April showers typically bring May flowers. Or, in the case of the U.S. Census, the decennial population count often brings wrangling over redistricting — the complex process of redrawing districts for the U.S. House and state legislatures.

Jonathan Cervas has followed such quarreling, which often turns into lawsuits, for years as a rising academic and has helped resolve some suits. Among the cases followed this spring by Mr. Cervas, 37, was in New York, where an independent commission had stalled and Democratic lawmakers passed maps of their own.

A request for Mr. Cervas arrived in April from Patrick McAllister, an acting justice on the State Supreme Court for Steuben County, a rural area near the Finger Lakes.

Would Mr. Cervas redraw the state’s 26 U.S. House and 63 state Senate districts? And do so in about a month, essentially a New York minute in what’s often a long, drawn-out process?

Advertise with us

“It’s like you’re a minor league baseball player, you never know when you’re going to be called up to the major leagues,” said Mr. Cervas, a Pittsburgh native. “Sometimes you just get the tap on the shoulder.”

A postdoctoral fellow at Carnegie Mellon University, he has worked for years to hone his mapping skills, and served in leading roles this year for two major states. Pennsylvania’s commission hired him as a consultant to assist in redrawing 253 legislative districts, and the New York judge picked him to lead efforts in the Empire State.

Mr. Cervas said he’s proud to use his academic studies in a way that he feels benefits voters and democracy.

“I don’t think anything has ever made me more proud than to restore or help — in some part, small or large — a voter’s undiluted vote,” he said.

‘No obvious path’

Advertise with us

Mr. Cervas — the son of a Giant Eagle curbside pickup clerk, who now works with people who know the supermarket chain’s executives — said it was not clear that he would get into politics.

He said his “apolitical” mother admitted to him that she voted for the first time in November 2020. His dad would regularly vote, and Mr. Cervas would join him to watch the news.

The Cervas family also experienced upheavals common to many Pennsylvania families in the 1980s. His parents grew up in the North Hills and the family hopped between Cranberry, Slippery Rock and ultimately Las Vegas, while he was growing up.

Mr. Cervas said living in a variety of places gives him a “different perspective” than other people. He added his journey — leaving as the son of parents without a college education, before returning as part of the eds and meds class — in some ways highlights the region’s economic changes in recent years.

Mr. Cervas came of age politically during the early aughts, and remembers following the 2000 presidential election as his first political experience. Late-night comedy soon became central to his political upbringing and “really fortified” his beliefs. He watched every episode of “The Daily Show With Jon Stewart” and “The Colbert Report,” and books from the two comedians rest on his bookshelf at CMU.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cervas began as an undergraduate political science major in 2003 at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, though was unsure what he wanted to do after college. He picked up bartending on the side, but ultimately found it wasn’t right for him.

“When I wasn’t working, I’d be on my computer running data, looking at elections, and already had this interest in politics that kept manifesting itself even while I was doing other things,” he said.”

Mr. Cervas said UNLV professor David Damore pushed him to learn how to use Geographic Information Systems software — a type of computer program that lets users merge different groups of information to create custom maps. He quickly took an interest in the software.

He decided to try to make a career where he could “meld” his hobbies. Mr. Cervas continued his studies at the University of California, Irvine, but faced what he described as a “huge disadvantage, in some ways,” while navigating the graduate school admissions process. No one in his immediate family has a college degree.

Jonathan Cervas, a redistricting expert and post-doctoral fellow at Carnegie Mellon University Friday, Aug. 12, 2022 in Pittsburgh. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Bernard Grofman, a professor and well-respected redistricting academic, noticed Mr. Cervas’ mapping skills after he sat in on one of Mr. Grofman’s classes at UCI. He would become a key mentor to Mr. Cervas, and they’d work together on court cases where Mr. Grofman was appointed special master — someone appointed by a court to carry out specific tasks on its behalf.

Advertise with us

“I think of him as a star in academic terms,” Mr. Grofman said, “and one of the people who’s going to be — over the next several decades — one of the handful of leading redistricting scholars and redistricting consultants slash sometimes special masters.”

‘Problems of democracy’

Mr. Cervas focuses his work on what he describes as the “problems” and “challenges” of democracy — figuring out the best way to structure a government where the public can rule itself.

Everything from the “bizarre institution” that is the Electoral College to state boundaries to the potential use of ranked-choice voting could be considered challenges, he said.

Mr. Cervas said it was hard for him to imagine why any American wouldn’t be interested in improving their government. But a key reason why he’s stuck with the field is because he finds American democracy to be “troubled” right now.

Advertise with us

He pointed to Republican-led redistricting efforts in states like Georgia, Florida, Alabama and Louisiana that he said “absolutely failed to draw what are legally required districts,” under federal law. He said many Americans shouldn’t be “so callous” as to let hard-won rights become diminished or slip away.

“They’re going to be allowed to hold elections using the lines that were drawn in ways that were ruled unconstitutional,” he said. “I mean, I don’t even have words to describe how troubling that is. We’re not talking about ones that we think might be unconstitutional, or think might be illegal. These are maps that were ruled by federal courts to be illegal.”

Growing visibly uncomfortable while talking about such efforts — including in Ohio, where he said some were “defying the rule of law in order to create advantage for their political party” — Mr. Cervas wondered aloud what could happen if democracy is “undermined.”

“Where will that lead us to?” he said. “We have examples in the world where democracy has declined, has regressed — and the outcomes are not good.”

Mr. Cervas said he believes the country has come a long way, but Americans need to put in more work to make democracy better.

Advertise with us

“Democracy is the only system of government — the only system — that is legitimate,” he said. “How to best create a democracy is still something that we should continue to question.”

