WASHINGTON — Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania made headlines earlier this year for being the lone Democrat to visit President Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago, the lone Democrat voting to confirm Attorney General Pam Bondi, and perhaps the most vocal Democrat to mock his own party over early protests against Trump’s sweeping overhaul of Washington.
But as the second Trump administration hits the 100-day mark Wednesday, Mr. Fetterman has recently stepped up his critique of the White House, particularly over moves affecting union workers, coal miner health and safety, and transgender Americans.
Progressive Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale has been a fierce critic of Trump, joining other Democrats on the House Ethics Committee in trying to subpoena Elon Musk for his slash-and-burn methods at the Department of Government Efficiency. Ms. Lee also led more than 100 House members in a letter last month pressing the Environmental Protection Agency to keep open its offices and programs focused on protecting disadvantaged communities from being disproportionately affected by pollution.
Rep. Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall, has challenged Democrats to rebrand with “a fighting spirit of patriotic economic populism” — accusing the party of being “spineless” after abandoning working class roots and letting “someone else fake economic populism and win power.”
And Gov. Josh Shapiro, who often fought Trump in court when he was attorney general, successfully sued the administration after up to $2 billion in federal funding crucial to Pennsylvania agencies and programs was frozen or in limbo. Seen as a potential Democratic presidential contender in 2028, Mr. Shapiro has said he’s open to working with Trump and Republicans, but has made clear he won’t back down from a fight.
Along with nationwide protests by progressive groups and lawsuits from advocates and Democratic attorneys general, the efforts by Mr. Shapiro and Pennsylvania's representatives on Capitol Hill make up a resistance that’s still divided and in search of a leading messenger, experts told the Post-Gazette.
Read More
But that resistance may be on the upswing in the wake of key election wins, court decisions blocking White House actions and sinking approval ratings in the three months since Trump took office.
“In a bleak time for Democrats, what has been giving them hope is that the first 100 days of the Trump administration have been toxic for Republicans running for office,” said J.J. Balaban, a Democrat strategist and admaker based in Philadelphia.
In Pennsylvania’s Lancaster County — Trump country as much as farm country since 2016 — a Democrat recently won a state Senate seat held by Republicans for more than a century.
In Wisconsin last month, neither $20 million in donations nor a cheeseheaded rally appearance from the world’s richest man, Mr. Musk, could help carry a conservative against a Democratic judge in a contest that preserved the state Supreme Court’s liberal majority.
And in Canada — a key trading partner for Pennsylvania and the U.S. that Trump has hit with tariffs while insisting the northern neighbor should be the 51st state — liberals and Prime Minister Mark Carney held on to power this week. Populist Pierre Poilievre, whose Conservative Party led polls by almost 30 percentage points just months ago, even lost his seat in Parliament.
These elections — combined with Trump’s approval rating dipping near 40% in several polls — offer signs of life for Democrats, who in November lost control of the White House and Senate, and who face their own low public standing as they battle over the best message to blunt Trump’s grip on Washington.
Christopher Borick, a political scientist and pollster at Muhlenberg College in Lehigh County, said some “elder statesmen in the party believe they should just let Trump bury himself … and by default, you’re the alternative.”
The other route is to “take the fight out there,” he said. That’s the tactic deployed by Sen. Bernie Sanders, the independent from Vermont who ran for president in 2016 and 2020, and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, who have held massive rallies in protest.
Sen Chris Murphy, D-Conn., has also risen as a strong voice against what he describes as a “billionaire takeover” of government. And Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J., kicked off April by breaking the record for longest Senate speech blasting the administration’s actions.
“If Democrats have clear messaging and a clear improvement of their brand, and couple that with Republican struggles, [the 2026 midterms] could be a wave-type election,” Mr. Borick said.
But if Democrats are seen as too dysfunctional, their own problems could “diminish their ability to make big gains,” he added.
“There’s more jockeying for position among Democrats than you’d find on a racetrack,” said Charlie Gerow, a Republican strategist based in Harrisburg. “But the problem is they haven’t found a coherent message, and certainly not an effective messenger.”
‘Shellshocked’
Political experts on both sides of the aisle tell the Post-Gazette Trump’s second White House stint is already historic.
