HARRISBURG — The state Senate was discharged Thursday afternoon with no agreement on a state budget and with the message it will return on Monday, making it very likely that no budget will be in place by Sunday’s constitutional deadline.

There was no indication of any major disagreement between negotiators for the Republican-controlled Senate and the Democrat-led House and administration. In fact, there were a number of positive comments from both sides. Gov. Josh Shapiro reiterated on Thursday a description he had made the previous day — that talks have been honest and productive — and he said he appreciated negotiators’ hard work.

Nonetheless, the development meant the July 1 start of the 2024-25 fiscal year would almost certainly arrive with no budget in place. After negotiators reach agreement on major pieces, lengthy bills that can take days to prepare must be readied for dissemination to all lawmakers ahead of the actual votes.

If all budget-related bills are passed and signed into law in early July, most state residents will notice no effect from the failure to meet the deadline.

Advertise with us

“I am encouraged by progress that has been made over the last several days,” said Republican Sen. Joe Pittman, R-Indiana and the majority leader in the upper chamber. He said he was “quite confident” that enough progress had been made to have things come together soon after the June 30 deadline. The top Democrat in the chamber, Sen. Jay Costa of Allegheny County, said progress had been made and the most important thing was to get the budget-conveying bills “done right.”

The state House, meanwhile, is scheduled to be in Harrisburg Friday and possibly on the weekend.

Late Thursday, the leader of the Republican minority in the House told reporters the budget never had a chance of being on time because Democrats who control the chamber failed to “lay the necessary groundwork” in terms of positioning bills and managing the House schedule. Rep. Bryan Cutler of Lancaster County — a former speaker of the House — said, “This was always going to be late, and that’s very frustrating.”

A spokesperson for Democratic Speaker of the House Joanna McClinton of Philadelphia declined to comment on Mr. Cutler’s statement.

Budget negotiators this year have plenty of money to work with — the state currently has a surplus of approximately $14 billion. Mr. Shapiro cited that surplus when he announced his $48.3 billion spending proposal, saying it was time to invest in the state’s future, and particularly education. His proposal includes a $1.1 billion increase in spending on K-12 education funding.

Advertise with us

Several senators said education funding was a key topic that has slowed negotiations. One of them, Sen. Lisa Boscola, D-Northampton, said there also was concern being expressed about the overall “spend” total in Mr. Shapiro’s proposal, which was about 8% greater than the current year’s total.

“An eight percent spend number is a lot of money, and I don’t know how we are going to sustain it,” Ms. Boscola said.

Ms. Boscola said senators should have stayed in Harrisburg and continued to work through the weekend, if necessary. Sen. David Argall, R-Schuylkill and chairman of the Education Committee, said it is likely the public will not notice any difference “if we are able to reach a budget in early July.”

Another Republican, Sen. Tracy Pennycuick of Montgomery County, said senators have been told to prepare to be in Harrisburg all next week — including the Fourth of July holiday on Thursday.

Separate from budget matters, debate over a bill that would cause universities that divest from Israel to forfeit their state financial support led to an emotional and bipartisan outpouring of support for that nation. Its ongoing conflict with the Hamas terrorist group has triggered protests at schools across the country, including the University of Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Lawmakers are likely to leave Harrisburg for a couple of months after the budget is done, and not return until after students return to campuses. Senators said it was important to send a message now to university leaders.

Sen. Judy Schwank, D-Berks, said some of the protests “devolved into lawlessness” and there were “implied and actual death threats” against Jewish people on campuses. Sen. Steve Santarsiero, D-Bucks and a prime sponsor of the bill, blasted the “BDS movement” — which stands for boycott, divest, sanctions — that has influenced the protests as a movement whose goals include the eradication of Israel.

The bill also would preclude state-controlled funds from divesting from Israel. Sen. Kristin Phillips-Hill, R-York, spoke in favor of the bill and recounted that the more than 1,000 Israelis killed on Oct. 7 in a surprise Hamas attack included a 94-year-old woman and a newborn baby.

She said Pennsylvania currently holds more than $55 million in Israel-based investments. “Like Israel, we will not be bullied,” Ms. Phillips-Hill said.

Sen. Art Haywood, D-Montgomery, said he supported Israel’s right to exist and was against violence against civilians and women, but he also supported Palestinian goals and disliked the use of “starvation as a weapon of war.” Mr. Haywood said he was concerned the bill would restrict free speech, and he said the ACLU of Pennsylvania also had concerns about it.

Advertise with us

The bill passed on a 41-7 vote and now goes to the House for consideration.

Besides Mr. Haywood, those voting “no” were Democratic Sens. Lindsey Williams of Allegheny County, Tim Kearney of Delaware County, Katie Muth of Montgomery County, Nikil Saval of Philadelphia, and Anthony Williams of Philadelphia, as well as Republican Sen Jarrett Coleman of Lehigh County.

Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com