HARRISBURG — In a series of party-line votes, a House committee Wednesday approved bills addressing topics ranging from police actions to an extended fee to support legal aid services.

The Democratic-controlled Judiciary Committee voted 14-11 in favor of House Bill 462 to ban police from using chokeholds on suspects in making arrests as well as any action that inhibits breathing or the flow of blood to the brain.

The panel voted 14-11 to amend the bill on a motion by Committee Majority Chairman Tim Briggs, D-Montgomery, to require that municipal police departments keep records on their use of force. The Pennsylvania State Police would coordinate this information and send an annual report to the committee.

The bill sponsor, Rep. Stephen Kinsey, D-Philadelphia, said banning chokeholds will save lives and end a practice that isn’t officially taught to officers by municipal police departments anyway.

Advertise with us

Committee Minority Chairman Rob Kauffman, R-Franklin, urged a no vote saying the bill doesn’t clearly define what a chokehold is and doesn’t support law enforcement.

On another police matter, the panel voted unanimously in favor of House Bill 1399 to require law enforcement officers to wear their badges with identifiable information visible at all times.

Read More

The bill sponsor, Rep. Donna Bullock, D-Philadelphia, said in a co-sponsor memo that having a badge in clear view would let people identify officers who are engaged in unethical or illegal behavior.

By a 14-11 vote the panel approved House Bill 1617 sponsored by Mr. Briggs to extend court fees used to support the legal aid services to apply a $2 fee to summary traffic violations.

Under current state law, $6 in fees are assessed on a range of court filings to support legal aid services.

Advertise with us

Mr. Briggs said he would ultimately like to see legal aid services funded by the state taxpayer supported General Fund. Absent that, he introduced HB1617 to provide more support to legal aid.

Mr. Kauffman urged a no vote saying he gets many complaints about fees tacked onto summary traffic violations and adding a $2 fee would be piling on.

By a 14-11 vote, the panel approved House Bill 637 to remove the ability of a criminal defendant to cite the so-called LGBTQ+panic defense in their case as a way to avoid being convicted or to get a lesser sentence.

The bill sponsor, Rep Benjamin Sanchez, D-Montgomery, said HB637 would remove a discriminatory offense that tries to blame the victim because of sexual orientation or gender identity or purported sexual advance from the books.

In a cosponsor memo, Mr. Sanchez said victims of violence shouldn’t feel the justice system won’t protect them because of a loophole that targets their existence.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kauffman urged a no vote saying he would like to see evidence this defense is used in court cases in Pennsylvania.

By a 15-10 mainly party line vote, the panel approved House Bill 1601 to require state agencies to help individuals transitioning from prison obtain legal ID, drivers’ licenses and work permits prior to reentry.

The bill sponsor, Rep. Emily Kinkead, D-Allegheny, said getting these documents can be difficult for people as they apply for jobs or find a place to live.

Mr. Kauffman urged a no vote saying he has concerns about adding a mandate to a state Department of Corrections reentry program that is working well.