Not only has the president rapidly reduced the size of the federal government and targeted agencies and grants he and allies claim are “woke” or wasteful. He’s also sought to expand presidential power in ways that have already led to constitutional showdowns in court.
Mr. Gerow said many administrations simply hope to “cobble enough together to make it look like there’s been some real accomplishment.”
“But Donald Trump hit the ground running from day one and accomplished more in his first few days than most administrations do in the first 100,” he said.
Mr. Gerow acknowledged the global tariffs proposed by Trump — which have rattled markets and opened the door for confusion among allies and critique from businesses and consumers, have “been a problem” the administration should “take a look at and maybe modulate.”
Christopher Nicholas, a Harrisburg-based GOP consultant, said Trump “likes to dominate the news and have a big impact.” But “The Democrats’ ever-changing and evolving reaction to Trump seems more like a live-blogging of someone’s therapy session than it does a coherent political message,” he said.
Larry Ceisler, a Pennsylvania public affairs executive and a Democrat, described his party as “shellshocked.”
“First they have to deal with their election loss and why that happened, but then, when you don't control any branch of government and basically you have to depend on the courts, you’re impotent,” he said.
The most effective way to combat Trump, according to Mr. Ceisler, may not be as “sexy or exciting” as big rallies or viral moments.
“You basically have to file lawsuits … and win elections as a run up to the midterms,” said Mr. Ceisler. “If you want a shift in policy, you have to show Republican members of Congress and state legislatures that if they’re going to be riding with Trump, that train could be headed for a wreck.”
Between Mr. Shapiro filing successful lawsuits and the surprising win for Democrat James Andrew Malone in Lancaster County, “that’s a lot more than Bernie and AOC have gotten by having rallies in Coachella,” Mr. Ceisler said.
He added that Trump’s sagging approval rating is another factor that could lead to more Republicans parting ways with Trump or at least being less likely to bend the knee to him.
“Those loyal members of [Trump’s] congressional majority … they’re looking at their [poll numbers] and it’s basically, ‘What is the down ballot effect of all this?’” he said.
Mr. Borick said what may have been considered “a honeymoon period for Trump never really materialized.”
“Usually where you are in the spring [on approval rating], you’re even worse in the fall,” he said. “It puts him in a tenuous state. Republicans’ willingness to go along with him will be eroded.”
‘Messenger-in-chief’
Mr. Balaban said losing always hurts a political party for awhile. But this year, the pain has been compounded by a president whose stated goal is to punish the opposition in unprecedented fashion.
“We’ve seen in polling tremendous frustration from the grassroots about some of the actions of some of the elected Democrats in Washington,” he said. “The consequences of losing in this situation feel significantly more severe than losing other presidential races in my lifetime.”
Former President Barack Obama certainly did things that made Republicans unhappy, but that wasn’t the goal, Mr. Balaban said.
“The goal was to pass health care reform, something Republicans opposed,” he said. “The policy in the current administration seems less about actually implementing policy goals and more about dispiriting Democrats.”
All the more reason Democrats should seek to build on the victories in Wisconsin and Lancaster County, which the party hadn’t won since not too long after the Civil War, Mr. Balaban said.
Mr. Ceisler said when he sees a poll like mid-March’s NBC News poll showing just 27% approval for Democrats, he believes it’s “not that people necessarily disagree with [Democratic] policies. They want something to happen. So they’re frustrated.”
“Democrats in many ways need to appoint a messenger-in-chief, and the messenger-in-chief is not supposed to run for president in four years, but bring some discipline,” he said.
Along with Mr. Shapiro, Ms. Ocasio-Cortez, Mr. Murphy and former transportation secretary Pete Buttigieg, Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker, Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear are among a handful seen as rising leaders in the Democratic Party.
Former Vice President Al Gore, the Democratic presidential nominee in 2000, sharply criticized the Trump administration recently for what he described as an assault on the truth.
Mr. Gore later told comedian Bill Maher that the U.S. is “really in danger right now, and we have got to rally the grassroots to take back the destiny of America.”
When Mr. Maher suggested that Mr. Gore, 77, had aged well and that the Democrats need someone who’s got “nothing to lose,” Mr. Gore responded that, “there may be a rising demand for another president in his late 70s.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.