John Fetterman, the Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate in Pennsylvania, said he will go toe-to-toe with Republican Mehmet Oz in a televised Nexstar debate on Oct. 25, two weeks out from the November election.
But that doesn’t mean the saga — the debate about the debates — is over.
Mr. Oz, who’s been pressing Mr. Fetterman for weeks to commit to a series of at least five debates, had indeed firmed up plans with Nexstar — but his campaign was naming the date as Oct. 5.
Nexstar’s affiliates reported Wednesday that Mr. Oz had not yet agreed to the Oct. 25 date.
In a statement Wednesday afternoon, the Oz campaign said they will accept the Oct. 25 debate invitation if certain conditions are met.
The campaign said they were told by Nexstar that Mr. Fetterman asked for closed captioning during the debate — a measure that would help his auditory processing problems. Mr. Fetterman is continuing to recover from a stroke he suffered in May.
Read More
Mr. Oz will accept, his campaign said, if a moderator explains to the audience “at the top of the debate” that Mr. Fetterman is using a closed captioning system, and if the debate is extended from 60 minutes to 90 minutes since there may be a delay between Mr. Fetterman being asked a question and him responding.
Another condition, the Oz camp said in a press release, is that the questions asked of Mr. Fetterman in any practice debate sessions — to give Mr. Fetterman some familiarity with using the closed caption system — bear no resemblance to the actual questions asked in the debate.
In a statement, Casey Contres, Mr. Oz’s campaign manager, said Mr. Fetterman’s commitment — to a debate that was originally scheduled for Oct. 5 — comes after “massive criticism from state and national editorials and commentators for ducking.” He said Mr. Oz will continue to push for more debates, including ones that are sooner.
“Pennsylvania voters should not have to wait until October 25th to hear from their candidates,” Mr. Contres said. “And while John Fetterman continues to mostly campaign from his basement, Doctor Oz will continue to rigorously campaign in every corner of the Commonwealth.”
In response to Mr. Oz’s conditions, a senior advisor to the Fetterman campaign accused the Republican of continuing to move the goalposts on his debate asks, alleging that instead of a debate, “what he really wanted was a distraction.”
“Oz agreed to a 60-minute Nexstar debate. Then we agreed to a 60-minute Nexstar debate. Now, suddenly 60 minutes isn’t good enough, and he’s demanding 90,” advisor Rebecca Katz said in a statement. “Let’s be real: If we agreed to 10 debates, Oz would be demanding 20. He’s going to keep trying to move the goalposts, because this is his only play.”
Though Oct. 25 is currently up in the air, Mr. Fetterman’s announcement marks the latest development in a back-and-forth about debates that, at times, has gotten confrontational.
Mr. Fetterman’s team said Mr. Oz’s debate requests were a stunt, intended to change the conversation and gain momentum in a rough stretch for the campaign.
Mr. Oz, on the trail and in appearances on national television, has repeatedly accused Mr. Fetterman of hiding from voters, either because he wants to take cover from his “radical” positions or because he’s not healthy enough.
Mr. Fetterman’s campaign has said he’s up for debating Mr. Oz, just not on the Republican’s terms.
Last week, Mr. Fetterman told Politico that he’d commit to one debate with Mr. Oz — on a major TV station “sometime in the middle to end of October” — and that he was still discussing accommodations for his auditory processing problems.
That could include the use of a closed captioning monitor, he said, so he doesn’t miss any words. In an interview with the Post-Gazette in July, he said he struggles with his hearing sometimes and may “miss a word” or “slur two together,” but he said it doesn’t happen often and that he was working with a speech therapist.
“We’re absolutely going to debate Dr. Oz, and that was really always our intent to do that,” Mr. Fetterman told Politico. “It was just simply only ever been about addressing some of the lingering issues of the stroke, the auditory processing, and we’re going to be able to work that out.”
The Fetterman campaign said the Nexstar debate would reach the highest number of viewers, and would be carried live on local network affiliates covering every Pennsylvania voter in all 67 counties. It would air on nine TV stations, including WPXI in Pittsburgh.
The Democrat’s team also said that Mr. Fetterman has no problems with the moderators explaining that he’s using closed captioning, and noted that Mr. Oz, in August, offered to work with him to “figure out how we can actually have a debate format that addresses your issues around your stroke.”
On Twitter, Mr. Oz wrote to his followers that he doesn’t see why his conditions are unreasonable and — likely referring to his request for a 90-minute debate — said he wants voters to hear them debate “rather than waiting for people to type closed captions.”
Mr. Oz had made the case that Mr. Fetterman should debate sooner because absentee ballots are going out to voters next week. His campaign repeated that argument on Wednesday, saying that an Oct. 25 date would “keep voters in the dark as long as possible.”
Countering that argument, the Fetterman camp is saying that during the COVID-impacted 2020 election in which historic numbers voted by mail, 83% of ballots in Pennsylvania were cast in the final two weeks leading up to the election.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.