HARRISBURG — Nine can­di­dates for gov­er­nor will ap­pear on Re­pub­li­cans’ pri­mary elec­tion bal­lot Tues­day. In the­ory, the win­ner could cap­ture 15% of the vote and still get the nom­i­na­tion — a worst-case sce­nario GOP lead­ers started se­ri­ously try­ing to avoid just last week.

But of the nine, only seven now are seeking votes: Two dropped out last week, in hopes of stop­ping front-run­ner state Sen. Doug Mas­tri­ano from win­ning the nom­i­na­tion. That be­came more dif­fi­cult Satur­day, though, when Mr. Mas­tri­ano picked up the pow­er­ful en­dorse­ment of for­mer Pres­i­dent Don­ald Trump.

In an­nounc­ing the en­dorse­ment, Mr. Trump said Mr. Mas­tri­ano, of Franklin County, is “a fighter like few oth­ers, and has been with me right from the be­gin­ning, and now I have an ob­li­ga­tion to be with him.”

In the last few days, Senate Pres­i­dent Pro Tem­pore Jake Cor­man, of Centre County, and for­mer U.S. Rep. Melissa Hart, of Pittsburgh’s North Hills, dropped out of the race and en­dorsed for­mer U.S. Rep. Lou Bar­letta, of Luzerne County. But it was too late to pull their names from the ballot.

Advertise with us

“The stakes are too high, our Re­pub­li­can pri­mary is too frac­tured, and we need some­one to come out of the Re­pub­li­can pri­mary who is a proven leader, who is a uni­ter, who is some­one who can get Dem­o­crat votes, and who can lead as a per­son who has a vi­sion and the val­ues that the peo­ple of Penn­syl­va­nia sup­port,” Ms. Hart said last week. “I am sus­pend­ing my cam­paign and I’m sup­port­ing Lou Bar­letta. We all win when we sup­port a can­di­date who shares our val­ues and shares our vi­sion and who can win. And that can­di­date is Lou Bar­letta.”

Some GOP in­sid­ers hoped they could per­suade each of the re­main­ing can­di­dates to sup­port Mr. Bar­letta, who gained some name rec­og­ni­tion for his unsuccessful 2018 cam­paign to un­seat in­cum­bent Dem­o­cratic U.S. Sen. Bob Ca­sey. Still, Re­pub­li­cans didn’t come to­gether fully in support of a single candidate, with some GOP lead­ers, such as Senate Ma­jor­ity Leader Kim Ward, R-Hemp­field, com­ing out in sup­port of busi­ness owner Dave White, of Delaware County.

Mr. Mas­tri­ano, meantime, was crisscross­ing the state, grow­ing his grass-roots sup­port. On Satur­day, he com­pleted a five-day trip in which he made stops in 16 dif­fer­ent towns.

Between April and May, Mr. Mas­tri­ano jumped in the Frank­lin & Mar­shall Col­lege Poll by five per­cent­age points, to 20%. Other polls show Mr. Mas­tri­ano’s lead much stron­ger, with a re­cent Tra­fal­gar Group poll find­ing Mr. Mas­tri­ano with nearly 28% sup­port among likely GOP vot­ers, fol­lowed by about 18% sup­port for Mr. Bar­letta.

Former U.S. At­tor­ney Bill McSwain, of Chester County, is the en­dorsed can­di­date by Com­mon­wealth Part­ners — a big money free-mar­ket lob­by­ist group. He raised the most money in the race, and the most in south­west­ern Penn­syl­va­nia, ac­cord­ing to a Post-Ga­zette anal­y­sis. Mr. McSwain raised $278,225 in the Pittsburgh region, from a to­tal of 77 con­trib­u­tors.

Advertise with us

But like a thorn in the lobbyist group’s side, Mr. Trump “un-en­dorsed” Mr. McSwain, whom Mr. Trump as president appointed as the U.S. attorney for southeastern Pennsylvania. Mr. Trump has told his supporters not to get behind Mr. McSwain because he didn’t do “enough” to help the former president over­turn the 2020 elec­tion.

