The festering war between Allegheny County’s Democratic establishment and the progressives who’ve railed against it — a battle that’s been playing out here on endorsement slate cards and campaign finance sheets in recent years — broke out into the open on Thursday with the appearance of one white-haired Vermont senator.
The physical presence of Sen. Bernie Sanders, the former Democratic presidential contender who’s become a symbol of anti-establishment fervor, brought out hundreds of supporters to the Westin on Penn Avenue, who came to pump the candidacy of state Rep. Summer Lee for Congress.
But Mr. Sanders’ trip also brought out the fury of some of the area’s biggest Democratic leaders in the hours before his appearance — those who are backing one of Ms. Lee’s opponents in the 12th District race, Pittsburgh attorney Steve Irwin.
Rep. Mike Doyle, the outgoing seat-holder, and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald deemed Mr. Sanders a do-nothing obstructionist, and Ms. Lee a candidate who will simply join him and other progressives in D.C. to talk loud, tout unrealistic policy proposals and refuse to collaborate with fellow Democrats.
Fighting back against that narrative, Mr. Sanders, from a stage in the Westin ballroom in front of a few hundred people, said Ms. Lee would have the courage — rare in D.C. — to “take on the powerful special interests who control this country.”
“As Summer has just said better than I could, at the end of the day, the only way that real change takes place is from the grassroots on up. It never takes place from the top on down,” Mr. Sanders said. “It takes place when working people stand up and say, ‘Enough is enough,’ and that’s what this campaign is about.”
Read More
“They have the money,” Mr. Sanders added. “We have the people.”
Ms. Lee, who famously got her start in state politics a few years ago by ousting a longtime Democratic incumbent, has pitched a vision for the party that’s focused more on movement-building and systemic change than it is status quo pragmatism. She’s organized around the issues of racial, environmental and economic justice and has talked of lifting up the most vulnerable.
To Mr. Irwin and his powerful surrogates on Thursday, it comes down to the ability to get things done in Washington at a time the Democratic agenda needs allies, not critics, they said. Mr. Doyle and Mr. Fitzgerald pointed to Mr. Irwin as someone who would immediately work as a partner with President Joe Biden’s administration and Democrats in Congress.
“If you want to pass laws — especially tough laws around these challenges that we’re dealing with — you have to build coalitions,” Mr. Doyle said. “You have to get outside your comfort zone and outside your base to share your vision.”
Mr. Doyle, the longest serving member of Congress in Pennsylvania who’s been in office for nearly 26 years, said when he retires, he wants his replacement to collaborate with Democrats, labor leaders, Mr. Biden’s administration and key stakeholders to continue to grow the region. That won’t happen, he said, by joining with fellow progressives and being a “crusader” who refuses to compromise.
Ms. Lee likened the attacks against her to the establishment throwing everything it can at her to stop the movement she’s helping to cultivate. She said it didn’t work when she took down the long-term Democratic state House incumbent Paul Costa in the 2018 primary, and it hasn’t worked since.
“Instead of going along to get along, we decided that there is more that we can do — that there are more people that we are going to empower and lift up,” Ms. Lee said. “We kept on coming back, cycle after cycle.”
She said the movement resulted in Pittsburgh electing its first Black mayor, Ed Gainey. Mr. Gainey, speaking at the rally, criticized super PACs for spending so heavily against Ms. Lee’s candidacy.
“The beauty of this is to show special interests that when the will of the people comes together, your money is only cents,” Mr. Gainey said.
Ms. Lee and Mr. Irwin are running in the Democratic primary against University of Pittsburgh law professor Jerry Dickinson, business owner Will Parker and nonprofit administrator Jeff Woodard.
On the Republican side, Michael Doyle — a man who has no relation to the current congressman — is running unopposed in the district that contains all of the city of Pittsburgh, much of the southern and southeastern suburbs of Allegheny County, and the western edge of Westmoreland County.
Mr. Sanders endorsed Ms. Lee in March, saying she’d be a fighter in Washington for Medicare for All, a $15 minimum wage and the Green New Deal.
“At a time of massive income and wealth inequality, at a time when the billionaire class is becoming more and more wealthy and more and more powerful, at a time when the middle class and working class are struggling, at a time when we have 600,000 Americans sleeping out on the streets, we need members of Congress who have the guts to stand up for working families,” Mr. Sanders told the crowd.
Mr. Fitzgerald, the county executive, said Mr. Sanders is the wrong messenger for Western Pennsylvania, and hypothesized that if the Vermont senator was the 2020 Democratic presidential nominee, the party would have lost the state.
He said that the right kind of Democrat negotiates to get a large chunk of the party’s agenda passed, even if it means sacrificing items on their wish list.
“For them, it’s my way or the highway,” Mr. Fitzgerald said of the “Sanders wing.” “Well, actually, it’s ‘my way or no highway,’ because the highway won’t get built if they don’t get every single thing they want.”
Mr. Fitzgerald, referencing the inner workings of the infrastructure package moving through Congress, claimed Ms. Lee would have joined “The Squad” in voting against it.
Members of “The Squad,” a small group of progressive Democrats in the House, said they voted against the $1 trillion package in an effort to force a vote on Mr. Biden’s broader Build Back Better agenda, which would have included a massive infusion of money into health, family and climate change programs.
Mr. Doyle said there would have been “real danger” in the party at-large adopting that position. Democrats may not have gotten either the infrastructure bill or Build Back Better, he said.

“We would have failed to pass the infrastructure bill if we didn’t get some Republican votes on the other side because the Squad refused to vote for that bill,” Mr. Doyle said. “You can’t have these absolute positions.”
State Rep. Jessica Benham, D-South Side, wrote on Twitter that she thought U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., was responsible for “preventing us from getting anything done on the federal level.”
In the crowd, Al Hart, a longtime member of the United Electrical Workers union who backs Ms. Lee, said that the reason Mr. Fitzgerald and Mr. Doyle warn of her ability to legislate is because they’re scared.
“I hear the old guard [is] scared that they’re losing control,” Mr. Hart said.
Ms. Lee, insisting that Democrats need to fight for change, asked why anyone in her party would want to stand in the way of clean air and water, a living wage and paid sick and family leave. She, too, remarked at the money spent against her.
“They throw millions of dollars at us. We’re going to build it anyways,” she said, referring to the movement.
“They want to throw candidates at us, but we’re going to build it anyways,” she added.
The election is May 17.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com; Twitter @julianrouth.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.