The recent arrest of an alleged Uzbek terrorist who obtained a Pennsylvania commercial driver’s license this summer has stirred calls for investigations by Republican lawmakers and pushback from the Shapiro administration aimed at potential flaws in a federal database.
The dustup comes as the Trump administration targets immigrant truck drivers — and several Democratic-led states — as part of its ramped-up immigration enforcement efforts and after deadly crashes in California and Florida. It also comes as the U.S. Department of Transportation’s push to restrict immigrants from obtaining CDLs remains in court, and as the administration pressed Pennsylvania to revoke scores of licenses or face federal funding losses.
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security this week announced that Immigration and Customs Enforcement had arrested Akhror Bozoro, a 31-year-old allegedly wanted for links to a terrorist organization in his native Uzbekistan. The arrest was made in Kansas on Nov. 9.
DHS directly pinned Gov. Josh “Shapiro’s Pennsylvania” for allowing Mr. Bozoro to get a CDL, and the Biden administration for releasing him after he entered the U.S. illegally in 2023.
News that Pennsylvania issued Mr. Bozoro a license sparked sharp critique of the governor by the state Republican Party and Republican lawmakers in Harrisburg.
The GOP’s endorsed candidate for governor in 2026, Treasurer Stacy Garrity, posted on social media that “someone must be held accountable,” along with a photo of Mr. Shapiro and allegations of an “immigrant CDL crisis.”
Read More
But Mr. Shapiro, the state Department of Transportation and leaders in other states where similar issues have arisen say the Trump administration needs to check under the hood of its own system.
The governor and state officials Wednesday pointed out that it was a federal database — relied on by PennDOT when processing license applications — that cleared Mr. Bozoro for a CDL.
“We relied on the feds before issuing this one,” the governor told reporters during a news conference in Bristol.
Mr. Shapiro said anytime a non-citizen applies for a CDL, the commonwealth is required to check a federal database to see if the individual qualifies. Mr. Bozoro was authorized as eligible by that database — not only in July when he received a license, Mr. Shapiro said, but even when double checking the database earlier this week.
“If you get rid of the political theatrics that I know most of the people are engaged in … there are real questions,” he said. “The questions, though, have to be directed to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and its database that is run by Secretary [Kristi] Noem.”
Mr. Shapiro added that the federal government “clearly” was “not minding the shop.”
“They’ve got to get better because every single state in the country relies on this database when making a determination as to who qualifies for a CDL,” he said.
DHS on Thursday did not immediately respond to a request for comment on whether it was reviewing the federal database known as SAVE (Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements), which state officials argue should have flagged an individual such as Mr. Bozoro.
“Not only was Akhror Bozorov — a wanted terrorist — RELEASED into the country by the Biden administration, but he was also given a commercial driver’s license by Governor Shapiro’s Pennsylvania,” DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. “This should go without saying, but terrorist illegal aliens should not be operating 18-wheelers on America’s highways,”
On Thursday, Sean Duffy, the U.S. Department of Transportation secretary, threatened to withhold $75 million in federal funding if the Keystone State did not revoke what the administration deems illegally issued CDLs.
The DOT said Pennsylvania failed by issuing “non-domiciled CDLs with an expiration date that extended well beyond the driver’s authorized stay,” and by not requiring “any proof of lawful presence before issuing a CDL.”
Alexis Campbell, a PennDOT spokesperson, said the agency “follows the established federal process for confirming that the applicant was lawfully present using the SAVE database in every case.”
She also said PennDOT fully cooperated with a regularly scheduled audit by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Association, “and out of 150 cases the federal government audited, FMSCA did not identify a single commercial driver's license issued to someone who was not eligible.”
"PennDOT's top priority is safety on our roadways and ensuring only those legally eligible are able to secure a license,” she said.
The Trump administration took similar action in California, where Gov. Gavin Newsom last week accused Mr. Duffy of “spreading easily disproven falsehoods in a sad and desperate attempt to please his dear leader.”
Mr. Newsom and Mr. Shapiro are seen as potential Democratic contenders for the White House in 2028, and both have gone toe-to-toe with the Trump administration on a range of issues.
In October, ICE and the Oklahoma Highway Patrol reportedly arrested more than 90 individuals issued CDLs by several states, including Pennsylvania.
Officials in Pennsylvania, California and New York have said they followed current federal guidelines when their state issued licenses that have later been questioned by the Trump administration as part of its targeting of CDLs and concerns about safety.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia challenged the administration’s safety claims in temporarily blocking its new CDL restrictions last week.
“According to the FMCSA’s own data, non-domiciled CDL holders account for approximately 5% of all CDL holders but only about 0.2% of fatal crashes,” the court order said.
State Sen. Jarrett Coleman earlier this month wrote to the state Department of Transportation demanding answers on PennDOT’s processes and oversight, Fox News reported. Mr. Coleman noted that 12 individuals with Pennsylvania-issued CDLs had been arrested for immigration violations in Oklahoma.
“This revelation is deeply concerning, particularly given the heightened scrutiny and verification processes that CDL applicants are expected to undergo,” he wrote. “The integrity of our licensing system is critical to public safety, national security and public trust.”
The letter also was signed by state Sen. Doug Mastriano, Mr. Shapiro’s opponent in 2022 and a potential primary candidate for governor in 2026.
"We aren't shocked that the Shapiro administration isn't taking accountability for their actions,” James Markley, the state GOP spokesman, told the Post-Gazette Thursday. “Congress should look into the practices used by Shapiro's administration in their 'vetting' process that led to this disaster."
Republican state House leaders wrote to Attorney General Dave Sunday and Auditor General Tim DeFoor this week, calling on them to dig into how Mr. Bozoro obtained a license.
But state officials assert that misinformation has swirled around the matter.
“Under current law, undocumented immigrants may not obtain driver’s licenses in Pennsylvania — period,” PennDOT Secretary Mike Carroll and Secretary of the Commonwealth Al Schmidt wrote to General Assembly leaders, Mr. Sunday and Mr. DeFoor Wednesday. “All non-citizens who apply for driver’s licenses, including commercial driver’s licenses (CDLs), must provide PennDOT with proof of identity and must have their legal presence in this country verified through the federal [SAVE] database.”
The letter noted that PennDOT stopped issuing all CDLs “to lawfully present non-citizens who have temporary legal status” in the U.S. following the new rules from FMCSA in late September.
Even with the federal court blocking that rule from taking effect, PennDOT “has not resumed issuing non-domiciled CDLs and continues to monitor that litigation,” Mr. Carroll and Mr. Schmidt wrote.
The pair added that concerns over the state’s Automatic Voter Registration process “are baseless.”
Mr. Bozorov has never been a registered voter in Pennsylvania, and he couldn’t have registered when he applied for a CDL, they wrote. That’s because non-citizens are “not given the opportunity to register to vote when they visit PennDOT.”
“What this episode reveals is that DHS’s SAVE database may contain incomplete or inaccurate information and fails to indicate that someone has been charged with criminal activity in a foreign country,” Mr. Carroll and Mr. Schmidt wrote. “PennDOT — like state agencies across the country — depends on the information it receives from the Department of Homeland Security. Efforts to improve the licensing process would therefore be better directed toward the federal officials who are responsible for maintaining the SAVE database.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.