Mr. Mas­tri­ano has amassed a fol­low­ing of con­ser­va­tive Chris­tian vot­ers from across the state. He at­tracted this same sup­port in south­west­ern Penn­syl­va­nia, re­ceiv­ing more than dou­ble the in­di­vid­ual con­tri­bu­tions of any other can­di­date in the re­gion, ac­cord­ing to cam­paign fi­nance data.

The Post-Ga­zette an­a­lyzed cam­paign con­tri­bu­tions from the 425 ZIP codes in south­west­ern Penn­syl­va­nia, which had con­trib­uted a to­tal of $726,725 as of the end of March. The con­tri­bu­tions re­flected strong sup­port for Mr. Mas­tri­ano, who re­ceived the most in­di­vid­ual do­na­tions -- 434 donors for a to­tal of $93,226.

Mr. Bar­letta re­ceived the sec­ond-most in­di­vid­ual do­na­tions in the region, with 147 in­di­vid­ual do­nors contributing $107,469.

While the Post-Ga­zette’s anal­y­sis fo­cused on south­west­ern Penn­syl­va­nia, it helps to paint a pic­ture of the hotly con­tested race statewide. Some can­di­dates raised mil­lions of dol­lars, but from a few in­di­vid­ual do­nors, such as Mr. McSwain and Mr. Cor­man. Mr. White, a former pipefitter, received the most support from local unions.

Advertise with us

“I thought that some of these other can­di­dates would have with­drawn prior to this, rec­og­niz­ing there was no path to vic­tory for them,” said Sam DeMarco, the chair­man of the Re­pub­li­can Com­mit­tee of Al­le­gheny County. “There is noth­ing to be gained by com­ing in fifth or sixth.”

‘He’s un­electable’

One of the GOP lead­ers hop­ing to stop Mr. Mas­tri­ano’s on Tues­day is Mr. DeMarco.

Why?

“We have the data and it’s show­ing us he’s un­electable,” Mr. DeMarco said last week.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeMarco was dis­cuss­ing in­ter­nal GOP poll­ing, which is rarely pub­li­cized. Mr. DeMarco said in­ter­nal polls show in a ge­neric matchup be­tween a Re­pub­li­can and Demo­cratic gu­ber­na­to­rial can­di­date, Re­pub­li­cans have a four-point ad­van­tage. Sub­sti­tute those can­di­dates for Mr. Mas­tri­ano and Demo­cratic can­di­date Josh Sha­piro, and Mr. Mas­tri­ano is be­hind by eight points.

“This should be a red-wave year,” Mr. DeMarco added. “I can’t sit idly by and watch us make what I be­lieve is a mis­take.”

In an unusual twist, state Attorney General Josh Shapiro, the lone Democrat in the governor’s race, reminded voters in a recent campaign ad that Mr. Mastriano is a Trump supporter. The thinking is that Mr. Shapiro was hoping to tip the scales in favor of Mr. Mastriano in the Republican primary, believing he would be easier to beat in the general election this fall.

Democrats outnumber Republicans in Pennsylvania by almost 554,000 registered voters. Independent voters make up nearly 15% of all voters in the state, meaning the winning Republican on Tuesday would need support in November from moderate Democrats and independents.

Mr. DeMarco said he hoped Mr. Cor­man’s de­ci­sion to leave the race would en­cour­age other can­di­dates to do so and support Mr. Bar­letta — a sim­i­larly Trump-aligned can­di­date.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeMarco noted that Mr. Mas­tri­ano has got­ten hardly any sup­port from his col­leagues in the state Senate. In­stead, state law­mak­ers have thrown their sup­port be­hind Mr. Bar­letta or Mr. White.

“I think that says all you need to know -- when the col­leagues who work with him don’t sup­port him, that should be a sign,” Mr. DeMarco added.

Mr. DeMarco endorsed Mr. White last week.

Gillian McGoldrick; gmcgoldrick@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gill_mcgoldrick