In October 1935, roughly six weeks after a devastating hurricane laid waste to the Florida Keys, a group of frustrated chamber of commerce executives from the storm-battered Florida cities of Miami, Fort Lauderdale and Hollywood got together to figure out what could be done about storms that mercilessly pounded the state’s coast every fall, threatening the burgeoning tourist economy.
The solution they landed on was a novel one, and, conveniently, it didn’t require anyone to move out of harm’s way. Instead, the executives suggested, the government should simply try bombing hurricanes before they got to Florida.
“These storms are not only local menaces,” reasoned Clyde Elliot, the secretary of the Hollywood, Florida, Chamber of Commerce. “They reach Newfoundland frequently before they disburse, hence this control is really of national importance.”
While their proposal didn’t gain any traction, it wasn’t the last time the idea would come up. On Sunday night, Axios reported that President Donald Trump has repeatedly urged senior Homeland Security and national security officials to explore the possibility of using nuclear bombs to weaken hurricanes before they reach the United States, which would make him the latest in a long line of politicians (and coastal property owners in Florida) who have suggested fighting storms with military force.
Early Monday, Mr. Trump denied ever pushing for the use of nuclear bombs against hurricanes, tweeting that the Axios story “that President Trump wanted to blow up large hurricanes with nuclear weapons prior to reaching shore is ridiculous” and “Just more FAKE NEWS!”
Axios quoted White House aides as saying that in the months after he took office, Mr. Trump proposed using nuclear weapons to push major hurricanes away from the mainland shore.
"I got it, I got it — why don't we nuke them?" Mr. Trump asked during an official White House hurricane briefing, the news web site Axios reported. “They start forming off the coast of Africa, as they’re moving across the Atlantic, we drop a bomb inside the eye of the hurricane and it disrupts it. Why can’t we do that?”
Mr. Trump raised the issue a second time in a conversation that was noted in a National Security Council memo, the news site said.
In a response to Mr. Trump's denial, Axios journalist Jonathan Swan said he "stands by every word in the story."
For its part, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration explains that it's quite possible that dropping a nuclear weapon would have no effect on the storm whatsoever, and, even more pressingly, that the storm’s winds would carry radioactive fallout to land.
Regardless of Mr. Trump’s feelings on the subject, the idea of hurling bombs in the path of incoming storms was once given serious consideration. Just weeks after the U.S. dropped the first atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945, Floridians started wondering if the same destructive force that had ushered in the end of World War II could also be leveraged to protect beachfront property. Herbert Frink, the mayor of Miami Beach, wrote a letter to President Harry S. Truman urging him to look into it, while members of the Lee County Commission in southwest Florida voted to offer the government a 7,500-acre tract that could be used as a launchpad, historian Gary Mormino writes in “Land of Sunshine, State of Dreams: A Social History of Modern Florida.”
But scientists quickly poured cold water on the idea. The Florida officials had been encouraged by reports that when the atomic bomb was tested in the New Mexico desert, nearby storm clouds had disappeared. But one meteorologist pointed out that there was no evidence that those two events were connected. Another warned that dropping a bomb in the middle of a hurricane could potentially make the storm even worse.
Then, there was the fact that atomic bombs weren’t exactly easy to come by. When the question was raised again in 1950, not long after the Korean War broke out, Grady Norton, the chief forecaster for the U.S. Weather Bureau (now the National Weather Service) in Miami, cautioned that “this is no time to waste bombs on hurricanes.”
“The real problem facing us today,” he told the Fort Lauderdale News, “is not ways to eliminate hurricanes, but instead the job of educating people to take full precautionary measures when a storm occurs.”
That logic evidently fell on deaf ears, because the advent of nuclear weapons prompted a new round of speculation by the end of the decade. Though the atomic bomb killed hundreds of thousands of people in Japan, the amount of energy it yielded was negligible compared to a mature hurricane, Jack Reed, a meteorologist at Sandia National Laboratory, explained in a 1959 paper. Nuclear weapons didn’t come close, either, he wrote, but a massive amount of air was lofted skyward when the hydrogen bomb was tested. If a submarine were to lob a nuclear missile at the eye of a hurricane, he theorized, the warm air fueling the storm would be lifted into the stratosphere. The hurricane might not come to an immediate stop, but at least it could be weakened or slowed.
This time, government officials appeared to take the idea into consideration. During a 1961 speech at the National Press Club, Francis Reichelderfer, the head of the U.S. Weather Bureau, revealed that the agency planned to study whether bombing a hurricane would stop it in its tracks. Asked specifically about nuclear weapons, the meteorologist replied that they “might do something to a hurricane, but he wasn’t sure if it would be good or bad,” The Associated Press reported. It wasn’t unthinkable that someday, the agency would hurl a nuclear bomb at a storm while it was still far from land, he said, but there were some major obstacles. Tests would cost millions of dollars, and the government needed to learn more about the potential side effects first.
Needless to say, those concerns won out. The FAQ section of National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s website now includes an explainer about why nuking a tropical storm before it develops a hurricane is “not a good idea.”
"During each hurricane season, there always appear suggestions that one should simply use nuclear weapons to try and destroy the storms," meteorologist Chris Landsea writes on that page. "Apart from the fact that this might not even alter the storm, this approach neglects the problem that the released radioactive fallout would fairly quickly move with the tradewinds to affect land areas and cause devastating environmental problems."
The NOAA continues: "The main difficulty with using explosives to modify hurricanes is the amount of energy required. A fully developed hurricane can release heat energy at a rate of [50 to 200 trillion] watts and converts less than 10% of the heat into the mechanical energy of the wind. The heat release is equivalent to a 10-megaton nuclear bomb exploding every 20 minutes. According to the 1993 World Almanac, the entire human race used energy at a rate of [10 trillion] watts in 1990, a rate less than 20% of the power of a hurricane."
It also says even a large, powerful nuclear bomb would not be strong enough to raise the barometric pressure of a hurricane. Hurricanes get stronger as their pressure drops, and weaker as their pressure rises.
And, as National Geographic previously pointed out, doing so would mean running afoul of the Peaceful Nuclear Explosions Treaty, which the United States and the former Soviet Union ratified in 1990.
But like clockwork, the question seems to resurface every few years. In 2004, during a particularly deadly hurricane season, Mary Aiken, an elected member of the Hernando County, Fla., commission, called on NASA to find a way to stop the storms before they could reach Florida, and likened Mother Nature to a terrorist.
“These storms infuriate me,” she said, according to the Tampa Bay Times. “There must be something that can be done. It’s like a war. This state looks like Iraq.”
Informed by the county attorney that government scientists had researched that question before, only to realize that they ran the risk of combining a hurricane’s powerful wallop with deadly nuclear fallout, Ms. Aiken wasn’t satisfied. The agency, she declared, simply hadn’t been trying hard enough.
Sun Sentinel, syracuse.com, New York Daily News and nj.com contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.