HARRISBURG — Former elected officials and government experts told a panel of state lawmakers that Pennsylvania’s primary system should be opened to voters who are not registered to a political party, arguing the status quo disenfranchises 1.3 million people.
Pennsylvania is one of nine states that has closed primary elections, meaning only registered Democrats and Republicans can vote for candidates from those parties and choose who will advance to the general election.
Two bills awaiting consideration in the state Legislature would change that by allowing independent voters to choose one major party’s primary to participate in. Both bills have bipartisan support, as have similar efforts in the past.
In 2019, the state Senate voted 42-8 to advance open primary legislation, but the bill failed to move in the state House.
During a Tuesday hearing of the House State Government Committee, supporters of changing the system pointed to the increasing number of independent voters in the state. Between 2016 and 2020, unaffiliated voters increased nearly 10% — outpacing growth in both Democratic and Republican party registrations.
People not registered with a major party aren’t completely shut out of primaries. They are able to vote on proposed constitutional amendments and other nonpartisan ballot questions during those elections. And all registered voters can pick any candidate on their ballots during the November elections.
Read More
But advocates for open primaries argue that the current restrictions disenfranchise around one-third of the electorate and amount to a modern form of taxation without representation, as Pennsylvania’s primary elections are publicly funded.
Closed primaries also effectively exclude independent voters in some parts of the state from choosing their elected officials. In 2020, more than one-third of the races for the Pennsylvania state House and Senate had uncontested general elections — meaning the races were effectively decided in the primary.
“If you don’t cast a ballot in the primary, nobody’s going to campaign to you. No one’s going to try to get your vote,” said John Opdycke, president of Open Primaries, a national nonprofit that opposes closed primaries. “So allowing independents to vote in the primary at least creates an opportunity.”
Advocates also contend that independents could serve as a moderating force in primary races, as candidates would need to appeal to a group outside of their base.
Some Republican state House lawmakers voiced concerns Tuesday about whether the new system would allow “party raiding,” wherein unaffiliated voters strategically use their vote to pick an unelectable candidate or one who doesn’t represent a party’s values.
State Rep. Paul Schemel, R-Franklin, said primaries are an internal party activity and should exclude anyone who isn’t registered with the party. Without evidence, he hypothesized that independents could somehow vote in both Democratic and Republican primaries during the same election cycle.
He said the purpose of a primary is for both parties to determine who their own candidates for the general election are. He said parties should have the right to determine their own destiny. All voters can participate in a primary by registering with one of the two parties, he added.
David Thornburgh — chair of Ballot PA, a project of the good-government organization Committee of 70 — pushed back, saying that the underlying constitutional right to vote overshadows any justification to exclude independent voters.
“To my mind,” he said, “the right to vote … is more important than party preferences.”
Not letting independents vote in primaries is taxation without representation, he added.
“It chips away at a sacred right: their chance at a fair say in how their local, school, county, state and federal taxes are spent,” he said. “At the same time, these voters have to pay for the elections that shut them out.”
Former state auditor general Jack Wagner also testified in support of the bills.
Mr. Wagner, a former Pittsburgh city councilman and state senator who is the founder of the nonprofit Pittsburgh Hires Veterans, said veterans are at the center of the issue over expanding voting opportunities for independents.
“The veteran population is locked out today, 51% of the time, when it comes to voting,“ said Mr. Wagner. About half of veterans identified themselves as independents in a national Pew Foundation study five years ago, he added.
Letting these independent veterans vote in primaries is a way of saying 'welcome home,’ he said.
HB 1369, the open primary bill, is sponsored by Rep. Christopher Quinn, R-Delaware.
Under existing state law, a registered voter can change party registration up to 15 days before an election and then change the registration back after the election.
Several panel members asked about the information given to voters about the impact of registering independent on voting access.
The traditional image of independent voters is they are less engaged, but that’s a false characterization, Mr. Opdycke said. Independents are seen as bridge builders with contacts on both sides in social media networks and, therefore, can help ease polarization in politics, he added.
HB1369 is a useful first step in the direction of fairness and voter choice, said Jennifer Bullock, coordinator of Independent Pennsylvanians, an advocacy group.
“With increased polarization and decreased voter turnout, the time is now for you to let us in joining many states that have an open or non-partisan election system,” she said.
Spotlight PA is an independent, nonpartisan newsroom powered by The Philadelphia Inquirer in partnership with PennLive/The Patriot-News, TribLIVE/Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, and WITF Public Media. Capitolwire.com contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.