In a primary defined by millions of dollars in negative advertising and contentious statements between the leading contenders, the Republican candidates vying for U.S. Senate have found common ground in issuing dire warnings about the state of U.S. immigration policy and the security of the southern border.
They’ve even shared exact words, at times, to paint a picture — albeit incomplete — of drugs and crime pouring into Pennsylvania communities as a result of lackadaisical border enforcement.
While former hedge fund CEO David McCormick was telling the New York Post that “every state is a border state,” Dr. Mehmet Oz was on Fox News saying “every state is truly a border state.” Then it was Jeff Bartos this past week in comments to the Post-Gazette, warning that “every state is a border state.”
Though not all of their rhetoric aligns with the reality of current border and immigration policy, it’s clear they’ve taken notice of a key statistic among the GOP primary voters they’re trying to court in one of the most important senate races in the country. That amid all of the talk about COVID-19 lockdowns and natural gas production, immigration and border enforcement are — by far and away — two of the most important issues on the minds of Pennsylvania Republicans who will pick a nominee.
A recent Fox News survey of GOP primary voters here — the same poll that found Mr. McCormick leading Mr. Oz by 9 points, with conservative commentator Kathy Barnette, Mr. Bartos and former U.S. ambassador Carla Sands rounding out the pack — revealed that more voters say immigration issues (53%) will be “extremely important” in their decision than those who cite social issues (38%) and COVID-19 policies (29%).
And to intensify the stakes even more for these GOP contenders, nearly one-third of primary voters (31%) said they were unsure which candidate they’d support — a trend that’s hit other polls, too. It’s created a rhetorical atmosphere in which drawing a hard line on illegal immigration and border security is the bare minimum — even as some push back on the lengths to which they’ll go to prove their bonafides.
Read More
Leading the field in recent polling, Mr. McCormick hasn’t shied away from the topic. His campaign says he’s the only candidate in the field to have visited the border in this primary — a venture he took in February to accept the endorsement of the head of the Border Patrol union.
A spokeswoman for Mr. McCormick’s campaign said he will restore former President Donald Trump’s “America First” policies to secure the southern border.
“On day one, Dave will support legislation that would finish Trump’s border wall, provide needed resources to our dedicated border patrol officials, and stop terrible catch-and-release policies,” McCormick campaign spokeswoman Jess Szymanski told the Post-Gazette this past week.
President Joe Biden did put a stop, earlier in his term, to construction of Mr. Trump’s border wall. The former president oversaw the building of 458 miles of new barriers, mostly in remote areas of Arizona and New Mexico, The Washington Post reported.
But in his new budget proposal last week, Mr. Biden pitched $15.3 billion in funding to Customs and Border Protection and $8.1 billion to ICE — increases that amount to about 13% and include $309 million for border security technology. It also provides $19 million for border fencing and other infrastructure, according to The New York Times.
As for the concept of catch and release, statistics show that the Biden administration, from the president’s first day in office through last December, used a Trump-era public health rule more than a million times to turn away migrants at the southern border, The Times reported. Of nearly two million encounters at the border, 458,000 migrants were allowed to enter the country under the requirement that they persuade an immigration judge to let them stay.
Mr. Biden repealed that public health rule this past week, as immigration and human rights advocates have argued that it’s been used improperly as an enforcement tool, the Times reported. News reports have anticipated a surge in migration as a result. Kevin McCarthy, the top Republican in the House, warned that it will worsen the situation on the border and overwhelm the Border Patrol.
Mr. McCormick, like his primary opponents, has described the current state of the Biden administration’s border enforcement as a breeding ground for lawlessness, allowing drugs to infiltrate communities and cartels to grow in size and strength.
In a visit to Wexford in February, he met with local law enforcement officers to talk specifically about drug trafficking as a result of people illegally crossing the southern border, Pittsburgh Public Radio outlet WESA reported. Though Butler County Sheriff Mike Slupe did tell Mr. McCormick that local law enforcement needed “military-like equipment” to offset “what the cartel can bring in,” he said his office has not specifically seen cartel activity in the county, according to WESA.
Mr. Oz has repeatedly criticized U.S. border policy, too. He told Fox News that people here are concerned because it “speaks to the broken covenant between Americans and our government” — that Americans pay taxes and obey the law in exchange for a secure border. He, too, has warned of cartels and human trafficking, and calls for the completion of a physical wall at the border — or one patrolled by technological advances.
“Under Joe Biden, we are witnessing dangerous open border policies that completely undermine the Rule of Law, allowing for the free flow of harmful Chinese fentanyl into America, and turning Pennsylvania into a border state by sending illegal immigrants into our communities in the dark of night,” Oz spokeswoman Brittany Yanick told the Post-Gazette, adding that Mr. Oz will serve as a line of defense in the Senate to prevent “dangerous drugs from reaching our streets.”
Border officials — at the request of Congress — are trying to combat the surge of fentanyl into the U.S. by coming up with a plan to scan 100% of arriving vehicles, according to The Washington Post. The drugs — entering the country at a time when more than 100,000 Americans are dying each year from overdoses — are hidden in commercial loads, typically.
Mr. Bartos, in a statement to the Post-Gazette, said he’s the only candidate to release a real policy plan with solutions, not buzzwords — and talked of the need to finish the wall, defund sanctuary cities, and repair the “broken” legal immigration system.
While U.S. Customs and Border Protection officials have acknowledged that nearly 1,000 people — as of reports a year ago — are sneaking into the U.S. per day without being identified or taken into custody, the agency reported more than 1.6 million encounters with migrants along the border in the 2021 fiscal year. That was the highest annual total on record, according to a Pew Research Center analysis.
Mr. Bartos credited Mr. Trump with implementing “common-sense immigration policies” and criticized Mr. Biden for working to overturn them.
“The Biden administration has shown no urgency to deal with their self-created border chaos that is affecting all Americans,” Mr. Bartos said.
Ms. Barnette’s campaign said the reason GOP voters care about immigration is because they want secure borders to prevent criminals and drugs from pouring into the country and social services from being overrun.
Ms. Sands, who didn’t respond to a request for comment, has released an advertisement in which she vows to protect people by fighting for “America First” border policies, and said she’d fight to build the Trump border wall.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com; Twitter: @julianrouth






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.