Pennsylvania in 2026 is home to one of 36 governor's races that will help shape state leadership, elections and policy across the country in the years to come.
With the popular Gov. Josh Shapiro likely facing state Treasurer Stacy Garrity — who upset a better-funded incumbent as a newcomer in 2020 — the biggest battleground state is again under the spotlight. Poised to be one of the most high-profile and costly of three dozen gubernatorial races, Pennsylvania's fight over the top seat in Harrisburg comes as control of Congress is on the line in midterm elections, and with President Donald Trump aiming to plow through any roadblocks to his agenda.
It also comes with Mr. Shapiro among the Democratic governors in the mix of potential contenders for the White House in two years.
"There is intense energy around the '26 governor's races," Lew Irwin, a political scientist at Duquesne University, told the Post-Gazette. "Democrats understand full well how the governors' races ... will affect the administration of the federal elections — including the presidential race — in 2028. So both sides are pulling out all of the stops to prevent the other side from gaining 'trifectas' [governor's seats and both chambers of state legislatures] wherever they can.”
Democrats are "late to the party," Mr. Irwin said. For several years, they “failed to take these down ballot races seriously,” while Republicans “focused a great deal of energy and resources” on taking state houses, leading to control over redistricting and voting procedures, he said.
Ms. Garrity, a Trump ally who beat Mr. Shapiro's record for most votes cast for a statewide candidate in 2024, hopes to stand in the governor's way.
Backed by the state GOP and several prominent Pennsylvania Republicans, Ms. Garrity picked up an endorsement last week from Maggie's List, the national PAC pushing to get more conservative women elected.
Ms. Garrity and other swing state Republicans expect to receive a boost from campaign stops this year by figures such as Vice President JD Vance and Trump, who both rallied in Eastern Pennsylvania last month to re-energize the administration's economic message.
“It’s going to be one of the most-watched and most interesting races in the country,” said John Brabender, a media consultant for Ms. Garrity and a handful of other gubernatorial candidates this year. “If we effectively do our job, [Shapiro] will have to spend a lot more than he's anticipating.”
Democratic governors and state house hopefuls seek to build off sweeping wins in November, and capitalize on continued angst over high prices and Trump's dramatic overhaul of Washington — both of which he campaigned on.
Like Trump, Ms. Garrity — who criticized the bipartisan budget signed by Mr. Shapiro in November after a four-month stalemate — paints a very different picture of the state than the governor, who frequently notes that the economy is growing unlike in other Northeastern states.
"Either we stand up right now and change course, or we let Josh Shapiro and the Democrats drive Pennsylvania straight into higher taxes, fewer jobs and a bankrupt future," she said on X this week.
During Mr. Vance's visit, Mr. Shapiro didn't name Ms. Garrity in comments to reporters, but he suggested that Pennsylvanians won't be fooled by the Republican administration's celebrations of an economy that features "rising prices, health care cuts and chaotic trade wars." He also celebrated that the state budget cut taxes for many Pennsylvanians while making investments in education, public safety, health care and more.
‘Launching pads’
One of Ms. Garrity’s most frequent knocks on Mr. Shapiro is that he’s distracted by a potential 2028 presidential run. He has not ruled out a White House bid, but says he's focused on getting things done in Pennsylvania.
”He’s really running for two offices at once,” Mr. Brabender said. “That’s always a dangerous proposition for a candidate.”
The issue will be a refrain beyond the commonwealth.
It has dogged the 2026 re-election bids of at least Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker and Maryland Gov. Wes Moore. Republicans have also criticized Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear for his interest in a White House run, though he is not up for re-election this year.
"[Gubernatorial races] are often viewed as important launching pads for potential presidential runs to follow," Christopher Borick, a political scientist at Muhlenberg College, said. "If there is a midterm wave election against the president's party, the opposition party's governors can get a boost.”
For Mr. Shapiro, "The timing in this cycle may be very good," Mr. Borick said, "to double up on both securing re-election and building some momentum" for 2028.
Democrats showed strong momentum in the 2025 elections, holding a majority in the state Supreme Court and racking up unprecedented wins in Republican strongholds and counties Trump won in 2016, 2020 and 2024.
