HARRISBURG — A roughly $5 billion disparity in revenue projections for Pennsylvania — one set from the administration of Gov. Josh Shapiro, one set from an independent agency — set off sparks Tuesday as state budget hearings got underway.

Revenue Secretary Pat Browne fielded questions from Republican senators on why the Democratic Shapiro administration revenue projections were so much more rosy than those from the state Independent Fiscal Office. Revenue forecasts are key as Mr. Shapiro and lawmakers start to negotiate a 2025-26 state budget.

Mr. Browne’s give-and-take on Tuesday got especially blunt with Sen. Kristin Phillips-Hill, R-York.

“Unlike Washington, D.C., we do not have printing presses to print dollars,” Ms. Phillips-Hill told Mr. Browne. “If we balance our budget based on what your department and administration is proposing, our state will be bankrupt. We have to look further out.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Browne pushed back strongly on Ms. Phillips-Hill’s use of numbers. He is a former top Republican lawmaker who used to run legislative hearings of the sort he testified at on Tuesday, and he years ago wrote the law that created the IFO.

“The disparity is over a five-year period, senator. It is not $5 billion over one cycle, it is over a five-year cycle with a revenue base of $300 billion,” Mr. Browne said. That, he said, amounted to a variation of less than 2%, well within professional accounting standards.

Mr. Browne also pointed out that revenue projections in general have missed the mark in recent years, although the COVID-19 pandemic had something to do with that. Concerning the IFO, Mr. Browne said, “Let’s not assume these numbers are absolutely accurate looking five years out.”

Mr. Shapiro’s proposed $51.5 billion budget anticipates the state will this year legalize the recreational use of marijuana. It is projected to generate $536.5 million in revenue during 2025-26.

Asked about details, Mr. Browne said the figure was based on the expectation of 267 dispensaries, 90 growers and 106 processors among the total of 504 active businesses involved in the system. Ohio’s experience with legalization — building upon a previously existing medical marijuana sales system — has helped shape the state’s thinking on what might happen here.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania’s medical marijuana law was signed in 2016.

“Other states have ramped this up relatively quickly,” Mr. Browne said. “If we were starting with nothing and we didn’t have a system within the Department of Health, Department of Ag, to regulate medical marijuana, I think the concerns would be more significant.”

Mr. Browne also fielded questions at a hearing in the House, and recreational marijuana came up again.

Allegheny County Democratic Rep. Emily Kinkead asked about the proposed 20% tax rate, noting that for consumers a certain level of taxing would mean “the illicit market ends up being cheaper.”

Mr. Browne said the 20% wholesale tax rate, combined with the 6% sales tax, would let a new recreational industry “ramp up” and “thrive.”

Advertise with us

Many Republicans oppose the concept. Rep. Charity Krupa, R-Fayette, said studies have shown legalization leads to various physical and mental health concerns, and she asked Mr. Browne if financial projections took into account potential harmful effects on the state’s tax-producing work force.

He indicated they did not. Projections, Mr. Browne said, were based only “on the activity we know is going to happen.”

Another new revenue source tapped in Mr. Shapiro’s plan is $368.9 million from the anticipated regulation of the roughly 70,000 “skill games” located in bars, clubs, convenience stores and other venues. Mr. Browne said the numbers were built on a projected 30,000 regulated machines, with a limit of 5 machines per venue and a tax rate of 52% — equal to the one for already-existing video gaming terminals.

Testimony linked the struggling performance of the Pennsylvania Lottery at least in part to the unregulated skill games.

Lottery Deputy Executive Director Stephanie Weyant said scratch-off ticket sales were down 3.9% this fiscal year, indicating an unprecedented fourth consecutive down year. Part of the challenge, she said, was the state has a “saturated gaming market.”

The Legislature, she said, could help by taxing and regulating skill games and requiring that lottery products be available for sale in skill game locations.