Americans have told pollsters for decades that the ideal family size includes about two-and-a-half children. Since 2018, the average has held at 2.7, according to Gallup.

But that’s at least one more kid than parents are having in both the country and Pennsylvania, with the average about 1.6 per woman according to state and national data — a record low for the U.S. in 2024.

“That tells me there are people who want to grow their families, but they’re not able to because there are structural barriers,” state Sen. Nick Pisciottano, D-West Mifflin, told the Post-Gazette. “Kids are expensive. If people know that not only they have to pay for formula and diapers and all the other things that come with children, but also they’re not going to get paid or lose their job in the immediate aftermath of having a child, I think that prevents people from having their first child or additional children.”

Mr. Pisciottano and state Sen. Amanda Cappelletti, a Montgomery County Democrat, plan to propose legislation guaranteeing paid parental leave to all Pennsylvanians early next year. 

Advertise with us

While there are broader bipartisan proposals on family and medical leave in the works, their initiative focuses on parents at a time when Pennsylvanians are having children later in life and fewer of them, and as affordability and declining birth rates are political flashpoints ahead of the 2026 midterm elections nationwide. 

“You need time to be able to support your family,” Mr. Pisciottano, whose wife recently had twins, said. “You can come at the issue from a moral, this is the right thing to do angle, or you can come at it from the policy angle: this is good for our people and if you want to attract folks to the state or keep them here, having these policies to support young families is good policy too. It’s something I believe Pennsylvania is lagging behind on and needs to catch up.”

Almost half the states in the country have “some flavor of leave law,” Mr. Pisciottano said, including a handful of states neighboring Pennsylvania. Some are straightforward mandates on employers, while others involve insurance programs and other structures. 

The Pennsylvania Chamber of Commerce and other business groups are following such proposals and advising businesses on what could be required for compliance. A message left with the chamber was not immediately responded to Tuesday.

Mr. Pisciottano’s and Ms. Cappelletti’s proposal is “purposely simple,” he said — a requirement for employers to provide paid parental leave for up to 12 weeks, but it includes a $20 million fund for grants to help small businesses recoup the costs. 

Advertise with us

He called the idea “the easiest way to expand benefits and make it universal rather than creating a state-run or private-run insurance program,” noting those can certainly work but are more complex.

The senator added that he understands some concerns about costs from the business community, but cited surveys showing such programs help parents and children, boost recruitment and lead to higher productivity and better mental health for workers.

While the paid parental leave proposal focuses on helping small businesses afford it, Mr. Pisciottano said “bigger companies such as Walmart are already complying in other states and paying into these programs or providing these themselves. They can handle this.”

A spokesperson for Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward told the Post-Gazette the senator would review the bill when it’s introduced.

The state currently relies on the federal Family and Medical Leave Act, which protects eligible employees from losing their jobs for up to 12 weeks to care for a baby, a seriously ill family member or to recover from illness.

Advertise with us

But that’s not enough support for families, according to the Women and Girls Foundation of Southwest Pennsylvania, the Restaurant Opportunities Center of Pennsylvania and several other groups who support the Family Care Act. 

With proposals in both the state House and Senate, the bipartisan Family Care Act would establish a paid family medical leave insurance fund in the state. It would let workers recover from illness or surgery, care for a sick loved one or new child not only with federal job protection from FMLA, but with the ability to earn a paycheck while they’re taking a break from work.

There are differences in the timeframes for coverage and the structures in the different chambers’ versions. A House version splits costs between employers and employees, while a Senate proposal from Sens. Devlin Robinson, R-Allegheny, and Maria Collett, D-Montgomery County, would fund the program through employee payroll deductions. 

Advocates say aging Pennsylvanians are a quickly growing population, with nursing home care costing taxpayers about $3.2 billion annually. They also say the proposed program lets small businesses offer the benefit to employees to better compete with larger companies. They also point to reduced infant mortality rates and reduced reliance on government benefits such as food stamps when paid parental leave is available.

“Enacting paid family leave in Pennsylvania will allow workers to take the time needed to care for aging parents, children or spouses without risking their job or financial stability,” said AARP Pennsylvania volunteer state president Nora Dowd Eisenhower, at a Fort Washington roundtable hosted by Ms. Collett in September.

Advertise with us

Republican Rep. Natalie Mihalek and Democratic Rep. Lindsay Powell of Allegheny County pushed for the House proposal earlier this year.

The state Chamber of Commerce urged lawmakers to oppose the House version in March. The group said it “assess a new multi-billion dollar payroll tax on Pennsylvania employers and workers to pay wage benefits for workers to take leave of as much as 20 weeks per year,” and could lead to automatic yearly tax increases without legislative input or approval.

“This legislation imposes direct and significant costs on Pennsylvanians and employers,” the chamber said in a memo. “[And] additional indirect costs and administrative challenges on employers, who would be prohibited from continuing their own leave policies that benefit their people while accommodating their own unique staffing requirements.”

The chamber at the time said it appreciated the intent of the bill, but that too many questions remain.

Gov. Josh Shapiro has expanded paid leave for state employees and is likely to support one of the measures in the works.

Advertise with us

“Governor Shapiro believes that no one should have to choose between taking care of their family or receiving a paycheck — that’s why he expanded paid parental leave benefits for commonwealth employees,” Kayla Anderson, a spokeswoman for the governor, told the Post-Gazette. “The Shapiro administration will continue to monitor these proposals as they move through the Legislature, and we look forward to working with the Legislature to improve paid parental leave in the commonwealth.”

Last year, a survey released by Small Business Majority, a national network of small businesses and community organizations, suggested that 78% of Pennsylvania small businesses would support a national paid family leave program funded by shared employer-employee contributions of 0.5% percent each.

“It’s better for all parties involved,” Mr. Pisciattano said of leave programs. “The baby, the mother, the family and the employer. There are different [versions] of this idea in red, blue and purple states, so why can’t we get this done in Pennsylvania?”