HARRISBURG — For more than a year, state lawmakers have debated and acted upon legislation to help the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission address the bleeding of tens of millions of dollars of lost revenue due to uncollected tolls.
This effort was spurred by the disclosure in the summer of 2021 that the commission had a loss of $104 million in revenue in Fiscal Year 2020-21 due to that problem. The revenue loss for Fiscal Year 2021-22 is $155 million.
A special performance audit of the commission released last September by Auditor General Tim DeFoor offers some recommendations to stem that revenue loss.
The initial response to the toll payment problem is the final passage last week of House Bill 1486, a multi-faceted bill that lowers the threshold for triggering suspension of vehicle registrations for owners with unpaid tolls and fees, requires the commission to conduct a feasibility study of third-party processing accounts for toll collections, requires electronic push notifications to E-Z pass users within 24 hours of a transaction and requires the commission to produce an annual report to the General Assembly on the toll revenue situation.
The bill awaits Gov. Tom Wolf's action.
HB1486 is somewhat unusual for a bill with a fiscal impact since there’s no public estimate for how much revenue will be generated by lowering the registration suspension threshold.
Read More
The House Appropriations Committee fiscal note says it can’t be determined how much additional toll revenue can be collected as a result of HB1486.
“That is difficult to estimate since revenue is dependent upon factors not related to the number of vehicles suspended,” said commission spokesman Carl DeFebo.
The commission estimates that 25,000 additional vehicles would qualify for registration suspension due to unpaid toll under the provisions of HB1486.
The commission notes that it has collected $11.4 million in tolls and fees tied to 23,095 suspended registrations under Act 165 of 2016, the law that allows the suspension of registrations for unpaid tolls.
Mr. DeFebo points out this occurred during a six-year period.
The estimates for an earlier version (House Bill 2139) of this legislation are that more than 23,000 registrations would be suspended.
“The uncollected toll amount (tolls and fees) associated with those (23,000) registrations totaled more than $18.1 million,” according to Mr. DeFoor’s performance audit. “Using a lower threshold for initiating registration suspension requests would help the Commission to collect unpaid tolls, however, it will not necessarily assist in collecting tolls from those whose registrations have already been suspended under the current criteria.”
The turnpike commission said HB1486 will authorize it to pursue toll cheats more swiftly.
“The legislation will allow us to better hold accountable those who intentionally cheat the system,” said Commission CEO Mark Compton.
The bill lowers the dollar threshold from $500 to $250 in unpaid tolls and fees that prompt vehicle registration suspensions, lowers the unpaid Toll By Plate invoices or violations from six to four, and extends the statute of limitations for unpaid invoices or violations from three years to five years.
“We need to pursue nonpaying drivers before their toll obligation exceeds the $500 mark and potentially hampers their ability to pay up,” said Mr. Compton.
HB1486 includes provisions from bills that generated in the Senate. These include the feasibility study looking at third-party processing for toll collection apps (like Apple Pay, Venmo, etc.) and the annual report on toll collections.
“Today, we offer E-ZPass and Toll By Plate customers six ways to pay: by mail, by phone, online, using the PA TOLL Pay mobile app, through the cash-payment network and by walk-in at our Harrisburg Customer Service Center,” said Mr. Compton. “E-ZPass remains the easiest, least-expensive way to pay on the PA Turnpike.”
DeFoor spokeswoman April Hutcheson said without commenting specifically on HB1486: “Our audit of the Pennsylvania Turnpike did highlight 23 recommendations which included better enforcement measures to collect unpaid tolls. The Pennsylvania Turnpike currently holds more debt than all of state government combined, and it is going to take many innovative solutions to right that ship without putting the burden solely on travelers. Closing loopholes that allow for travelers to avoid paying tolls is a good first step.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.