‘Democratized the process’

Mr. Cervas said redistricting has emerged in recent years from smoke-filled rooms to the public sphere, with meaningful ways for the public to influence proposals.

Chairman Mark Nordenberg, second left, listens to House Majority Leader Kerry Benninghoff, R-Centre, speaks during a meeting of the Pennsylvania Legislative Reapportionment Commission at the Capitol in Harrisburg, Pa., Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021. (Matt Rourke / Associated Press)

Redistricting software has also become easier to use, and more approachable for people who aren’t experts. One of the most prominent free websites is Dave’s Redistricting App, and another is Philadelphia-based DistrictBuilder.

Mr. Cervas said he built his New York maps in DRA, and the Pennsylvania maps also significantly depended on the website. Members of the public can now use the same tools as the pros, which he said levels the playing field.

Advertise with us

He said people “unattached from the political interests” submitted dozens of maps in Pennsylvania and New York. Mr. Cervas said there were also many informal comments about draft maps that helped improve the final product — such as when someone posted a tweet pointing out that Scranton was split four ways, something done “accidentally.”

“I think we took many good ideas away from those submissions,” he said. “I think just even the idea of people understanding the process and those tools, helping for people to understand that process, is very valuable.”

Pulling a book off his shelf at CMU, Mr. Cervas said factors in redistricting often balance against each other, making it impossible to “optimize on every single thing.” Mr. Cervas added that his mentor, Mr. Grofman, likes to compare redistricting to juggling.

“With many different objects in the air, of different sizes and weights. And some of them are on fire. And sometimes it’s like adding a penny into the mix. And so you have all these things, simultaneously, you’re juggling,” he said. “Maybe you could call that art. An artist has many colors on their palette, and they’re trying to find the right mixture of those things. Or you could call it science because, like a chemist, you have to try and find the right balance. … But like art, there is not one objective truth, there’s not one objective right answer.”

Evening drives on the turnpike

Advertise with us

After working under Mr. Grofman, the student has become the teacher as Mr. Cervas has taken on major roles in redistricting.

Mark Nordenberg, the University of Pittsburgh’s chancellor emeritus, led the commission redrawing Pennsylvania’s state legislative districts over the last year. He said Mr. Cervas contributed strong technical and academic skills, something especially sought after, but also helped establish the tone of the work.

“He has, throughout his life, maintained contact with ordinary people and understands what they might want out of the political process,” Mr. Nordenberg said. “The contributions that he made went far beyond the technical and far beyond the academic, to include common-sense judgments and a deep concern about the overall well-being of people, and our commitment to being fair to people.”

While much of the work happened in Harrisburg, Mr. Nordenberg said many important conversations would happen while driving three hours home on the Pennsylvania Turnpike.

“The discussions that we had were sometimes as focused as sharing ideas about particular districts or communities. Very often though, they involved larger issues of the law, and what it would mean to apply the law fairly in a particular part of the commonwealth,” he said, adding the chats would sometimes be peppered by another team member, who was becoming an amateur turnpike expert, sharing a fact or two about the road.

Advertise with us

The commission ultimately approved the maps by a bipartisan vote, 4-1, and the state Supreme Court later signed off unanimously. State Rep. Kerry Benninghoff, R-Centre, who was the sole vote on the commission against approving the maps, is now suing the commission at the U.S. Supreme Court and alleges race was too large a factor in the maps’ creation.

Speaking generally about the final maps, Mr. Cervas said he thinks they don’t dilute votes and is “very proud” of them.

“I think we should have plans that allow voters to have real choices — undiluted, non-dilutive, undiluted choices — so they can make real choices and have representation that really reflects their own values,” he said. “And that the maps themselves shouldn’t be putting their thumb on the scale.”

A New York month

The work as a top deputy in Pennsylvania became something of an opening act for Mr. Cervas’ role this spring as chief of the quick-turn operation in New York.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cervas got to work in April to form a small mapping team, which soon began working as many as 14 hours in a day. Much work and many draft maps had already been completed in New York, and Mr. Cervas described the task as “to organize them and take from those the best ideas.”

“It was a lot of intense work for a short amount of time, but that has never stopped me in the past,” he said. “I don’t mind having the pressures. I think in some ways the pressure can be beneficial.”

Mr. Cervas ended up hiring Mr. Grofman to help out as a consultant — a reversal in roles which Mr. Grofman said was “delightful.”

“A goal of any faculty member is to have students who are at least as good, and preferably better, who are going to perform and be major contributors in research — or in this case, in the world of practical affairs,” he said. “For me, it was a delight to be working with Jonathan, as opposed to Jonathan working with and for me. Because I thought, gee, this is the way it’s supposed to be — this is, now, Jonathan’s career is launched.”

Top Democrats — including Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, a potential successor to U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi — assailed Mr. Cervas as an “unelected, out-of-town special master” wreaking havoc. The redrawn maps have forced uncomfortable battle lines for many Democrats, who dominate the state’s politics.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cervas said the remark made for a “nice talking point,” but didn’t give it much stock.

“I actually really strongly feel that neutrality is extremely important in the creation of district lines,” he said, “because when you’re not neutral you lead to bad outcomes, or outcomes that are at least worse for voters than otherwise.”

Through a spokesman, Justice McAllister declined an interview request to talk about working with Mr. Cervas.

Mr. Cervas said those chosen by courts to lead redistricting efforts are typically senior professors – and he doesn’t necessarily consider himself to be among their ranks.

“Even to this day, I sometimes find it to be a little hard to believe that my career has been propelled so quickly,” he said. “Last year, I was thinking of the idea of working for courts and to help to try to police egregious behavior — that this would be something that would happen in the next decade. But instead, it happened this decade.”

Jon Moss: mosspg412@gmail.com; Twitter: @mossjon7.