HARRISBURG – As state budget negotiations continued Wednesday, statements from top lawmakers made it appear unlikely that a proposed change in how the University of Pittsburgh gets its state funding will happen, or that the school will see any increase in state aid.

Republican Sen. Joe Pittman of Indiana County and Democratic Sen. Jay Costa of Allegheny County, speaking at separate times in the afternoon, went against a concept pitched by Gov. Josh Shapiro to have money for Pitt and other state-related universities approved by a simple majority vote of lawmakers.

Currently, the money – well in excess of $500 million for four universities – requires a two-thirds majority vote in both the House and Senate. Mr. Pittman, the Senate majority leader, told reporters that lawyers said it would be unconstitutional and are “adamant” the two-thirds requirement remain in place.

Mr. Costa, the top Democrat in the Senate, said in an interview that he, too, believed the change would be unconstitutional. Mr. Costa also said that it appeared likely Pitt and other state-related schools would be flat-funded for 2024-25, while Mr. Shapiro had asked for a 5% increase.

Advertise with us

The new fiscal year began Monday without a budget in place, but the lack of one will have little or no negative effects unless it lasts many weeks. The descriptions of budget talks were generally positive on Wednesday, with Mr. Pittman calling them cordial and productive.

“As we always say, unless everything is agreed to, nothing is agreed to,” Mr. Pittman said. “I still remain optimistic and hopeful that we are going to conclude this process in the next several days.”

Mr. Pittman said Mr. Shapiro, a Democrat, has been directly involved in the negotiations. Shapiro spokesman Manuel Bonder – when asked about a White House meeting Wednesday of Democratic governors – said Mr. Shapiro would attend that meeting virtually.

The governor, Mr. Bonder said, would stay in Pennsylvania and work with leaders of both parties to “close a budget deal.”

Another key player is Rep. Matt Bradford of Montgomery County, leader of the House Democratic majority. A spokeswoman for Mr. Bradford, Beth Rementer, said, “We continue to work with all parties in good faith.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Shapiro kicked off the budget discussion in February, when he unveiled a proposed $48.3 billion spending plan that included a proposed $1.1 billion increase in K-12 education funding. Both Mr. Pittman and Mr. Costa on Wednesday said a key sticking point is what sets of data are used to create the formula to direct newly allocated money to school districts.

Mr. Shapiro’s budget proposal was built on the findings of the Basic Education Funding Commission, which used self-reported data from school districts to devise a formula to fill a gap in the adequacy of funding many school districts – a gap the commission said exceeds $5 billion.

Mr. Pittman said Republicans believe census data, rather than self-reported data, should be used. But Mr. Costa said that if census data is used, the size of the adequacy gap – and hence the potential amount of new spending on school support – is reduced by about $1.4 billion.

Mr. Pittman said Republicans still want the budget to include a new voucher-style program that would give state-funded scholarships to students in low-performing public schools so they can attend private ones. At the same time, a Republican-backed bill that advanced in a Senate committee this week would give tax credits of up to $8,000 to families whose children attend private schools.

The prime sponsor of the bill, Republican Sen. Judy Ward of Blair County, said in an interview that getting either concept into the budget deal – scholarships or tax credits – would “be a win for Pennsylvania families, especially the ones in failing schools.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Costa said he is against both, calling them “very expensive programs that are open-ended.”

Meanwhile, lawmakers on Wednesday continued on a pre-summer-recess burst of bill-passing.

The Senate gave final approval Wednesday to a measure that would allow Pittsburgh to start a property tax relief program aimed at longtime owner-occupants of homes in neighborhoods where values are rising rapidly. The bill will now be considered by the House, which endorsed the concept last year.

Separately, the Senate gave final approval in a 45-5 vote to a bill intended to limit students’ use of cell phones in schools. The Pennsylvania State Education Association gave its support, saying in a statement that “emerging research is demonstrating the severe problems that cell phones are causing for students in terms of their learning and mental health.”

And a proposal to give the state Game Commission the authority to expand Sunday hunting got final approval in the Senate in a 33-17 vote that divided both parties.

Advertise with us

A state law passed in 2019 allowed for up to three days of Sunday hunting. A strong supporter of the latest bill, Sen. Dan Laughlin, D-Erie, praised the earlier action as the beginning of the end of a Sunday prohibition that is one of the last “blue laws.”

The latest bill, he said, is necessary because the near-total Sunday ban “does not reflect the realities of modern life” in which Sunday is the only day many people have available to hunt. Beyond that, he said, Pennsylvania is one of the last states to maintain Sunday hunting prohibitions.

But senators from both parties spoke against the bill.

Democrat Judy Schwank of Berks County said the process that created the bill was flawed. She said it merged two bills that should have remained separate. And, she said, most Sundays should be protected so people who do not hunt but enjoy the outdoors can have “one day a week where I can go out and enjoy nature.”

Republican Elder Vogel of Beaver County said the proposal to vastly increase the number of hunting Sundays after removing the total ban only five years ago shows that “you give somebody an inch, they take a mile.”

Advertise with us

The bill now goes to the House for consideration.

Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com