HARRISBURG — Some school district leaders in Allegheny County and elsewhere are deeply unhappy with the state Department of Education for saying nothing as they struggle with difficult-to-understand messaging from the new administration of President Donald Trump, a lawmaker said Wednesday.

Questioning Acting Secretary of Education Carrie Rowe during a budget hearing, Sen. Lindsey Williams said those school leaders have waited in vain to hear something from the department since a Jan. 31 message indicated information would be forthcoming.

Ms. Williams, a Democrat from Allegheny County, read a particularly blunt statement by a superintendent within Allegheny County whom she did not identify.

“The department has failed local superintendents, school boards, and the students of the Commonwealth by remaining silent,” the statement said. “This lack of timely guidance has placed districts in a vulnerable position, forcing them to incur additional expenses from frivolous litigation, Right-to-Know requests, and legal challenges stemming from unclear and conflicting mandates.”

Advertise with us

Since the president was sworn in on Jan. 20, some of his administration’s attempts to quickly change federal government have led to confusion — and Ms. Williams told Ms. Rowe some school leaders feel “alone and unsupported” as they navigate serious questions. She called it more important than ever that schools know that the department and Gov. Josh Shapiro “have their back.”

As Ms. Rowe sat before Ms. Williams and the rest of the Senate Appropriations Committee on Wednesday, she was in her seventh day on the job. Ms. Williams acknowledged the acting secretary’s brief tenure but called for a public statement from the department.

“I need you to say it, clearly and unequivocally, that executive orders and dear colleague letters are not law,” Ms. Williams said.

Ms. Rowe said recent days have been challenging, information-wise. Among other things, she said, “information comes out and is retracted” or federal executive orders that require another event to occur before taking effect are issued. It can be tough, she said, for the department to determine the most accurate thing to say to schools.

“The last thing we want to do is put out guidance that then needs to be retracted. But saying something is important,” Ms. Rowe said.

Advertise with us

She said that perhaps, after she gets through her seventh day on the job, the department “can move toward getting something out.”

Many lawmakers questioning Ms. Rowe on Wednesday honed in on the goings-on in Washington. Sen. Vincent Hughes, D-Philadelphia, said a vote in the U.S. House late Tuesday included a proposal to cut $330 billion from education in the U.S. budget.

“We sit here talking about what the governor has proposed,” Mr. Hughes said. “While we have this big elephant poised over our head.”

Ms. Rowe said the talked-about elimination of the U.S. Department of Education could lead to one of multiple different scenarios. In one, the state could lose as much as $1.6 billion of federal funding, but Ms. Rowe also said it also sounded possible that the money could flow thorough a different federal agency.

A loss of all the money, she said, would be “catastrophic” for the state. Even without that, she said, the loss of guidance if the federal agency were closed would be challenging.

Advertise with us

Sen. Joe Pittman of Indiana County, a Republican, lambasted the numbers in one of the key pieces of Mr. Shapiro’s proposed education budget: the “adequacy” and “tax equity’ supplements going to school districts deemed to be underfunded. Of the $606 million increase proposed for K-12 education, he said, 97% will be split up by 348 school districts, while only 3% will go to the remaining 152.

“Fairness is in the eye of the beholder,” Mr. Pittman said. “I am hard pressed to figure out how that is fair.”

Mr. Shapiro proposed the money as the second installment of a multi-years series of funding increases for school districts deemed to be underfunded, following a 2023 court ruling that found the Pennsylvania basic education funding system unconstitutional.