HARRISBURG — The state House on Tuesday passed a bill that would allow the same person to serve as a borough’s employee and elected official — regardless of its population — triggering an impassioned critique from a lawmaker who named several Allegheny County boroughs as places that could end up having the “ultimate patronage position.”
State law currently includes a prohibition that says, “No elected official of a borough with a population of 3,000 or more may serve as an employee of that borough.” A bill sponsored by Rep. Nick Pisciottano, D-West Mifflin, that would remove that provision was passed by the House in a 125-78 vote, with 23 Republicans joining all Democrats in support. It now goes to the Senate for consideration.
Just before the vote, Rep. Russ Diamond, R-Lebanon, lambasted the potential for conflicts of interest if the bill becomes law. He said he understood the logic of allowing a person in very small borough to serve as both elected official and employee, but not in larger ones. Among the examples he named were State College, with a population of about 40,000, and several Allegheny County boroughs, including Monroeville, population about 28,000; West Mifflin, population about 19,000; and Bethel Park, population about 33,000.
Mr. Diamond said a scenario could develop where an elected official would be creating policies or helping to create policies that directly affected his or her own job.
“Tell me again that you can’t find someone who is not employed by those boroughs to fill elected positions in those boroughs,” Mr. Diamond said. He said the bill was not good government.
“This would be the ultimate patronage position,” he said.
Read More
A memo linked to the bill online described allowing for “boroughs to operate more efficiently and to encourage participation by individuals invested in the success of their community.” But contrary to the language in the actual bill — which completely removed any population threshold — the memo described lifting the cap to a population of 5,000.
Attempts to contact Mr. Pisciottano following the vote were not successful. State Rep. Rob Mercuri, R-Pine, said in an interview he voted against the measure because he agreed with Mr. Diamond.
“This opened it up to all boroughs in Pennsylvania, that you could sit on a board and also be employed by the borough,” Mr. Mercuri said. “It is a clear conflict of interest and it is inappropriate. That is why I voted ‘no.’”
Mr. Mercuri added, “The borough manager could run for mayor, or council. It is easy to see how that could lead to abuses.”
Officials at the Pennsylvania State Association of Boroughs were not immediately available for comment.
Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.