HARRISBURG — Voting on a controversial issue in a rapidly changing energy environment, six Democratic senators, including Nick Pisciottano of Allegheny County, joined all Republicans on Wednesday to pass a bill that would erase Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative regulations from Pennsylvania’s books.
The RGGI rules came into being after Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf took executive action in 2019 to put Pennsylvania into the market consortium of a dozen states. It is designed to reduce carbon dioxide emissions from power plants.
Pennsylvania’s active involvement in RGGI was put on hold after opponents went to court.
The bill passed on Wednesday — it consists of a few sentences — has the same wording as one introduced about nine months earlier and put to a final vote in the Senate on Feb. 4. Four Democrats joined all Republicans to pass that bill. It has been awaiting action in the House since then.
“We cannot keep waiting on the court decision,” said Sen. Lisa Boscola, a Northampton County Democrat, during the Senate debate Wednesday. “RGGI is a relic. It does not reflect the reality of today’s grid or today’s cost.”
A Democratic supporter, Sen. Carolyn Comitta of Chester County, said she voted ‘no’ because of a worsening climate crisis and the lack of action by Pennsylvania government on it. She also said the state must support either RGGI or a new plan submitted by Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro.
Read More
Action on the second-time-around bill sponsored by Sen. Gene Yaw, R-Lycoming, came as lawmakers are buffeted by near-daily concerns tied to energy. There are worries about rising energy use, inadequate supply, data center electricity demands, and proposals for multi-billion dollar companies to build power plants that will only serve one or two corporate customers.
Top Republicans have said separating the state from any association with RGGI is a mandatory part of any Pennsylvania energy strategy. Many Democrats believe the climate-protecting intent of RGGI must be supported.
“It is time to move on,” Senate Republican Majority Leader Joe Pittman of Indiana County said. “We need to support abrogation of this regulation again.”
Mr. Yaw said in an interview that he introduced the bill a second time to “emphasize the critical nature of the issue.”
As an illustration of how rapidly things are changing, Mr. Yaw said that at the start of the year, perhaps one percent of Pennsylvanians knew what PJM Interconnection was. Now, he said, it’s likely that a lot more people know PJM is the organization that runs the power grid for Pennsylvania and other nearby states – because of all the worries about rising electric bills, potential brownouts, and other power issues.
“I think there is a little bit more understanding with how these things are affecting electricity and generation,” he said.
Mr. Shapiro sued PJM and has threatened to pull Pennsylvania out of the organization. On RGGI, his administration appealed to the state Supreme Court after Commonwealth Court struck down Pennsylvania’s participation in the consortium.
Asked Wednesday about the bill approval in the Senate, a spokesperson for Mr. Shapiro, Rosie Lapowsky, pointed to the governor’s own energy proposals.
“Independent studies have shown that if passed into law, the governor’s plan will save Pennsylvanians millions on their energy bills while creating billions of dollars in energy investment,” Ms. Lapowsky said. She added that Senate Republicans should “stop playing political games” and work with Democrats to create a comprehensive energy plan.
The six Senate Democrats who voted with Republicans on Wednesday were Mr. Pisciottano, Ms. Boscola, and Sens. Marty Flynn of Lackawanna County, James Malone of Lancaster County, Nick Miller of Lehigh County, and Christine Tartaglione of Philadelphia. In the Feb. 4 vote on the earlier, identical bill, Mr. Malone was not yet in office and Ms. Tartaglione voted against the measure.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.