Progressives have long seen John Fetterman as one of their own: He endorsed Bernie Sanders for president, hung marijuana and LGBTQ flags outside his office as Pennsylvania’s lieutenant governor, and championed clemency for people serving life sentences when he ran the state’s Board of Pardons

But as the freshman Democratic senator wraps up his first year in Washington, his breaks with progressive allies are bursting into clearer view, especially in his staunch support for Israel’s war against Hamas and his openness to joining Republicans in supporting an immigration crackdown.

“I’m not a progressive,” Mr. Fetterman told NBC News in an interview that published Friday. “I just think I’m a Democrat that is very committed to choice and other things. But with Israel, I’m going to be on the right side of that. And immigration is something near and dear to me, and I think we do have to effectively address it as well.”

His assertion that he’s “not a progressive” was his most explicit rhetorical break from a wing of the Democratic Party that has long supported him. But it was only the most recent.

Advertise with us

Ever since Hamas attacked Israel in October, Mr. Fetterman has found himself on the opposite side of many of his progressive allies. In the weeks after the Oct. 7 attack, which left 1,400 dead and some 240 held hostage, the freshman Democrat has repeatedly affirmed unwavering support for the Jewish state and bucked progressives’ calls for a ceasefire. He has stood firm even after Israeli retaliatory strikes in Gaza killed more than 15,000 Palestinians, forced even more to leave their homes, and raised calls for a ceasefire to a fever pitch.

And as Republicans refuse to approve more military aid to Ukraine and Israel without significant new restrictions on immigration across the southern U.S. border with Mexico, Mr. Fetterman has urged his party not to dismiss concerns about migration.

“I hope Democrats can understand that it isn’t xenophobic to be concerned about the border,” he told Politico earlier this month. “It’s a reasonable conversation, and Democrats should engage.”

Citing the nearly 270,000 border encounters that U.S. Customs and Border Protection reported in September, he added: “Honestly, it’s astonishing. And this isn’t a Fox News kind of statistic. This is the government’s. You essentially have Pittsburgh showing up there at the border.”

Mr. Fetterman’s recent comments and positioning don’t make him anything like a conservative Democrat in the mold of retiring West Virginia Sen. Joe Manchin, nor is he a threat to leave the party like Arizona Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, a Democrat-turned-independent.

Advertise with us

He remains a reliable Democratic vote on most key issues, even one firmly in the party’s left wing. He joined Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., in opposing legislation suspending the debt ceiling earlier this year because it was tied to new work requirements for food stamps and other spending cuts. And he endorsed two candidates for Philadelphia City Council from the liberal Working Families Party, in defiance of the local party establishment.

Years earlier as Braddock mayor, he endorsed Mr. Sanders over Hillary Clinton for president in 2016.  “What Bernie wants to do for the U.S., I want to do here in Pennsylvania,” Mr. Fetterman said at the time, while he was mounting his first U.S. Senate campaign.

But his comments to NBC News underscored his willingness to break from his party’s progressive wing on certain issues. He said that while it’s “not ideal to have this conversation” about immigration policy in connection with aid for Israel and Ukraine, “it’s still one that we should have” given that Republicans refuse to advance such aid otherwise.

“Progressives better do that because we can't leave Israel — we can’t sell them out, and we can’t sell Ukraine out, and we have to deliver on this,” Mr. Fetterman told NBC. “I just would very much like to get a deal to deliver this critical aid.”