WASHINGTON — Joe Biden kicked off his 2020 presidential campaign in Pittsburgh, holding his first rally at a Lawrenceville union hall. He ended it there, too, holding his last rally 17 months later with Lady Gaga at what was then Heinz Field.
And as Mr. Biden launched his 2024 campaign Tuesday, this time as the incumbent president, Pittsburgh and Pennsylvania loom as large as ever in his political hopes.
After all, it’s the second most populous city, in the politically competitive second largest county, in one of the small handful of states that will determine if he gets to spend another four years in the White House.
“In his head, he probably knows that Western PA is key for his politics. And, in his heart, Western PA seems like where he wants to be,” said Jesse Ferguson, a longtime Democratic strategist who worked on Hillary Clinton’s 2016 campaign. “Last time, he told working people what he'd do and this time he can show them what he's done. He has this unique authenticity and credibility that people respond to, and that's one of the reasons he reaches people in places like Pittsburgh.”
Pittsburgh and the rest of Pennsylvania again will be one of the most critical electoral battlegrounds that the president and his eventual Republican opponent will fight over until Nov. 5, 2024. With Florida having moved firmly into the GOP column over the last few election cycles, Pennsylvania’s 19 Electoral College votes make it the biggest swing-state prize on the map.
"A Pennsylvania native, President Biden has a special appreciation for Pittsburgh because of its rich history with organized labor and perseverance through similar economic struggles that the president grew up in,” said Zack Kennedy, a former Democratic operative with experience in Pennsylvania campaigns. “Pittsburgh is also a powerhouse city in a strategic battleground state, as well as a gateway city to the Midwest, where presidential elections are decided.”
The man Mr. Biden beat in 2020, former President Donald Trump is running again, and polls suggest he’s the early frontrunner to win his third consecutive GOP nomination. A Wall Street Journal poll released earlier this month found him with the support of 48% of Republican primary voters, twice as much as his closest competitor, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis — who has struggled even before launching a campaign.
Democrats had carried Pennsylvania in presidential elections for almost a quarter-century until Mr. Trump’s surprise success with white working class voters flipped the state and others like it in 2016. Mr. Biden yanked it back into the Democratic column four years later.
“He’s someone who fits with Pennsylvania on a personal and cultural level,” said J.J. Balaban, a longtime Philadelphia-based Democratic strategist.
Referring to Mr. Biden’s early upbringing in Scranton and his long tenure as a U.S. senator from Delaware, Mr. Balaban added: “He’s Scranton Joe. He’s someone who represented the suburbs of Philadelphia.”
Gov. Josh Shapiro said Tuesday that Mr. Biden “has routinely delivered for Pennsylvania.” Speaking to reporters in Harrisburg, he credited Mr. Biden’s responsiveness to the Feb. 3 train derailment just over the Ohio border in East Palestine, which has also had ongoing health and environmental effects on Beaver County.
“I was on the phone with the president multiple times where he just kept stressing that the federal government would deliver whatever is needed for Western Pennsylvania to deal with that,” Mr. Shapiro said. “And he has.”
Mr. Biden is sure to face challenges from continuing economic uncertainty and an electorate as politically and culturally divided as ever. An NBC News poll released earlier this month showed 54% of voters disapproving of the president’s performance in office, compared with just 41% who approved.
“There is a big buyer’s remorse among Biden voters,” said Harrisburg-based Republican consultant Charlie Gerow. “That’s what any election is going to be about. It’s the referendum on the incumbent’s administration.”
Mark Harris, a Pittsburgh-based Republican strategist helping run the super PAC supporting Nikki Haley's presidential campaign, said Mr. Biden starts “in a weak position” for an incumbent.
"All of the public polling shows him way upside down in his favorability," Mr. Harris said.
But Mr. Biden’s local connections and the state’s political profile give him a slight edge in 2024, Mr. Balaban said.
“We do know that the Democratic presidential nominee has carried Pennsylvania in every presidential election save one going back to 1992,” he said. “That’s a lot of data points. You would rather be a Democrat running for president in Pennsylvania than a Republican. That’s been true for 30 years.”
But not enough to ensure victory. Over that time, only Barack Obama was able to win more than 51% of the Pennsylvania vote, according to the website 270towin.He did that in both 2008 and 2012. That was before the Trump era accelerated the political realignment that has come to define Pennsylvania politics in recent years, in which formerly Republican suburban strongholds turned blue, and formerly Democratic exurban and rural strongholds turned red.
