In closing arguments in Butler County family court on Tuesday, a lawyer representing the estranged wife of U.S. Senate candidate Sean Parnell said his “long history of anger and bad behavior” has inhibited his ability to parent, while his lawyer framed him as an “enthusiastic” father with a flexible work schedule and clean parenting record.
Wrapping up the final day of a case that will decide custody of their three children, Mr. Parnell and Laurie Snell closed the books on a three-day hearing by defending their roles as parents and accusing one another of being irresponsive and acting unilaterally without the other’s input.
It culminated in five-minute closing arguments, in which Mr. Parnell’s attorney, Kristen Eberle, said her client is not accused of “even a stitch” of hostility or abuse that took place in the aftermath of a custody order in April 2019, when the parties agreed to share physical and legal custody.
Ms. Snell’s attorney, Jill Sinatra, said Mr. Parnell has a history of “explosive anger and abuse” — issues that have “plagued this family for many years.”
Before closing arguments, Tuesday’s session drilled down into the details of Mr. Parnell’s relationship with Ms. Snell and their children, examining his emphatic denial that he was physically abusive.
Mr. Parnell, an Army veteran whose custody battle has emerged as a character reference, of sorts, for his national political campaign, was questioned extensively by Ms. Snell’s attorney about two alleged incidents with his children. One, in which he was said to have slapped one of their children hard enough to leave fingerprint-shaped welts on his back through the child’s shirt; and another, in which he is alleged to have punched a closet door so hard that it flew into another of their child’s face, leaving a bruise.
Read More
Shown a picture that Ms. Snell claims to be their son’s bare back with fingerprint-shaped welts taken shortly after the alleged incident, Mr. Parnell said the incident didn’t happen, and twice said, “That’s not a picture of my son.”
As Ms. Snell’s lawyer sought to point out consistencies between the background of the photo and the boy’s room from real estate appraisal pictures, Mr. Parnell testified that he didn’t see the similarities, including colors of the walls, carpet and baseboard.
“I can’t tell what color that is. They look black,” Mr. Parnell said of the walls in the photo, testifying that it was different than the light blue color of the walls in the appraisal.
Asked if the mole in the photo matches a mole on his son’s back, Mr. Parnell said he couldn’t see the mole in the picture and didn’t know what the mark was.
In her closing argument, Ms. Sinatra said Mr. Parnell denied he could see “what is very clearly a mole” in the picture.
On the incident with the closet door, Mr. Parnell repeated his testimony from Monday that Ms. Snell was not present — and that what really happened wasn’t a result of anger, but an accident.
On Monday, he had testified that as he was changing to go to the gym, his son’s head popped around the closet door. His reaction startled the child, Mr. Parnell said, and his son pulled his head back and bumped it on the door. Allegations that he slammed his head as a result of an angry punch could “not be further from the truth,” Mr. Parnell testified.
Ms. Snell’s lawyer noted that in a separate protection-from-abuse hearing, Mr. Parnell testified that during the alleged incident, Ms. Snell was in her office — which she said is connected to the master bedroom and in full view of the closet where the incident would have happened.
Mr. Parnell characterized Ms. Snell’s office as a separate room with no view of the incident that happened in the closet.
Accused by Ms. Snell of choking her, hitting their children and lashing out at her with obscenities and insults, Mr. Parnell had taken the stand Monday to repeatedly and emphatically deny that he physically abused his wife or children. He described his relationship with Ms. Snell as “tumultuous,” but never to the point he got “physical” with her.
Mr. Parnell’s lawyers called two witnesses on Tuesday who spoke to his schedule and his dedication as a father.
One was a woman who was a nanny for the Parnells for many years before their separation, and continued to work for Mr. Parnell after the separation. Asked if she’s had any concerns about Mr. Parnell being angry or having an unreasonable temper toward the children, the woman said, “No.” She also said “no” when asked if she had concerns about Mr. Parnell’s parenting or discipline before the separation, or if she thought the children ever seemed fearful of him.
During cross-examination, the nanny confirmed that Ms. Snell had confided in her that Mr. Parnell had gotten rough with the children. She also confirmed she was sent the picture purporting to show the welts on the child’s back, and said she didn’t take further action after seeing the picture.
Asked if it was Mr. Parnell’s child in the picture, the nanny testified, “I don’t know that.”
The other witness was Mr. Parnell’s current girlfriend, Melanie Rawley, who testified that he is “the best dad I’ve ever seen. He loves his kids and his kids love him.” She said his discipline of the children is mostly telling them to stop, sending them to their rooms or taking away their electronics. She said she hasn’t seen him physically punish or hit his children.
Another focal point of Tuesday’s hearing was Mr. Parnell’s claims that the case would have an impact on his children if left unsealed and open to the media and public.
Ms. Snell’s lawyer noted that once he left court on Nov. 1 — the day Ms. Snell alleged physical abuse, among other things — he posted on Facebook and said Ms. Snell’s accusations were lies. Asked if he thought about the post’s impact on his children, he said the reason he posted was because he didn’t want them to see headlines and think he’d hurt them or their mother.
Mr. Parnell is considered a leading contender for the Republican nomination in the Pennsylvania Senate race for 2022. He has been endorsed by former President Donald Trump. The seat became open when Sen. Pat Toomey decided not to seek re-election.
His availability to share custody of his children if he’s elected to the Senate — requiring frequent travel and attendance to more than 100 days in session in Washington — was examined by both lawyers.
Ms. Eberle, advocating for sole legal custody for her client, said Mr. Parnell has proven to have a flexible work schedule and that he’s able to make it work when he has events.
“He’s not just available. He’s enthusiastic about being a parent,” Ms. Eberle said.
Ms. Sinatra argued that Mr. Parnell already has several jobs, works as a writer and is frequently out of town. How, she asked, could he get the kids from school, help them with their homework and take them to their activities on a 50-50 basis if he has to be in session for a chunk of the year?
“She’s always there,” Ms. Sinatra said of her client, Ms. Snell, adding that it doesn’t make sense to keep the children in limbo. The judge should rule in favor of stability, she said.
Mr. Parnell issued a statement on Tuesday evening.
“The past week has been unquestionably the most trying in my young family’s life,” the statement read. “I love my kids, and being their father is the greatest honor I have ever had. Now that I have had the opportunity to present my case I will not have anything further to say until the judge issues his ruling.”
Butler County Senior Common Pleas Judge James Arner said he has a lot to consider and will issue a written opinion and order when he comes to his decision.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com; Twitter: @julianrouth







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.