The leader of the House Republican caucus in Pennsylvania asked the state’s highest court on Thursday to throw out the proposed legislative maps and order that the 2022 elections for state House and Senate be held under the current maps.
In official legal documents, House Majority Leader Kerry Benninghoff, R-Centre, is urging the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to deem the maps unconstitutional and give them back to the Legislative Reapportionment Commission again — this time to pass a plan that doesn’t “eviscerate” the principle that voters choose their representatives, not the other way around, the filing reads.
Mr. Benninghoff was the only member of the five-person commission to vote against the maps when they passed earlier this month, calling them an “extreme partisan gerrymander.” The once-a-decade redistricting process decides the boundaries of 50 state Senate and 203 state House seats.
University of Pittsburgh chancellor emeritus Mark Nordenberg, chair of the commission, told the Post-Gazette last week that he thought the body produced fair maps that help reverse years of baked-in advantages, better reflecting the reality of Pennsylvania’s changing population and intricate political landscape.
The GOP leader counters, in court, that the maps improperly maximize the number of Democrat-leaning districts and do not adhere to constitutional criteria. He said because of the legal problems he cites, there’s a chance that not all issues will be sufficiently resolved in time to give voters and candidates certainty about the district lines — and that as a remedy, the court should demand the 2022 elections for General Assembly be held under the current maps.
“The request to run in the current legislative districts is in line with past precedent and reflects the dual realities of this plan's significant legal challenges and the need to have certainty in the conduct of the 2022 elections,” Mr. Benninghoff said in a statement.
Read More
The legal filings by Mr. Benninghoff were expected. The commission’s passing of the final maps in early February kicked off a 30-day period for court challenges, and the Republican leader had repeatedly blasted the maps publicly as unconstitutional.
To Mr. Benninghoff’s claims that the House map engineers favorable outcomes for Democrats, Mr. Nordenberg said last week that the map continues to favor the GOP, albeit by a less significant margin than the earlier map did. Most of the changes reflected the dramatic shift in population from rural areas in the north and west to the more urban areas of Pennsylvania, the chairman added.
The chair of a key redistricting advocacy group said last week that data shows in a hypothetical 50/50 state House election, the maps have gone from an extra 15 Republican seats to an extra five Republican seats — still an advantage for the GOP, but “much smaller.” Currently, the Republicans hold a 112-88 advantage in the House. There are 3 vacancies.
“I am proud of the final map, which fares very well when measured against the traditional reapportionment criteria in the state constitution,” Mr. Nordenberg said, “but also is fairer in terms of the opportunities of either party to seek a majority.”
Mr. Nordenberg said Mr. Benninghoff, like other caucus leaders on the commission, was a political leader who had an incentivized interest in the outcome of the mapping process, and as such, “saw the map as not preserving enough of the advantages that were built into the map that was enacted 10 years ago.”
The Republican leader had responded that his concerns were actually based on the chairman’s willingness to use race as a predominant factor to create districts, alleging that rather than helping minority communities, the plan maximizes Democratic opportunities.
He repeated that criticism in the new court filings, saying there was no evidence that drawing districts on the basis of race was justified — and even so, the final plan “unnecessarily reduces minority voting strength in many areas rather than increasing it.”
Mr. Nordenberg told the Post-Gazette that the maps give power to minority groups to influence elections, noting that much of the population growth in the last decade in the state came from within minority communities, particularly among Hispanics.
Mr. Benninghoff is arguing to the court that the final maps split communities of interest, too, including in Harrisburg, Lancaster, State College and Montgomery County.
“As a commissioner on the Pennsylvania Legislative Reapportionment Commission, I have been vocal throughout the state redistricting process about these glaring legal issues,” Mr. Benninghoff said, summarizing the filings. “It is clear the only way to remedy these obvious flaws now is for the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to send this plan back to the drawing board.”
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com; Twitter @julianrouth






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.