HARRISBURG — The distress of countless people associated with Sharon Regional Medical Center and other traumatized Pennsylvania hospitals fueled a Tuesday vote by lawmakers to give government more oversight when important health care entities are sold.

The House Health Committee voted 20-6 to approve a bill that would give the state attorney general power to review and potentially block certain hospital and health system transactions. The bill, which will now go to the full House for consideration, was brought about by a yearslong string of ugly situations where hospitals closed after being bought by for-profit entities, leaving patients and employees in the lurch.

The proposed involvement of the state’s top law enforcement official spawned a multi-sided debate, including a focus on the government-in-health-care aspect.

Situations such as the January closing of 125-year-old Sharon Regional Medical Center in Mercer County after its purchase by a for-profit company “must stop,” said Republican state Rep. Timothy Bonner of Mercer County. Mr. Bonner said the government ultimately pays for 67% of health care in the U.S., so government already is “vested” in hospitals.

Advertise with us

A Democrat from the other end of the state, Rep. Tarik Khan of Philadelphia, said the 2019 closing of Hahneman University Hospital after its purchase by a private-equity interest was one of the reasons he ran for office.

“We have to do something to stop this from happening,” Mr. Khan said.

Hospital system buyers, he said, should not be allowed “pillage our communities in the name of profit.”

But Rep. Stephanie Borowicz, R-Clinton, cited the positions on health care of former President Ronald Reagan in vigorously rejecting the bill.

“This is just another bill that involves the heavy hand of government in our health care system,” Ms. Borowicz said.

Advertise with us

Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro has called on the Legislature to take action against money-hungry private-equity entities in health care. Last month, standing outside the recently closed Crozer Chester Medical Center in Delaware County, Mr. Shapiro said “people here in Delco got screwed” by the owner responsible for the closure, private-equity firm Prospect Medical Holdings.

That same day, the sponsor of the bill voted through on Tuesday, Democratic Rep. Lisa Borowski of Delaware County, said she had her first child in the now-closed hospital.

On Tuesday, she told the committee the health of 500,000 children and adults in her area had been endangered so executives and investors could make more money.

“We can’t watch it happen anymore,” Ms. Borowski said.

All Democrats on the committee voted for the bill and Ms. Borowicz was among six Republicans who voted against it. The others were Reps. Marla Brown of Lawrence County, Brad Roae of Erie County, Leslie Rossi of Westmoreland County, Joanne Stehr of Schuylkill County and Jamie Walsh of Luzerne County.

Advertise with us

The top Republican on the committee, Rep. Kathy Rapp of Warren County, credited an amendment from Mr. Bonner as paving the way for her “yes” vote. The amendment did the following:

• Increased the threshold for the attorney general’s involvement in a transaction from one worth $5 million or more to one worth $10 million or more.

• The “waiting period” before an affected transaction could more forward would be 60 days after the attorney general is notified and can start a review, instead of 90 days.

• Eliminated a provision from the bill that would have had it cover qualified transactions involving groups of physicians.

Both Ms. Borowski and Ms. Rapp said the bill was not perfect and almost certainly would be changed in the process of moving forward through the Legislature. Ms. Rapp called it a “first step.”

Advertise with us

Sharon Regional has since reopened under a new owner.

Mr. Bonner said in a Tuesday interview that Sharon Regional is “in the process of rebuilding the health care system, but it is very important that we don’t see a repeat.”