Mr. Shapiro campaigned for three state court justices and the winning governors in New Jersey and Virginia. He also donated $250,000 of his campaign funds to bolster Democratic infrastructure and outreach for the next few years. Observers say he'll continue to take an active role backing and raising funds for Democrats up and down the ballot in Pennsylvania and beyond.
Ms. Garrity, a retired U.S. Army Reserve colonel and businesswoman from Bradford County, is seen by experts and party officials on both sides as a stronger candidate than the man Mr. Shapiro beat in 2022, state Sen. Doug Mastriano.
Mr. Brabender said unlike Mr. Shapiro’s previous opponents, Ms. Garrity will have the resources to scrutinize and advertise what the campaign alleges is wasteful spending and a lack of transparency from the Shapiro administration.
The Garrity campaign also recently told the Post-Gazette that “the treasurer is looking forward to being a partner with President Trump, and not a courtroom opponent like Josh Shapiro.”
But the Pennsylvania Democratic Party is eager to link Ms. Garrity — and U.S. Reps. Brian Fitzpatrick, Scott Perry, Rob Bresnahan and Ryan Mackenzie — to a president whose approval rating slipped as 2025 came to a close.
"Candidates ... who have put loyalty to Trump ahead of the needs of Pennsylvania, have got to be incredibly worried," the PA Dems said in a memo after the November elections.
Mr. Shapiro, who fought the Trump administration in court when he was the state's attorney general, argues that the state's battles with the White House are a fight for Pennsylvania workers and families facing high prices and cuts to health care or food benefits.
The governor has also touted a bipartisan track record. And being in a purple state Trump narrowly won in 2024, he cannot afford to alienate too many independents and moderate Republicans, strategists in both parties say.
California Gov. Gavin Newsom — not up for re-election because he is term-limited — is even more vocal in his critique of Trump. He’s also the Democrat leading early 2028 presidential primary polls.
Mr. Shapiro averages just below 5% support in 2028 polls over the last five months, but his national profile continues to rise. He's made many national TV appearances and is releasing a memoir in late January, while he also spent much of the last six weeks touring the state highlighting the budget and its investment in communities.
‘Forces of nature’
Pennsylvania is one of five states that Trump won in 2024 where Democrats are defending governorships; the others are Michigan, Wisconsin, Arizona and Kansas. At least 10 U.S. House Republicans have decided to leave Washington to run for governor, and many states will feature primaries for both parties.
Republicans like Ms. Garrity face the traditional challenge of a potential midterm swing against the party in power in Washington, while being denied the historical benefit of Trump's name on the ballot.
For several years, GOP candidates in Pennsylvania have consistently under-performed when Trump is not directly in the mix — one of the reasons the White House midterm campaign mode kicked off in the Keystone State.
J.J. Balaban, a Philadelphia-based Democratic strategist and admaker, told the Post-Gazette that Trump and down-ballot Republicans face "political forces of nature."
"His opponents are angry and motivated, while his supporters are frustrated that the realities of governing are different than the poetry of campaigning," he said. "That’s in part what all of the attention to the Epstein Files is about ... it’s a simple example of how the Trump administration isn’t keeping its promises. Similarly, the president’s tariffs have raised prices instead of keeping his promise to lower them. Campaigning is a lot easier than governing."
Mr. Balaban said it's too soon to judge "whether Trump and his allies are able to turn around a very unfriendly political environment."
"So far, their efforts have consisted of trying to convince Americans that the economy is stronger than it actually is," he said. "That strategy didn’t work for the Biden Administration, but one shouldn’t underestimate Trump’s communications skills."
James Markley, the state GOP spokesman, recently told the Post-Gazette that Trump has “done nothing but deliver on many of the major themes of his campaign.”
The president has fortified the southern border, targeted deadly drugs, crime and safety, and, “he's doing everything he can to lower prices for working families,” Mr. Markley said.
Meanwhile, Ms. Garrity has an advantage some other gubernatorial challengers lack at this point: early support from her state party.
“From every corner of the commonwealth,” Mr. Markley said of her endorsement — even with Mr. Mastriano floating a primary challenge in recent months. “We've seen complete unity with Treasurer Garrity.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.