“Pennsylvania’s been a swing state in a presidential election for a long time,” Mr. Balaban said. “Even when [Democrats] were winning those elections, it was by reasonably close margins. It wasn’t a blow out.”
Over the last several years, the state’s electorate underwent shifts similar to the rest of the country. More moderate suburban voters repulsed by Mr. Trump’s policies and his behavior in office shed their GOP loyalties, while working-class whites embraced the outspoken candidate who promised to fight the cultural elites for them and upend the status quo.
In Chester County, for example, Mr. Obama and Republican Mitt Romney fought to a tie in 2012 in the Philadelphia suburb. In 2020, Mr. Biden carried it by 17 percentage points.
Luzerne County, a white working-class area just south of Mr. Biden’s native Scranton, backed Mr. Obama by 5 points in 2012. Eight years later, Mr. Trump carried it by 14 points.
Allegheny County, which includes heavily Democratic Pittsburgh, stayed firmly in the blue column, going for Mr. Obama by 15 points in 2012 and for Mr. Biden by 20 points in 2020. But with its union-friendly, working-class culture, increasingly post-industrial economy, and politically competitive suburbs and exurbs in Allegheny County and beyond, Western Pennsylvania overall remains a political battleground.
Pennsylvania “fits so well into the major fault lines of American politics," said Christopher Borick, a pollster and political science professor at Muhlenberg College in Allentown. "Republicans are going to be focusing here extensively. They know the math and you'll see lots of visits and engagements."
Mr. Biden signed into law several major pieces of legislation as the U.S. emerged from the COVID-19 pandemic and the economic struggles that came with it.
They included a $1.9 trillion stimulus bill shortly after he took office, a $1 trillion bipartisan infrastructure law, legislation to encourage companies to build computer chips in the U.S., and a measure to spur domestic development of clean energy and cut the cost of prescription drugs.
“The divisive, nonsensical rhetoric that has replaced well-intended democratic debate is very loud,” said Michael Soliman, a Democratic strategist. “But if the president stays on message and reminds people of the work he has done on their behalf…he will break through that noise.”
Republicans blame all that spending for sparking the highest inflation rate in decades, criticism that has resonated with voters. In the NBC News poll, Biden was 20 points underwater when it came to his handling of the economy, with 58% disapproving and only 38% approving.
Mr. Gerow said Mr. Biden is unlikely to turn that negative perception around.
“Incredible federal spending simply can’t be sustained and it hurts every family,” Mr. Gerow said. “President Biden doesn’t call me for advice and counsel but if he did, I would say, ‘Enjoy your retirement.’”
Despite the polls, Democrats say they have a great story to tell.
“From bringing domestic manufacturing back through good-paying union jobs to investing in our roads and bridges, President Biden has taken historic steps to support American workers,” New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy said. “His agenda is focused on lowering costs for families and rebuilding the middle class — a message that will resonate in critical battlegrounds like Pennsylvania.”
Also buoying Mr. Biden is the continuing backlash to restricting abortion access. Outrage over the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision last year to overturn a 49-year-old constitutional right to abortion sparked bigger-than-expected Democratic voter turnout in last year’s midterm elections, when a predicted Republican wave failed to materialize.
In Pennsylvania, Democrats captured a GOP-held U.S. Senate seat, replacing retiring Republican Pat Toomey with Democrat John Fetterman. Democrats also won control of the state House for the first time in more than a decade.
A Wall Street Journal poll released earlier this month found abortion is the second biggest issue on voters’ minds, behind only the economy.
But Mr. Biden also faces questions about his age. He turned 80 last year, already making him the oldest person ever to occupy the White House.
In an Associated Press-NORC poll released this month, even 52% of Democrats said he shouldn’t run again, compared to 47% who said he should.
“Polling has shown that Democrats are not necessarily thrilled with
Biden running again,” said Rutgers University pollster and professor Ashley Koning. “They think he‘s too old. But certainly [Democrats] are going to rally behind him.”
Former U.S. Rep. Paul McHale, D-Lehigh, said Mr. Biden shouldn’t run, despite what he called “a tremendous first term in office.”
“I think it’s time for him to mentor the next generation of leadership and assist another qualified candidate to run for the presidency,” Mr. McHale said. “If Joe Biden had concluded that the time had come for retirement, I think we’d see a half dozen qualified candidates emerge.”
Nevertheless, Mr. McHale said he would support Mr. Biden.
“The paramount issue is not his age,” Mr. McHale said. “The paramount issue is what kind of presidency has he established during the past three years.”
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant; Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com, @BenKail





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.