HARRISBURG — Coming on the heels of a hard-won budget deal for 2025-26, a nonpartisan numbers-crunching agency has issued its annual five-year forecast for Pennsylvania government’s financial future — and within it is a sea of red ink.
The outlook that includes a close-up on the General Fund — the government equivalent of the main family checking account — shows that a hefty $3.65 billion deficit for this year will swell to more than $7.5 billion by 2029-30. Opinions in Harrisburg on what those numbers mean clash so strongly that a repeat of this year’s 135-day budget impasse doesn’t seem like a far-fetched concept.
“Next year will decide which direction this Commonwealth goes,” said Republican Sen. Scott Martin of Lancaster County, chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee. The choice, he said, is between fiscal prudence or future, big-time tax increases.
Democratic Sen. Jay Costa of Allegheny County said he doesn’t have a lot of confidence in the outlook’s numbers, generated by the state Independent Fiscal Office.
History, Mr. Costa said, has shown that “we have been able to manage those deficits” year after year.
The IFO put out a similar projection one year ago. The deficit picture did not change because the just-completed budget did nothing to change the fact that Pennsylvania spends far more than it takes in. The new spending plan benefitted from the use of billions in “one-time” money that will not be available in 2026-27.
Read More

But Mr. Costa said the spending-revenue gap could narrow with approval of new revenue sources like recreational marijuana, taxes or fees on so-called “skill games.” Another possibility, he said, is approval of a “combined reporting” tax change to reduce the ability of multi-state corporate entities to shift tax liabilities out of Pennsylvania.
Pennsylvania already has legal medical marijuana. Getting approval for recreational use was a battleground issue this year, and the main defeat came in May when a Republican-run Senate committee shot down a bill that had passed the Democratic-controlled House.
Similarly, years of talk about skill games regulation have failed to produce bipartisan agreement. A combined reporting bill passed the House in late June has received no action in the Senate.
According to Mr. Costa, some attention should be paid to the expectation that the massive financial bill signed by President Donald Trump on July 4 will force the state to spend more money in years to come — perhaps offsetting revenue increases achieved elsewhere. An example, he said, is greater administrative costs for the state for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program.
The IFO estimates on the size of future deficits look too small to Mr. Martin. The situation, he said, is “much more dire than what the IFO is putting out.”
Lawmakers will face a decision very soon on whether to raid the $7.75 billion budget reserve stabilization fund — also known as the Rainy Day Fund — which as recently as five years ago held less than $500 million. Mr. Martin said such a raid would be a major mistake.
Dealing with deficits of the scope predicted by IFO, he said, requires “getting spending under control” or facing “big, broad-based tax increases” in the near future.
He discounted the potential effects of passing marijuana and skill games legislative. A reasonable guess that the two might produce a combined $500 million in one year, he said, doesn’t seem like much “when you’re talking about a $5 billion hole.”
Observations included in the IFO outlook this year included
- “Wealth metrics” that support consumer spending — and hence, tax revenue — continued to surge in the past year. Existing Pennsylvania home values grew by 4.8% in the second quarter following very strong gains of 13.8% in 2021; 10.6% in 2022; 6.1% in 2023; and 6.8% in 2024.
- During the 2020-2024 pandemic and recovery years, revenue to the state’s General Fund expanded at a rapid pace because of high inflation, federal stimulus efforts and a strong stock market. The report said, “That growth rate was unusually strong and could not be maintained under normal economic conditions.”
- Expenditures for the single biggest category in the General Fund budget, the Department of Human Services, increased at a rate of about 7.1% per year from fiscal 2018-19 to 2023-24. Those increases, the report said, have been “the primary driver of General Fund spending.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.