Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner announced Monday afternoon that an arrest warrant issued last week for Democratic state Rep. Kevin Boyle has been withdrawn, based on new information that his office was only able to fully confirm on Monday.
His announcement came six days after Philadelphia police said a warrant was issued for Mr. Boyle for violation of a restraining order. Mr. Boyle’s whereabouts since then have been a matter of speculation.
As recently as Monday morning, a spokesperson for Mr. Krasner’s office said Mr. Boyle “has not turned himself in and remains at large. There remains an active warrant for his arrest.”
Mr. Boyle’s uncertain status triggered heated disagreements in the state House last week in Harrisburg. A proxy voting system already in place allowed a designee to cast 18 votes for Mr. Boyle on Wednesday, even though he was not present and was the subject of an arrest warrant.
Monday afternoon, Mr. Krasner said at a press conference the withdrawal of the arrest warrant was “based ultimately on information obtained by the district attorney’s office this morning.” That information, he said, was that the “protection from abuse order was no longer in effect when Mr. Boyle was alleged to have violated that order.”
Mr. Krasner said he saw no indication of bad faith by police or his office.
Read More
The announcement came on the eve of a primary election in which Mr. Boyle is seeking the Democratic nomination for re-election to an eighth two-year term in the state House — and in which state Democratic campaign money is flowing to Mr. Boyle’s opponent. Asked by reporter whether the closeness of the election was a factor, Mr. Krasner said some might speculate on a “big plot” but “might it just be that people operating in good faith were missing a fact and went back and got it.”
Mr. Krasner said the case involving Mr. Boyle would be scrutinized. He said he could not rule out the possibility of another charge being filed.
Earlier in the day, state Rep. Mark Gillen, R-Berks, said the situation in the House that had allowed Mr. Boyle to vote in the House while subject to arrest was shameful and had “brought disrepute” on those who let it happen.
The proxy voting system was permitted by a recent change in House rules.
Mr. Gillen pointed out that state Rep. Joe Kerwin, a Dauphin County Republican who announced in December he would deploy to east Africa with the Pennsylvania Army National Guard, is listed as on “leave” in the House.
He has not cast a vote in the House since Dec. 13. Mr. Gillen said he spoke on the phone late Sunday with Mr. Kerwin, who commands a Guard company responsible for securing key American assets from terrorist threats. He said Mr. Kerwin has been able to follow events in Harrisburg via the web.
Mr. Gillen is minority chair of the House Veterans Affairs and Emergency Preparedness Committee.
“We discussed business issues related to the military,” said Mr. Gillen. Concerning his leave status, Mr. Gillen said, “What Kerwin has done is show the right way to handle this situation.”
The voting status questions pertaining to Mr. Boyle were crucial because Democrats hold a slim 102-100 majority in the 203-seat House, with a special election scheduled for Tuesday to fill a vacant seat. That election is being held in the 139th House District in Pike and Wayne counties where registered Republicans outnumber Democrats by nearly 2 to 1.
Bills require a 102-vote majority for passage. While Mr. Kerwin’s on-leave status leaves Republicans with only 99 votes, the loss of Mr. Boyle’s vote would meant Democrats would have needed at least one Republican vote to pass bills.
House Democrats on Wednesday had rebuffed Republican demands that Mr. Boyle be placed on leave. Some of Mr. Boyle’s “yes” votes by proxy on Wednesday actually were on questions directly relating to his situation.
Democratic Speaker of the House Joanna McClinton of Philadelphia said the House clerk was in possession of a properly filed vote-by-designation form for Mr. Boyle, so his participation by proxy vote was permissible.
Rep. Bryan Cutler of Lancaster County, the Republican minority leader, called it an “absurd interpretation of the rules” and challenged Ms. McClinton’s ruling — a challenge that was defeated by 102 votes that included Mr. Boyle’s vote via proxy.
Late last week, a top Democrat submitted a proposed resolution to set up a multistep “incapacity inquiry” process that would let the House take steps leading to possible suspension or expulsion of members found unable to carry out their duties. Mr. Cutler dismissed the move as a stalling tactic designed to allow Democrats to cling to the 102-vote majority.
Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.