HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania cannot enforce a regulation to make power plant owners pay for their planet-warming greenhouse gas emissions, a state court ruled Wednesday, dealing another setback to the centerpiece of former Gov. Tom Wolf's plan to fight global warming.

The Commonwealth Court last year temporarily blocked Pennsylvania from becoming the first major fossil fuel-producing state to adopt a carbon-pricing program, and the new ruling makes that decision permanent.

The ruling is a victory for Republican lawmakers and coal-related interests that argued that the carbon-pricing plan amounted to a tax, and therefore would have required legislative approval. Mr. Wolf, a Democrat, had sought to get around legislative opposition by unconstitutionally imposing the requirement through a regulation, they said.

The court agreed in a 4-1 decision.

Advertise with us

The regulation written by Mr. Wolf’s administration had authorized Pennsylvania to join the multistate Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, which imposes a price and declining cap on carbon dioxide emissions from power plants.

It would be up to Mr. Wolf's successor, Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro, to decide whether to appeal the decision to the state Supreme Court. Mr. Shapiro's administration had no comment Wednesday on whether it would appeal, and Mr. Shapiro himself hasn’t said publicly whether he would follow through on the plan to join the consortium, should the courts allow it.

Still, Mr. Shapiro is “focused on addressing climate change, reducing emissions, and protecting public health while creating jobs and protecting consumers,” his administration said in a statement.

Republican lawmakers hailed the decision and urged Mr. Shapiro not to appeal it. Such a plan continues to have no chance of passing the state Legislature, where the Republican-controlled Senate has been protective of hometown coal and natural gas industries in the nation’s No. 2 gas state.

In a statement, Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman, R-Indiana, said Pennsylvania lawmakers should now work to “foster greater energy independence, while ensuring the responsible development of our God-given natural resources.”

Advertise with us

In the House, where Democrats hold a one-seat majority, neither a carbon-pricing plan, nor Mr. Shapiro’s most well-defined clean-energy goal — a pledge to ensure that Pennsylvania uses 30% of its electricity from renewable power sources by 2030 — have come up for a vote.

A coalition of environmental advocacy groups said there is no alternative climate plan waiting on Mr. Shapiro's desk and, in a statement, they urged him to appeal the decision to “demonstrate his commitment to protecting the climate, human health, and the economic future of Pennsylvanians.”

Critics had said the pricing plan would raise electricity bills, hurt in-state energy producers and drive new power generation to other states while doing little to fight climate change.

Opponents also included natural gas-related interests, industrial and commercial power users and labor unions whose members build and maintain pipelines, power plants and refineries.

Backers of the plan had called it the biggest step ever taken in Pennsylvania to fight climate change and said it would have generated hundreds of millions of dollars a year to promote climate-friendly energy sources and cut electricity bills through energy conservation programs.

Advertise with us

The plan's supporters included environmental advocates as well as solar, wind and nuclear power producers.

In the majority decision, written by Judge Michael Wojcik, the court found that the revenue from the fees paid by polluters would be the same as a tax, and that such a new tax should only be authorized through legislation. Mr. Wolf had sought to trigger the state’s entry into RGGI through an executive order directing the Department of Environmental Protection to promulgate regulations making it so.

“The Rulemaking is an invalid tax; we declare that the Rulemaking is void; and we enjoin the Secretary from enforcing its provisions,” Judge Wojcik wrote.

Judge Ellen Ceisler wrote a dissenting opinion in which she asserted that it’s not clear that the payments by polluters in RGGI would amount to a tax rather than a fee that the agency could implement.

“There is still a persuasive argument to be made that the emissions allowance auction process does not establish a tax. Acting Secretary asserts in his brief that the Rulemaking creates fees, because the auction proceeds will be put towards both administering and supporting DEP’s air pollution control programs; the auction process creates emissions allowance credits, the value of which is set by the market, not the government; the allowance credits pertain to a voluntary act (i.e., emission of CO2); and the Rulemaking allows for CO2 emitters to purchase such credits from other states and apply them to emissions made in this Commonwealth,” she wrote.

Capitolwire.com contributed