One month ago, a crowd of golfers, family and friends of the late mayor Bob O'Connor announced to Pittsburgh that the course was now, officially, the Bob O'Connor Golf Course.
Each City Council member read a chapter from the history of the course, which was established in the 1880s and is, as of this year, managed by First Tee of Pittsburgh, a nonprofit group that promotes golf to build character in young people.
As I watched the ceremony, I recalled my own association with the course -- though not as a golfer -- and the role played by the late Herb Simon, my colleague at Carnegie Mellon University. The details of our story were not told that day, but I think they have a place in the course's history, if not the city's.
Herb Simon, who died in 2001, was well known for his 1978 Nobel Prize in economics. He was also the father of artificial intelligence in computer science. Like many great thinkers, he liked to walk. For 40 years, he lived on Northumberland Street and regularly walked through the Schenley Golf Course and onto Frew Street to his campus office.
I arrived in Pittsburgh in 1981 from England to become a professor of mechanical engineering at Carnegie Mellon. We purchased a home at the corner of Northumberland and Gladstone, next to the Pittsburgh Golf Club. For 26 years I walked daily in every condition of weather through the golf course to my campus office.
When Sophie Masloff was mayor in the early 1990s, she decided that the city was incapable of managing and making a profit from the city's aviary, conservatory and golf course. She was determined to have all three assets sold and privatized.
In 1992, a private group of Pittsburghers drafted plans to convert the Schenley course into an urban country club with a nine-hole course, an expensive restaurant and a lighted driving range.
Public hearings were held. At one, I asked if the working folk who regularly walk through the golf course would be able to continue their pleasant and convenient short cut. The answer was emphatic: "Absolutely not! Only golfers may walk on a golf course."
Herb and I agreed that something had to be done to prevent this privatization.
At the hearing of the City Council, some 100 protesters and banners made our presence felt. A diverse group of senior citizens from all religions and races, rich and poor, testified that privatization of the golf course would effectively remove an important exercise and social outlet.
A direct descendant of Mary Schenley, who lived on Northumberland facing the course, read aloud the deed of Mary Schenley, which clearly states that Schenley Park, including the golf course, was her gift to the "people" of the city forever.
However, Mayor Masloff was determined to proceed with privatization.
I called Sophie's office and asked her to meet with Herb and me. She agreed -- at the same time assuring us that nothing would change her mind.
I asked Herb to bring a copy of his autobiography. From it he read to Sophie the inspiration he found in his daily walk through the course. He also mentioned that he had served as an economic adviser to Milwaukee, his hometown, and that city had realized a surplus.
"We have never managed that in Pittsburgh," Sophie said.
Herb and I decided to approach Robert Mehrabian, then president of Carnegie Mellon. We stressed the disadvantages of privatization: students would no longer have access to the golf course (but they might be able to drink at the proposed clubhouse). The driving ranges would bring more traffic to further aggravate the university's parking problems. Countless residents (not to mention me and Herb) would be forced onto the busy roadway for our walk. CMU, we thought, should seek to acquire the golf course.
Dr. Mehrabian had a problem: Before he arrived in 1990, the university had planned to house him in a substantial property in Sewickley Heights, with room for the horses that his equestrian wife maintained. The proposed purchase of a multimillion-dollar presidential estate was leaked and there was a hue and cry. The board of trustees canceled the purchase. Dr. Mehrabian ended up buying a more modest horse-friendly place near Butler.
He did not relish another accusation that CMU proposed to purchase a property outside its educational mission.
Eventually we proposed that Carnegie Mellon take over management of the golf course -- without payment or any transfer of funds involved. That idea took hold.
The private group's proposal, meanwhile, became a huge political battlefield throughout 1992 and 1993. In April 1993, after much fracas, the city agreed to lease the course for $1 a year to Carnegie Mellon.
The university set up a nonprofit subsidiary to run the course. A surplus was realized from the fees, which paid the golf pro and provided further improvements. No CMU funds were used to support the course.
•
As I walked home through the golf course on the day the agreement was announced, I was welcomed with a resounding cheer from smiling golfers, as one of the "liberators" of Schenley Park Golf Course.
I had met Bob O'Connor on several occasions, to plot our campaign against privatization, at breakfasts in the Eat 'n Park on Murray. Afterwards, I would chat with him as I walked through the course when he was teeing off with friends.
I'm sure that his soul rests in peace in heaven.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.