State Attorney General Dave Sunday defended allowing Gov. Josh Shapiro take the helm of lawsuits against the Trump administration, pointing Monday to the commonwealth’s unique division of powers and suggesting that the work may be better to lawyers under the governor’s control.
Mr. Sunday’s remarks, made at a House budget hearing, raises an issue that is evident to anyone who has read the first page of dozens of recent lawsuits.
In group filings against President Donald Trump’s administration, the vast majority of plaintiff states are represented by their attorneys general. Pennsylvania, however, is joined to suits by Mr. Shapiro, not Mr. Sunday.
“There’s no other state in the country that has a Republican attorney general, a Democrat governor, and a divided legislature,” Mr. Sunday said when questioned by House members on Monday. That situation is “unique” but “can also be a strength,” he added.
Mr. Sunday’s comments this week were his most extensive on the issue since he took office a little over a year ago. A Republican, Sunday’s predecessor as attorney general was Mr. Shapiro, a Democrat, who famously took Trump to court on a near-constant basis during the president’s first term.
Speaking shortly after Mr. Sunday was sworn in, Mr. Shapiro had declined to opine on whether the new attorney general would or should pursue litigation against Trump. But within a few weeks it was clear that the governor would be taking the lead on the matter, with attorneys from the Office of the General Counsel (OGC) — which is under the control of the governor — filing suits against Trump over a laundry list of federal funds Trump had attempted to rescind.
At Monday’s hearing, House Democrats pressed Mr. Sunday as to why he had spent the past year abdicating what they considered to be his responsibility to pursue litigation against the federal government, and instead foisted the job onto the OGC.
“We took a lot of time to dive into this and figure what is the right way to handle all of this,” Mr. Sunday responded, noting that, in most states, the OGC would be under the purview of the attorney general and not a separate executive agency.
Both his office and the OGC have hundreds of attorneys at their disposal, Mr. Sunday said, but their capabilities don’t always overlap. His office received 541 referrals last year from the OGC for potential legal action, Mr. Sunday said, and pursued 465 of those, with remainder in part being proposed actions against the federal government that Shapiro ended up pursuing unilaterally.
“There are some things that the OGC can do that we also can do, but there are tons of things that I do that they can’t do,” Mr. Sunday said, and “everything that we say ‘yes’ to means we say ‘no’ to something else.”
Pennsylvania statute requires the attorney general to defend the commonwealth’s laws, but also provides that the governor can request to supersede the attorney general in order to defend an executive agency, or bring suit on behalf of one.
“The Commonwealth Attorneys Act gives the governor the right to bring cases when he deems that necessary,” Mr. Sunday said. While his office has pursued many OGC referrals, “there were other cases that were delegated to the governor at the governor’s request, because the governor wanted to bring those cases, which he has a legal right to do,” Mr. Sunday said.
But Mr. Sunday hasn’t always let Mr. Shapiro take charge on issues of partisan sensitivity. As state Rep. Emily Kinkead, D-Allegheny County, pointed out, Mr. Sunday has been involved in defending Pennsylvania’s longstanding prohibition on Medicaid funding being used for abortion-relation health care.
A suit against this statute was brought by several providers affiliated with Planned Parenthood, and Mr. Shapiro declined to defend the law, with Mr. Sunday’s office stepping in last year to argue in favor of the ban.
But this is simply part of his job description, Mr. Sunday said, regardless of how he personally feels about the abortion funding rules.
“We will follow the law, we will defend every statute that is passed by this body whether I like it, I don’t like it, I’m indifferent to it,” Mr. Sunday told Ms. Kinkead. “We are going to defend each statute that is passed by this body, signed by the governor, and has not been ruled unconstitutional yet.”
Through whatever legal means, the result has been a clear division of labor over the past year, with Mr. Sunday representing the commonwealth when the argument involved appeals to conservatives, and Mr. Shapiro when it appeals to liberals.
Challenged by state Rep. Ben Waxman, D-Philadelphia, to name an instance in which he has challenged an illegal action by the Trump administration, Mr. Sunday did not answer directly, but sought to reassure House members that he wasn’t afraid to stand up to Trump or Congressional Republicans.
Mr. Sunday pointed to his office going after AI companies using a new state law on AI-generated images of sexual abuse, despite the fact that Trump and Congressional Republicans have sought to pre-empt states’ abilities to take such actions.
“We chose to be the leader and chose to stick our you-know-what out there because it was the right thing to do,” Mr. Sunday said, even though “actions like that may not have been looked upon in a manner that was what would be positive from the federal government.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.