HARRISBURG — Nine candidates for governor will appear on Republicans’ primary election ballot Tuesday. In theory, the winner could capture 15% of the vote and still get the nomination — a worst-case scenario GOP leaders started seriously trying to avoid just last week.
But of the nine, only seven now are seeking votes: Two dropped out last week, in hopes of stopping front-runner state Sen. Doug Mastriano from winning the nomination. That became more difficult Saturday, though, when Mr. Mastriano picked up the powerful endorsement of former President Donald Trump.
In announcing the endorsement, Mr. Trump said Mr. Mastriano, of Franklin County, is “a fighter like few others, and has been with me right from the beginning, and now I have an obligation to be with him.”
In the last few days, Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman, of Centre County, and former U.S. Rep. Melissa Hart, of Pittsburgh’s North Hills, dropped out of the race and endorsed former U.S. Rep. Lou Barletta, of Luzerne County. But it was too late to pull their names from the ballot.
“The stakes are too high, our Republican primary is too fractured, and we need someone to come out of the Republican primary who is a proven leader, who is a uniter, who is someone who can get Democrat votes, and who can lead as a person who has a vision and the values that the people of Pennsylvania support,” Ms. Hart said last week. “I am suspending my campaign and I’m supporting Lou Barletta. We all win when we support a candidate who shares our values and shares our vision and who can win. And that candidate is Lou Barletta.”
Some GOP insiders hoped they could persuade each of the remaining candidates to support Mr. Barletta, who gained some name recognition for his unsuccessful 2018 campaign to unseat incumbent Democratic U.S. Sen. Bob Casey. Still, Republicans didn’t come together fully in support of a single candidate, with some GOP leaders, such as Senate Majority Leader Kim Ward, R-Hempfield, coming out in support of business owner Dave White, of Delaware County.
Read More
Mr. Mastriano, meantime, was crisscrossing the state, growing his grass-roots support. On Saturday, he completed a five-day trip in which he made stops in 16 different towns.
Between April and May, Mr. Mastriano jumped in the Franklin & Marshall College Poll by five percentage points, to 20%. Other polls show Mr. Mastriano’s lead much stronger, with a recent Trafalgar Group poll finding Mr. Mastriano with nearly 28% support among likely GOP voters, followed by about 18% support for Mr. Barletta.
Former U.S. Attorney Bill McSwain, of Chester County, is the endorsed candidate by Commonwealth Partners — a big money free-market lobbyist group. He raised the most money in the race, and the most in southwestern Pennsylvania, according to a Post-Gazette analysis. Mr. McSwain raised $278,225 in the Pittsburgh region, from a total of 77 contributors.
But like a thorn in the lobbyist group’s side, Mr. Trump “un-endorsed” Mr. McSwain, whom Mr. Trump as president appointed as the U.S. attorney for southeastern Pennsylvania. Mr. Trump has told his supporters not to get behind Mr. McSwain because he didn’t do “enough” to help the former president overturn the 2020 election.
Mr. Mastriano has amassed a following of conservative Christian voters from across the state. He attracted this same support in southwestern Pennsylvania, receiving more than double the individual contributions of any other candidate in the region, according to campaign finance data.
The Post-Gazette analyzed campaign contributions from the 425 ZIP codes in southwestern Pennsylvania, which had contributed a total of $726,725 as of the end of March. The contributions reflected strong support for Mr. Mastriano, who received the most individual donations -- 434 donors for a total of $93,226.
Mr. Barletta received the second-most individual donations in the region, with 147 individual donors contributing $107,469.
While the Post-Gazette’s analysis focused on southwestern Pennsylvania, it helps to paint a picture of the hotly contested race statewide. Some candidates raised millions of dollars, but from a few individual donors, such as Mr. McSwain and Mr. Corman. Mr. White, a former pipefitter, received the most support from local unions.
“I thought that some of these other candidates would have withdrawn prior to this, recognizing there was no path to victory for them,” said Sam DeMarco, the chairman of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County. “There is nothing to be gained by coming in fifth or sixth.”
‘He’s unelectable’
One of the GOP leaders hoping to stop Mr. Mastriano’s on Tuesday is Mr. DeMarco.
Why?
“We have the data and it’s showing us he’s unelectable,” Mr. DeMarco said last week.
Mr. DeMarco was discussing internal GOP polling, which is rarely publicized. Mr. DeMarco said internal polls show in a generic matchup between a Republican and Democratic gubernatorial candidate, Republicans have a four-point advantage. Substitute those candidates for Mr. Mastriano and Democratic candidate Josh Shapiro, and Mr. Mastriano is behind by eight points.
“This should be a red-wave year,” Mr. DeMarco added. “I can’t sit idly by and watch us make what I believe is a mistake.”
In an unusual twist, state Attorney General Josh Shapiro, the lone Democrat in the governor’s race, reminded voters in a recent campaign ad that Mr. Mastriano is a Trump supporter. The thinking is that Mr. Shapiro was hoping to tip the scales in favor of Mr. Mastriano in the Republican primary, believing he would be easier to beat in the general election this fall.
Democrats outnumber Republicans in Pennsylvania by almost 554,000 registered voters. Independent voters make up nearly 15% of all voters in the state, meaning the winning Republican on Tuesday would need support in November from moderate Democrats and independents.
Mr. DeMarco said he hoped Mr. Corman’s decision to leave the race would encourage other candidates to do so and support Mr. Barletta — a similarly Trump-aligned candidate.
Mr. DeMarco noted that Mr. Mastriano has gotten hardly any support from his colleagues in the state Senate. Instead, state lawmakers have thrown their support behind Mr. Barletta or Mr. White.
“I think that says all you need to know -- when the colleagues who work with him don’t support him, that should be a sign,” Mr. DeMarco added.
Mr. DeMarco endorsed Mr. White last week.
Gillian McGoldrick; gmcgoldrick@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gill_mcgoldrick






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.