A decade after Donald Trump upended the Republican Party by attacking the GOP establishment in his first presidential campaign, the political outsiders he mobilized are continuing to fight their own leaders in a battle for future control of the conservative movement.
Nowhere in Pennsylvania has that battle been fought harder than in a solidly Republican state Senate district southwest of Pittsburgh where a longtime leader of the GOP in the General Assembly is embroiled in what has become the most expensive legislative primary in the state this year — and possibly ever.
In all, more than $2.7 million has been poured into the race, mostly by outside groups paying for ads that have bombarded voters for months as Sen. Camera Bartolotta battles a challenge from Al Buchtan, a businessman and former bricklayer who has won the support of local GOP organizations.
It’s a fight that would have been almost unthinkable a decade ago.
Bartolotta, 62, has the support of the state’s top Republicans, including U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick and Treasurer Stacy Garrity, the party’s likely nominee for governor. The state senator also claims a 98% lifetime rating from the Pennsylvania Chamber of Commerce and endorsements from the NRA and Gun Owners of America.
Buchtan, a former Carmichaels Area School Board member, has tried to turn that institutional support against her, echoing Trump’s tactics against his opponents in the 2016 election.
Read More
“[Bartolotta] is the establishment,” Buchtan, 58, told the Post-Gazette. “She is the swamp.”
The catalyzing moment in the race for the state Senate’s 46th District traces back to the final months of then-candidate Trump’s 2024 campaign, when he singled out a town in Bartolotta’s district, Charleroi, claiming its Haitian immigrant population had left the borough on the banks of the Monongahela River “virtually bankrupt.”
Bartolotta came to the defense of immigrants in the borough who had suddenly been thrust into the national spotlight. Charleroi’s Haitian community, she said, was paying taxes, starting businesses and working legally.
She also said the majority of Charleroi’s immigrants with work visas had been doctors, teachers, engineers, electricians and other professionals in their home country.
Her defense of the residents came as Trump campaigned on the promise of launching a historic deportation effort and seeking to portray immigrants as dangerous and drains on society.
For some in the district — a conservative swath of the state that encompasses Greene and Washington counties, and a portion of Beaver County — it was a betrayal of the man who has been the main unifying force in the Republican Party for 10 years.

“Basically, she criticized Trump in the middle of his re-election, supporting the immigration of the Haitians in Charleroi,” said Steve Renz, chair of the Washington County Republican Committee, which is supporting Buchtan.
Buchtan seized on the comments, which he said showed his opponent does not align with her party.
“For her to say they were all doctors and lawyers and such, and then call my president a liar when he spoke out about it, shows where her loyalty is to the Republican Party,” Buchtan said.
Bartolotta has pushed back by pointing to her history of being a reliable advocate for conservative causes in the state Legislature.
“I’m running on my record of what I’ve already done, and thankfully there are thousands of people who understand that and are supportive of me,” she said.
A GOP divide
The last time Bartolotta faced a Democrat, eight years ago in a midterm election in which Republicans lost seats across the country, she trounced her opponent with nearly 60% of the vote. Four years later, Democrats didn't bother to run a candidate against her.
But this year, as she faces a challenge not from the left but from her right, the campaign has turned into an early test of how far loyalty to Trump still shapes the party as the term-limited president enters his final years in office.
The race is emblematic of a rift in the GOP — highlighted by growing complaints over Trump’s decision to attack Iran, including from influential conservatives such as Tucker Carlson, one of the country’s most prominent media figures, and former Fox News host Megyn Kelly.
But even as some factions of Trump’s coalition have split with him over the war and the spike in inflation that has followed, his grip on core Republican voters led to the ouster of five state senators in Indiana who defied the president’s demand to redraw the state's legislative districts ahead of the midterm elections.
In Pennsylvania, Bartolotta’s fight against Buchtan has pitted state and local GOP groups against each other.
After Bartolotta’s defense of the immigrants in Charleroi, the Washington County Republican Party executive committee issued a vote of no confidence in the senator by a margin of 21-3 — an extraordinary rebuke of one of the county’s most prominent elected officials and a signal that they would back a challenger.
In announcing the vote in mid-January, the group claimed that Bartolotta “undermined President Trump in the middle of his reelection campaign.”
The state party fired back.
Its chairman, Greg Rothman — who serves in the Senate with Bartolotta — declared the no-confidence vote null and void and accused the county party of violating its own rules to attack a sitting lawmaker in their own party.
Then, in April, the state GOP went after Buchtan, who is also running to be a member of the state party’s governing committee.
The party asked the Washington County Board of Elections to remove Buchtan from the ballot in the committee race after a state judge ruled Buchtan’s residence is in Greene County, not Washington County, a decision affirmed by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.
Buchtan was ultimately removed from Washington County’s voter rolls, meaning he would be unable to cast a vote for himself in that race, but election officials allowed him to remain on the ballots.
For Buchtan, the intraparty battle — pitting him and Washington County Republicans against the state party and a three-term incumbent — highlights his message that he’s a political outsider.
“It definitely benefits me because it's political cannibalism,” he said. “That’s what you’re seeing right now on the Republican side. They want to take care of their own. They’re swamp creatures.”
Gambling money fuels attack ads
As the race to be the Republican nominee for the state Senate district heated up in recent months, an unprecedented amount of money poured in.
Win for PA — a political action committee funded by online gambling giants including DraftKings, Fanduel, and Fanatics — has spent at least $1.5 million on ads favoring Bartolotta, according to the political ad-tracking firm AdImpact.
That’s in addition to the $512,000 spent by Bartolotta’s campaign.
At the same time, Citizens Alliance of Pennsylvania — a group backed by Georgia-based skill games operator Pace-O-Matic — spent more than $680,000 on ads for Buchtan.
“I don’t know what the record is, but I can’t imagine there ever has been this much money spent on a state Senate race,” Renz said.
Citizens Alliance has paid for all of Buchtan’s television advertising, according to AdImpact.
“My opponent isn’t Al Buchtan, it’s Pace-O-Matic” Bartolotta said. “The skill games conglomerate has been pumping out negative garbage for months, not just in my race but in other Republican state Senate races across the Commonwealth because we sit on positions on committees that could vote to tax or regulate skill games.”
Buchtan, who was also represented by a Pace-O-Matic attorney in his legal battle to remain on the ballot, denied having ties to the gaming company.
“I have no relationship with Pace-O-Matic,” he said. “The relationship would be through my consultants and advisers. … The people that are helping me with my campaign finance are the Citizens Alliance. Wherever they get their funds, you’d have to ask them.”
The ads themselves focus not on the policy goals of the gaming companies that are paying for them, but on attacking opponents for being insufficiently loyal to the party — and Trump in particular.
In one, Citizens Alliance says Bartolotta “betrayed taxpayers, betrayed Trump, betrayed Republicans.”
In another, Win for Pennsylvania says Buchtan is “bought and paid for by a liberal anti-Trump union,” and that he’s “no friend of President Trump.”
As the president’s shadow continues to loom over the primary, it illustrates the dramatic shift that has taken place within the GOP over the past decade, said Christopher Borick, a political scientist and director of Muhlenberg College’s Institute of Public Opinion.
“It is more about a referendum on who’s closer to the Republican Party that’s been made in the image of Donald Trump,” he said. “Especially in that corner of Pennsylvania where President Trump remains popular and where voters had supported him overwhelmingly in three elections.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.