Though Senate Republican leaders in Pennsylvania say they're the ultimate arbiters of who gets seated in their chamber, a federal judge is expected to rule soon on a lawsuit brought by a GOP candidate who lost in the 45th District but argues that a critical number of votes were invalid.
With a key deadline for briefs in the case now passed, U.S. District Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan is expected to decide Monday whether a few hundred undated ballots in Allegheny County should be voided, a move that could swing the election from incumbent Democrat Jim Brewster — who won by 69 votes — to Republican challenger Nicole Ziccarelli. He could also decide that the court doesn’t have jurisdiction to settle the issue, observers say, which could lead to a battle in Harrisburg over who’s seated.
Last week, Senate Republicans who control the chamber refused to seat Mr. Brewster alongside his fellow electoral victors, arguing that the federal case should be allowed to play out and that members should have enough time to digest Ms. Ziccarelli's complaint on their own.
In a written statement, Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman said his caucus plans to let the federal case come to its conclusion and seat whoever is successful, "as long as the findings from the court are to the merit of the challenge and the validity of the disputed ballots and not based on the lack of jurisdiction of the federal courts."
"If the federal court rules, as we believe, that the ballots should not count then we will seat Mrs. Ziccarelli immediately and if they rule ballots should count we will seat Sen. Brewster immediately," Mr. Corman said. "A subsequent appeal will not delay that seating, although it could result in further action in the future if the district court decision is not upheld."
Mr. Corman asserted that the Senate is the "ultimate authority of the election and who meets the qualifications to be seated."
"We have the power to put into place a process that would find facts and declare a lawful winner," Mr. Corman said. "But just because we have the power to do something doesn’t mean we should exercise it."
Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, criticized Mr. Corman's comments, saying that they "demonstrate a pattern of undemocratic behavior" from Senate Republicans.
“The suggestion that he would defy yet another court order in his quest to steal the 45th District from Sen. Brewster is chilling, and takes clear cues from his role model, Donald Trump," Mr. Costa said.
Ms. Ziccarell’s lawsuit argues that Allegheny County's tallying of the ballots — which were missing dates on their outer envelopes, but otherwise correct and proven to have been submitted on time — constituted due-process and equal-protection violations of the U.S. Constitution. She wants the court to toss the ballots, effectively declaring her the winner, and require Allegheny County to re-certify the race.
The county’s elections board has countered that there is "no action remaining that [the county elections board] can be enjoined from committing and no action Ms. Ziccarelli needs to obtain from [the board] in order to obtain relief." The board had certified the results of the race before Ms. Ziccarelli's suit, lawyers added.
Mr. Brewster, who's intervening in the case, argues that the federal court lacks jurisdiction to overturn a ruling by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, which has upheld the counting of the ballots.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.