commons first, where they can get rides to the emergency shelter. The county says it is continuing to work on adding new overflow shelter beds and “expanding safe places to access care” during the winter.
In the meantime, Mr. Evans said, the hospital system will bear the burden when people have nowhere else to turn. In general, studies show that people experiencing homelessness often use the hospital emergency department as their only source of health care.
“We're legitimately putting people's lives in danger,” he said. “It's not an emergency plan if going to the emergency room is a better option.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.