Meadowcroft Rockshelter sediment to be tested for human DNA from early inhabitants
Arguably the oldest known site of human habitation in North America, Meadowcroft Rockshelter in westernmost Washington County keeps offering new discoveries with each advance in science.
A researcher now is trying to recover human DNA from sediment samples he’s collecting from the “deep hole” — the deepest portion of the archaeological excavation at the now famous rock shelter.
The Meadowcroft Rockshelter and Historic Village in Jefferson Township, near the West Virginia border, is open to tourists seasonally and operated in association with the Heinz History Center.
“There will, for certain, be DNA,” said Devlin Gandy, a Ph.D. candidate in archeogenetics at St. John’s College, University of Cambridge in England. “But it could be bacterial, fungal or from recent contaminants.”
There also could be strands of mammal DNA.
Most intriguing would be recovery of ancient strands of DNA from the human portion of the genome. If so, it would allow researchers to look for genetic similarities with DNA samples from other archaeological excavations throughout the Americas and help identify the origins of the humans who lived in or used the rock shelter many thousands of years ago.
“Remember, we share most of our DNA with other animals and a very small percent of our DNA is unique to humans,” Mr. Gandy said. “Any DNA information will be useful. My emphasis here is to look more at the feasibility of this.
“We may not detect [human DNA] but that doesn’t mean it’s not there,” he added.
Any DNA samples he recovers will be processed at the Center for Geogenetics in Copenhagen, where Mr. Gandy studies under noted evolutionary geneticst Eske Willerslev.
Genetic analysis could add to the vast discoveries from the Meadowcroft Rockshelter, a National Historic Landmark, which changed views about the most ancient humans in North America and how fast they migrated across the continent. DNA evidence even could help determine a more exact age of the earliest humans to inhabit the rock shelter, Meadowcroft researchers say.
Whatever DNA is discovered, “we will be able to process it and determine what is readable and identify it through reference libraries,” Mr. Gandy said.
James Adovasio, at the time a University of Pittsburgh archaeologist, led the rock shelter archaeological excavation from 1973 through 1978 and recently joined the Meadowcroft staff as director of archaeology. “In his role he will promote archaeological investigation, research, and publication, which furthers our understanding of the people of North America,” according to a Heinz History Center news release.
The elevated area where the dig was done features an area sheltered by a large rock overhang. The entire site overlooks Cross Creek. Archaeological finds revealed the site served as a seasonal campsite for Paleo Indians beginning sometime between 16,000 to 19,000 years ago.
Surrounding controversy
The exact date remains unclear and even is controversial among archaeologists with differing analyses of carbon dating.
“We have tried to stress,” Mr. Adovasio said, “that archaeology is not supposed to be a static field but fluent enough to absorb new information from technologies and methodologies. In this case we are borrowing technology from genetics and trying to use it to answer new questions about the earliest human use of such locations as Meadowcroft.”
He said it’s impossible for the very first North American humans to have camped at the rock shelter, because it’s inland. But there’s strong evidence that the Paleo Indians at Meadowcroft existed long before humans inhabited Clovis, N.M., the 12,500-year-old site long regarded as the continent’s earliest human settlement.
“But we always maintained that this is the longest series of episodic visits in the New World,” Mr. Adovasio said in a previous interview. “People have been coming off and on to the rock shelter for 16,000 years. But we try to stay away from the question of whether or not it’s the oldest.”
Mr. Gandy’s work, he said, “is an example of one technological development that holds potential to enlighten us about earlier use of this site, rather than what tools were used and what animals were eating — but about the humans here and human beings at large.”
In 1955, Albert Miller, the brother of harness-racing legend Delvin Miller, found a flint knife on their family farm by digging up a fresh groundhog hole near the rock shelter. Eighteen years later, Mr. Adovasio thought the rock shelter would serve as a good field site for archaeology students, with few other expectations.
But discoveries from meticulous digging 6 to 8 feet deep into the rock-shelter floor, often with razor blades, produced charcoal, bones and other remains extending back 16,000 years — more than 3,000 years earlier than Clovis discoveries, and potentially even earlier. Results sparked disbelief and claims the dates were skewed backward by coal-dust contamination. But it also spawned new theories about how prehistoric people populated North America.
Other East Coast digs now have found similarly aged remains, adding to acceptance of Meadowcroft as one of the earliest if not the earliest Paleo Indian sites on the continent. The fact that the Smithsonian Institute did the radiocarbon dating added confidence that the Meadowcroft timeline is accurate.
"There's not a site that's engaged more vitriolic debate — been more of a lightning rod — than Meadowcroft," Mr. Adovasio said in a previous interview.
David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578. Twitter: @templetoons.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.