HARRISBURG — When voters go to the polls Tuesday for a pair of special elections — including one in Allegheny County — it will ring the opening bell of a high-stakes election year for the Pennsylvania General Assembly. Control of both chambers could be in play, as well as the fate of weighty issues such as marijuana legalization and skill games regulation.
Democrat Jen Mazzocco and Republican Joseph Leckenby will face off for the South Hills’ 42nd House District seat left vacant by the recent resignation of Democratic Rep. Dan Miller, who was elected to a county judgeship.
On the other side of the state, a special election in the 22nd House District that includes part of Allentown — a seat left open by the resignation of former Democratic Rep. Josh Siegel — will pit Democrat Ana T. Tiburcio against Republican Robert E. Smith Jr.
Democrats are in a bit of a precarious position. The party holds a two-seat majority in the House, with a count of 100-98, and five seats are open because of resignations. Republicans control the Senate by a 27-23 margin.
But Democrats are fired up after strong showings in the November election and there is even some talk in the party of taking control of both chambers. This year, all 203 state House seats are up for election along with half the 50 state Senate seats.
Allegheny County Democratic Chairwoman Kate Garfinkel said she couldn’t speak to the statewide picture, but within the county, “I just see people engaged, people hungry for information.”
Read More
Both special elections Tuesday will occur in districts with a strong Democratic lean. In the 42nd, Democrats have nearly 26,000 registered voters vs. fewer than 15,000 Republicans, while in the 22nd there are nearly 17,000 registered Democrats and fewer than 7,000 Republicans.
But the coming months will bring still more chances for the parties to improve their positioning.
Three more special elections will be held in March and May, adding up to a total of five this year after 13 in the previous three years.
And in November, the traditional midterm election cycle in 2026 will have voters coming out to decide hundreds of federal, state, and county-level positions,
Replacing Dan Miller in the 42nd
In the 42nd House District race, Ms. Mazzocco, 41, has been a teacher for about 15 years has been elected to Dormont Borough Council three times. She currently is president of the council. Mr. Leckenby, 27, and an attorney, lives in Mt. Lebanon, recently graduated from law school, and ran unsuccessfully against Mr. Miller in 2024.
Despite the Democratic registration advantage, Ms. Mazzocco said she is taking nothing for granted, having personally knocked on 1,300 doors. Mr. Leckenby, meanwhile, will have the benefit of name recognition as a result of his unsuccessful run against Mr. Miller in 2024.
“Joe is a resilient, tough young man. He’s got some experience and he is going to give it his best,” said Jason Richey, the Allegheny County Republican chairman who is a candidate this year for lieutenant governor.
Ms. Garfinkel called Ms. Mazzocco a “great candidate” and saw no reason to expect anything much different than Mr. Miller’s defeat of Mr. Leckenby by 2-to-1 margin.
There is at least one significant issue that both candidates said they’ve heard about from 42nd district voters and that the state Legislature can influence. It is what Ms. Mazzocco referred to as “affordability” and what Mr. Leckenby referred to when he said “people will vote their pocketbooks.”
Separately, both have been hearing about Immigration and Customs Enforcement controversies, as stepped up immigration enforcement across the region and the country has drawn attention under the Trump administration. Because ICE is a federal agency, state lawmakers have limited ability to influence the debate, but the issue is on the candidates’ radar.
Ms. Mazzocco said people have brought up ICE in her discussions and many are worried about what they are seeing across the country. Friends of hers, she said, work in rapid response groups — organizations that generally seek to document ICE activities. She has heard from people who “don’t want to see their neighbors taken off the streets.”
Mr. Leckenby described himself as a believer in a secure border. He said he disagrees with what Ms. Mazzocco has said publicly concerning law enforcement and ICE.
“I understand people are very angry about it on both sides,” Mr. Leckenby said. “I am different because I am not a quick-to-judge individual.”
The 42nd encompasses Baldwin Township and Mt. Lebanon and part of Upper St. Clair, as well as Castle Shannon and Dormont.
Mr. Miller was first elected in a 2013 special election, then re-elected six times. He eventually held the prominent roles of House Democratic Caucus chairman and House Democratic whip.
His prominence makes it that much more important, Ms. Mazzocco said, to carry out her campaign in a way “to make sure I talked to as many people as I could.”
Because of her profession, Ms. Mazzocco said she cares a lot about how education is handled in Harrisburg. “In a dream world I would love to work on some sort of universal pre-K (legislation),” said the mother of two.
Affordability is another key issue, in terms of utilities, health care and education, she said.
In 2024, Mr. Leckenby lost to Mr. Miller by a tally of 26,932 to 13,436. He frames the challenge that year as one of facing an opponent who is “a household name.”
His stances include opposing taxes on Social Security and military pensions, and declares himself a big fan of recent moves to ban cellphone use by students in schools.
Beyond that, he said he believes he could function well with a bipartisan mindset. “I am a person who values the ability to listen,” he said. “When people are overly partisan, that is when things stall.”
So many special elections
After the five special elections in 2026 — barring any more resignations — the state will end the year having held 18 special elections in four years.
While the process is long-established, it is not without critics.
Some complain about the cost. A Post-Gazette review found that in 2023 alone, the state had to reimburse counties nearly $1 million for holding special elections.
Rep. Chris Rabb, D-Philadelphia, strongly dislikes that candidates for special elections typically are chosen by county-level political organizations.
“The process is not transparent, democratic or inclusive,” said Mr. Rabb. Following the private selection step, Mr. Rabb said, the special election often produces little turnout from the voting public.
The winner then becomes an incumbent in the next regular election and, in Mr. Rabb’s words, “Incumbency is the most significant factor for viability.”
Mr. Rabb has introduced a bill several times that would make changes to the special election process. The last version, introduced during the 2023-24 session, died in the House State Government Committee.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.