HARRISBURG — The state Supreme Court on Wednesday heard arguments in the most significant challenge in almost 30 years to the preemption law barring local governments from passing stricter gun laws than those enacted by the state.

The case, Crawford v. Commonwealth, was filed in October 2020, claiming the state preemption law “handcuffs local governments so that they cannot enact or enforce even simple, well-researched policies that have been repeatedly shown to save lives, while it also refuses to enact statewide gun safety laws. … In short, the Pennsylvania General Assembly’s actions have stoked the gun violence epidemic.”

Jasmeet Ahuja, representing the plaintiffs in the case, argued that Article 1, Section 1, of the state Constitution provides a “right to self-defense by legislation” which should empower local municipalities to determine if they should have stricter gun laws.

The lawsuit was brought by Philadelphia and survivors of gun violence.

Advertise with us

In May 2022, Commonwealth Court dismissed the case with three judges favoring dismissal and two dissenting. The plaintiffs appealed the Commonwealth Court decision to the Supreme Court.

The plaintiffs are attacking the state’s preemption law on three fronts, asserting:

• That the General Assembly’s unwillingness to let local governments pass stricter gun control laws results in a “state-created danger” that has made citizens more vulnerable to gun violence;

• That the preemption law violates citizens’ rights spelled out in Article 1, Section 1 of the state Constitution, including the rights of life, liberty and “pursuing their own happiness.”

• And that the preemption law prevents the municipalities from responding to the gun violence epidemic as a public health threat.

Advertise with us

In rejecting those arguments, the Commonwealth Court had pointed to the precedent from the 1996 decision in Ortiz v. Commonwealth in which the Supreme Court had ruled that because gun laws are a statewide concern, it made sense to have a statewide gun law.

Wednesday, justices repeatedly questioned how the courts could weigh in on the matter without making policy decisions that ought to be made by the General Assembly.

They also noted that unlike prior major decisions, like one determining that the state is unconstitutionally underfunding poor school districts, there is nothing in the state Constitution that explicitly spells out the rights being asserted by plaintiffs in this case.

Ms. Ahuja said that the ordinances that Philadelphia would enact if empowered to do so would not impact gun rights of lawful gun owners.

“The proposed legislation would target unlawful gun ownership,” she said. “We are not trying to impinge on lawful gun ownership.”

The ordinances that Philadelphia would enact include a measure that would require gun owners to obtain a city permit to obtain a firearm, a measure barring gun purchasers from buying more than one gun a month, and a red flag ordinance, intended to make it easier to take away gun rights from those deemed a danger to themselves or others.