HARRISBURG — The election of Rep. Mark Rozzi as a House Speaker who doesn’t plan to caucus with either party raises a question of what it means to be an independent at the state Capitol.
Mr. Rozzi said he wants to provide a seat at the table for independent voters during a brief address after his surprise election with a bipartisan 115-85 vote Tuesday. He said he would hire staffers from both parties and take a policy-based approach to legislative issues that eschews partisanship.
Mr. Rozzi didn’t mention that he was reelected as a Democrat to his House seat in Berks County just two months ago or say anything about changing his voter registration from Democrat.
Mr. Rozzi’s path as an independent speaker will be tested in coming weeks as he exercises the powers of the office in such matters as appointing committee chairs and as partisan control of the House teeters with the outcome of several special elections.
The last state lawmaker to declare himself an independent pursued that identity in a different way. Former Sen. John Yudichak of Luzerne County announced he was switching from Democrat to Independent in 2019 and changed his voting registration accordingly.
Yet Mr. Yudichak caucused with the majority Republican caucus saying, “If there was an independent caucus, I would be in the independent caucus. There are only two.”
Read More
Mr. Yudichak didn’t seek reelection when his 14th District Senate seat was transferred from Luzerne County to the Lehigh Valley under legislative reapportionment.
The Capitol’s architecture reflects a long-dominant two-party structure and taxpayer money goes to operate the two party caucuses with their majority and minority leadership.
Independent lawmakers have been sparse at the Capitol. The Pennsylvania Manual lists one independent member in 1907-08 and two independent members in 1933-34.
There have been occasional third-party lawmakers, including members of the Roosevelt Party who won some seats with Teddy Roosevelt’s Bull Moose presidential campaign in 1912.
Former Senate President Pro Tempore Joseph Scarnati, R-Jefferson County, was actually elected as an independent in a three-way special election in 2000 under unusual circumstances. But Mr. Scarnati quickly returned to the Republican Party following that and began his rise to power.
Former House Speaker Dennis O’Brien, R-Philadelphia, served as a minority-party speaker from 2007-09 with Democratic support during another period when the chamber was closely divided. After Democrats padded their majority in 2008, Democrat Keith McCall of Carbon County was elected speaker. Mr. O’Brien served as minority chairman of the House Children and Youth Committee in his final term.
Mr. Rozzi’s election as an independent speaker may well serve as a national paradigm for bipartisanship, said former House Speaker William DeWeese, D-Greene, who was involved with the O’Brien ascension, on Wednesday.
DeWeese said it augurs in favor of a non-partisan approach and diminution of partisanship that can benefit incoming Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro.
Presumably being independent means Mr. Rozzi will look at issues not from a partisan point of view but more from the policy side of things, said Terry Madonna, senior fellow in residence at Millersville University.
The looming question is whether Democrats will accept Mr. Rozzi as “independent” speaker if they win the three special elections in what are traditionally Democratic districts and achieve an effective majority, added Mr. Madonna.
Republicans say the House lineup is currently 101 Republicans, 98 Democrats and one Independent.
Mr. Rozzi faces an immediate test of his commitment with the appointment of committee chairs. The speaker holds that power and traditionally consults with the leadership of both caucuses. The committee chair wields power in deciding which bills are voted upon and which bills languish in their committee.
What Mr. Rozzi does regarding the committee chairs will say it all, said DeWeese.
The questions surrounding these appointments include whether the seniority system would be scrapped and even whether one could see a mixture of Democratic and GOP committee chairs, observers said.
The House has yet to adopt operating rules for the 2023-24 session, but the numerical split on the committees would have to reflect the close divide in the House.
A group advocating for full voting rights for independent voters is excited by Mr. Rozzi’s win.
One of the goals of Independent Pennsylvanians is to pass legislation allowing registered independent voters and non-affiliated voters to vote in primaries.
Ending the closed primary system will bring Pennsylvania out of the stone age, said IP director Jennifer Bullock adding that her group has already reached out to Mr. Rozzi.
The vehicle for this last session was House Bill 1369 which got a hearing in the House State Government Committee, but no votes. Mr. Rozzi was a bill cosponsor.
Ms. Bullock said her group is concerned more with whether an elected official acts on behalf of all people and avoids partisanship than how they are registered to vote.
“We need to make sure the voice of all the people is heard,” she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.