Updated at 4:32 p.m. on Friday, Nov. 6, 2020:

Now on the cusp of winning the presidency, former Vice President Joe Biden took the popular vote lead in Pennsylvania on Friday morning and appeared poised to win its 20 electoral votes, with more than 95,000 mail-in ballots — a type of vote he’s carried by a 3-to-1 ratio — left to tally, as well as a potentially large number of provisional ballots.

As Philadelphia and its surrounding counties continued their mail-in counts through Thursday night into Friday morning, President Donald Trump’s lead — which was once nearly 700,000 because of the quick count of Republican-leaning in-person voting — dwindled and then diminished entirely, with Mr. Biden grabbing the lead shortly before 9 a.m.

As of shortly before 4 p.m., Mr. Biden was ahead by 13,471 votes — 49.53% to 49.33% — over Mr. Trump, in a race that’s seen more than 6.6 million voters cast ballots.

Advertise with us

The former vice president’s numbers steadily grew overnight, as counties successfully tallied about 37,200 mail-in ballots. In the previous 12 hours, mail-in votes had gone to Mr. Biden by a nearly 3-to-1 ratio. The former vice president won that new batch by a 7-to-1 margin.

The president, who had falsely declared victory in the state, needs to hold the state — which he won by about 44,000 votes four years ago — to win re-election, experts have said. A win for Mr. Biden — with other key states remaining to be called — would put him at 284 electoral votes.

The exact tabulation of remaining votes was not known and would have to take into account provisional ballots that will have to be reviewed by county election boards and ballots that were postmarked on or before Election Day and are received by 5 p.m. Friday.

More than half of the mail-in ballots that remain to tally appear to be in counties where Mr. Biden has racked up large margins up to this point.

Then, there are at least 92,500 provisional ballots that the counties will have to review and count, according to the York Daily Record. These are ballots that were cast, at in-person precincts on Election Day, by voters who either ran into problems with their eligibility or wanted to vote in-person even though they applied for a mail-in ballot.

Advertise with us

Those votes will be counted if they’re determined to be legitimate by voters’ county boards of elections, which have until next Tuesday to review them.

Lara Putnam, a University of Pittsburgh professor who studies the electoral landscape in Western Pennsylvania, said she expects the provisional ballots to “less Biden-heavy than mail-ins, but still net Biden more votes than Trump.”

Ms. Putnam said she anticipates some provisional ballots to be driven by “the usual range of factors” that more often capture Democratic than Republican voters — like age and mobility — while the rest are driven by mail-in ballot requests that have skewed heavily pro-Democrat and pro-Biden.

She also cited data compiled by Mike Johnson, data director at the Pennsylvania AFL-CIO, who noted that in June’s primary, mail-in ballot requests by Republicans were about twice as likely to end in casting a provisional ballot. If those ratios are carried through the electorate — which is a “big assumption,” Mr. Johnson noted — “we may see a pretty similar number of [Democratic] and [Republican] provisional ballots.” He said he’d guess a “slight” Democratic advantage on their outcome.

There are also an unknown number of late-arriving mail-in ballots that will be counted if they are received by mail by 5 p.m. today and were postmarked on or before Election Day. The number is shaping up to be “significantly lower” than officials had anticipated, Secretary of State Kathy Boockvar said Thursday. It’s a “fraction” of what Pennsylvania saw in the primary, she said — and that number was about 60,000.

Advertise with us

In Allegheny County, officials said they would still have to review about 35,000 mail-in and absentee ballots, but are mandated, by law and by court order, to wait until Friday to work through them.

More than 674,000 votes were counted and uploaded by the state’s second-largest county before its election workers wrapped up operations Wednesday night. Of those, Mr. Biden held a commanding lead — 58.7% to 39.7% — over Mr. Trump, a margin padded by winning the 313,000 or so mail-in ballots by about a 4-to-1 margin over his opponent.

Allegheny County, noting that there was an obvious discrepancy in the 313,000 counted mail-ins and the 348,485 it said it has received for this election, said the reason the warehouse didn’t count those on Thursday wasn’t because they’re taking a day off, but because they weren’t permitted to count the rest of them without undertaking the legally mandated process to review them.

That’s because the remaining ballots include an estimated 29,000 that are subject to review because they represent a faulty batch of incorrect ballots a third-party contractor sent to voters last month — a batch that the county has been warning, all along, would have to wait until Friday to be reviewed. To correct their mistake, the vendor sent new, corrected ballots to the affected voters — and the county agreed to segregate all of the impacted ballots, including the incorrect ones, when they received them from voters. This was mandated by court order.

The county will have to review those ballots to ensure that one vote is counted per person, and has to wait to do that until 5 p.m. Friday because they had to first swear-in a return board. Then it has to wait until the deadline passes for ballots to be received by its office by mail — which will count if they were postmarked on or before Election Day.

Advertise with us

It remains unclear how many of those 29,000 ballots will appear in the final count. It’s possible there were some cases where a voter returned both the incorrect and corrected versions.

After swearing in its return board Friday morning around 9 a.m., the county immediately began reviewing the other 6,800 mail-in ballots that remain. These include about 2,250 that “were unscannable and will need to be duplicated” and 4,350 that have other issues, such as missing dates and ineligible voters listed on their declarations.

Around 11:50 a.m. Allegheny Elections Division Manager David Voye said the process is going "smoothly," but noted there are still many ballots left to sort through.

"We are in the process of counting and tabulating 2,800 ballots that were either damaged or wouldn't go through the scanners, or (some) that our letter openers sliced in half," Mr. Voye said at the Allegheny County Warehouse. "That should be done in approximately a half hour. When that process is done, we had shipped over to our office in town now approximately 4,000 ballots that were sent in from military voters and overseas civilians."

Mr. Trump, in remarks from the White House briefing room on Thursday, opined that he was up by nearly 700,000 votes in Pennsylvania — which was true on Wednesday morning — but that his lead had dwindled. He had previously alleged that his leads in “key locations” were “getting whittled away in secret.”

Advertise with us

“I won Pennsylvania by a lot. And that gets whittled down to, I think they said now we’re up by 90,000 votes and they’ll keep coming and coming and coming,” Mr. Trump said of Pennsylvania during his remarks before 7 p.m.

The reason for Mr. Trump’s diminishing edge in the race was actually because the mail-in ballots that counties continued to process — at a slower pace than the Republican-leaning in-person vote because of an arduous counting process — were largely cast by Democrats.

“The president told people not to vote by mail,” said Chris Borick, director of the Muhlenberg College’s Institute of Public Opinion. “Democrats wanted to vote by mail.”

Meanwhile, Mr. Biden spoke briefly on Thursday and urged the public to “stay calm,” saying “there is no doubt when the count is finished,” he will be the winner.

Pennsylvania Secretary of State Kathy Boockvar, in a midday Thursday press conference, noted that while she had routinely said she expects the overwhelming majority of votes to be counted by Friday, the counties were “ahead of schedule.” She also reiterated that even after this vote count was providing more clarity in the presidential race, the counties would still have to tally provisional ballots, many military and overseas votes and those that came in after Election Day but were postmarked by Nov. 3.

Advertise with us

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com. Post-Gazette staff writer Lacretia Wimbley contributed reporting.