HARRISBURG — A special election set for March 25 will break the 101-101 tie in the 203-seat state House, but those with a keen interest in its political control have already looked into the future and gamed out what might happen after four other potential special elections.
The contest next month will fill the seat left vacant by the death of Democratic Rep. Matt Gergely. But with four other members seeking elective positions outside the Legislature — Democrats Dan Miller and Josh Siegel and Republicans Torren Ecker and Lou Schmitt — the potential exists for at least four more special elections later in the two-year session.
The conventional wisdom on the March 25 contest to fill 35th House District seat in Allegheny County favors a Democratic win in part because the party has a 15,000-plus voter registration advantage. Similar thinking dominates consideration of what might happen if some or all of the four potential departures take place in the 22nd, 42nd, 79th, and 193rd House districts.
Republican Rep. Torren Ecker of Adams County, who holds the 193rd District seat, said he believes all four districts “are held pretty strongly Republican or Democrat.” Another of the four, Democratic Rep. Josh Siegel of Lehigh County, said the four districts that could be involved in future special elections are all viewed as safe for the incumbent party.
“Nobody thinks any of these seats are flipping,” Mr. Siegel said.
Multiple scenarios could play out in the House, depending in part on how many of the four succeed in their runs for other offices. In one scenario, all four win the other jobs and resign their legislative seats sometime after the Nov. 4 election, setting up special elections in each case.
Read More
Pennsylvania has had 20 special elections for General Assembly seats in the past four years: 17 for House seats and three for Senate seats. Besides the contest for the House seat left vacant by Mr. Gergely’s death, there will be a special election the same day to fill the 36th Senate District seat in Lancaster County left vacant by the resignation of Republican Sen. Ryan Aument.
Although the general speculation holds that if things follow the most likely course, party power in the House will remain unaffected long-term, close observers say the potential multiple changes mid-session will nonetheless have ripple effects.
“It adds another logistical factor into legislative agendas, strategies and timing,” said Chris Borick, a pollster and professor of political science at Muhlenberg College. “It takes up some bandwidth for leaders, who have to incorporate it into their work.”
Jim Lee, a pollster and CEO at Susquehanna Polling & Research, said the situation raised questions about how the four would spend their time: mostly on their lawmaking jobs, or mostly on their campaigns.
“I am not saying it is impossible to do both,” Mr. Lee said. But, he added, “They can’t be everywhere at the same time.”
Concerning the four candidates for non-legislative posts:
- 193rd House District: Mr. Ecker, 38, is running for judge in the Adams County Court of Common Pleas. He won election to the House seat in 2018 and was unopposed in the November elections in 2020, 2022, and 2024. In the 193rd, Republican have a 2.5-to-1 voter registration advantage.
- 22nd House District: Mr. Siegel is running for Lehigh County executive. He was 28 and an Allentown City Council member when he was elected in the newly redrawn 22nd in 2022. He was re-elected without opposition in November. Mr. Siegel had run unsuccessfully for mayor of Allentown in 2017 and won his City Council seat in 2019. In the 22nd, Democrats hold a 2.5-to-1 voter registration advantage.
- 42nd House District: Democrat Dan Miller, 52, is running for judge in Allegheny County. He was elected in the 42nd in a special election on May 21, 2013 and sworn in on June 4 of that year. He was re-elected six times, including his 67%-33% victory over Republican Joseph Leckenby in November. Mr. Miller was the majority caucus whip last session. There are roughly 72% more Democratic voters than Republicans in the district.
- 79th House District: Republican Lou Schmitt, 62, is running for judge in Blair County. He was first elected to his seat in the House in 2018 and has been re-elected three times. Republican voters outnumber Democrats by about 2-to-1 in the 79th.
Mr. Schmitt said his home county is supposed to have a full complement of five judges, but has been short of that number for more than a year. “I thought I could best serve the people of Blair County by being judge,” Mr. Schmitt said.
He also said Republicans’ loss of the majority in the House in the 2022 election, after 12 years of dominance, had something to do with it. “I certainly do not like being in the minority,” he said.
Of his decision to seek a new job after only a couple of years in the House, Mr. Siegel said “there is no substitute for a good and viable executive” in a major county like Lehigh. He said, “You can steer things and make things happen.”
Mr. Siegel said he will not have an opponent in the primary and will face a Republican candidate in November, but he feels he will probably win because Democrats have performed very well in Lehigh County in recent elections.
Mr. Ecker said he was an attorney in private practice in Adams County who figured that at some point in his career he would run for judge. Then, about seven years ago, 10-year House incumbent Rep. Will Tallman decided not to run for re-election, and Mr. Ecker was approached about seeking the seat.
Six years in office have shown him that being a House member requires a lot of time away from his children, who are 12 and 9. Being a judge locally in Adams County, he said, would be more stable for his family.
Beyond that, he said, “This is something, in the back of my mind, I always thought I would do.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.