Heading into the second weekend without a winner in the high-stakes Republican primary for U.S. Senate, Pennsylvania counties are starting to undertake their state-ordered recounts, Mehmet Oz is declaring himself the presumptive victor, and David McCormick, in second place, is hoping the courts will help his prospects next week.
Such is the reality of a race separated by less than 1,000 votes, ahead of a general election that may decide control of the United States Senate. While Pennsylvania Lt. Gov. John Fetterman was declared the Democrats’ winner on election night last Tuesday, Republicans still don’t have their standard-bearer.
Mr. Oz, the celebrity doctor, leads the race, and according to political experts, there’s little precedent to suggest that a recount can change the outcome of a statewide election. Still, Mr. McCormick, the former hedge fund CEO, is trying to find votes wherever he can get them.
Allegheny County officials said their recount will begin Wednesday at 8 a.m. in their North Side warehouse. Up to 75 county staffers will be sworn-in to help the effort, which will involve counting all ballots using a different device than was used for the election.
That means the mail-in ballots, counted using high-speed scanners on Election Day, will be fed through precinct scanners used for in-person votes, and vice versa, according to the county. It should take about two days, officials added.
The state ordered the recount this week, with Mr. Oz and Mr. McCormick separated by a margin of less than 0.5 percent. Counties were told they could begin their recounts as early as Friday, but must begin no later than next Wednesday.
Read More
Counties must finish their recounts by noon on June 7 and submit their results to the state by noon the following day, according to the Pennsylvania Department of State. The recount is expected to cost upwards of $1 million in taxpayer funds.
As of Friday evening, Mr. Oz was up by 921 votes, a margin of 0.07 percent. It’s unclear if there were any ballots remaining to be counted. The state said, on Wednesday, that 10,000 ballots were left, both Republican and Democrat. Since then, the state’s election website has uploaded the results of less than 800 GOP ballots.
Early Friday, Mr. Oz released a video message, thanking supporters and saying that he is “blessed to have earned the presumptive Republican nomination for the United States Senate.”
“This was a tough campaign,” Mr. Oz said in the video. “I traveled everywhere.”
There is no such thing as a presumptive nominee under state election law, the race is pending a recount and The Associated Press is yet to call the race.
Mr. McCormick is continuing to fight at the margins of the race. He’s asking both the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and Commonwealth Court to step in and compel all 67 counties to count undated mail-in ballots, which were submitted by voters without handwritten dates but were otherwise verified to have been cast on time.
The Commonwealth Court scheduled a hearing on the suit for Tuesday.
In the state Supreme Court, parties continued to file legal paperwork late this week.
Lawyers for Leigh Chapman, acting secretary of the commonwealth, wrote that the court should “exercise jurisdiction over this case now so that the status of those ballots can be promptly resolved, and the primary election’s winners can be certified based on a count of all lawfully cast ballots.”
“Potentially thousands of Pennsylvanians who voted in the 2022 primary election are at risk of having their right to vote denied because some counties may not canvass timely received absentee and mail-in ballots merely because the voter omitted an inconsequential date from the ballot’s return envelope,” Ms. Chapman’s legal team wrote.
Mr. Oz, as well as the Republican National Committee, have argued that Pennsylvania law says mail-in ballots must be dated. In a legal filing, Mr. Oz’s lawyers called Mr. McCormick’s suit “a desperate attempt to scrounge up more votes” to win the race.
“These are legitimate votes where the voter didn’t handwrite the date on them, but again, they were time-stamped,” Mr. McCormick told “The Hugh Hewitt Show” this past week. “If they were time-stamped, why would anyone want to throw those votes out?”
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com; Twitter: @julianrouth






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.