Whether it's more beneficial to elect a candidate who has experience owning a small business or one who has served in elected office already will be up to the Republican voters of Pennsylvania’s 37th Senatorial District on Tuesday, when party members will choose whom they want to run against incumbent Democrat Pam Iovino in November.

On one side of the primary contest is Devlin Robinson, a Marine veteran and Bridgeville small business owner who said he has personally felt the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic and ensuing shutdown — which he believes sets him apart as a GOP contender.

On the other is Sewickley Council President Jeff Neff, who served as the borough's fire chief for 15 years and says he's a true community leader whose experience in elected office — and as a youth sports coach — makes him the better choice.

The winner will face Ms. Iovino, the Mt. Lebanon Democrat who won the seat in a special election early last year after Republican Guy Reschenthaler vacated it to run successfully for the U.S. House. The district encompasses Allegheny County's western and southern suburbs, as well as Peters in Washington County.

Advertise with us

Both Republican candidates, like many others in the region, say their main pitch is that voters need someone who will stand up for them in Harrisburg — and that they're most capable.

Mr. Robinson said that means backing his constituents and not just echoing Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf's wishes, alleging that the governor thinks Pennsylvania only consists of what's east of the Appalachian Mountains.

Insisting that Allegheny and Washington counties were treated "kind of unfairly" during the COVID-19 shutdown, Mr. Robinson said his small business — a medical supply company offering equipment in the field of urology — felt the strain directly.

"My business took a hit. I felt the pain and I know that we're going to have to rebuild the economy here throughout the summer and the fall," Mr. Robinson said. "That's the type of experience I want to bring to Harrisburg."

Mr. Neff said standing up for his constituents means working across the aisle, acting not out of self-interest and caring about "the constitution being followed."

Advertise with us

"I just think we need to get back to ground zero of what our forefathers set this country out to be," Mr. Neff said. "It's going away from that and it's upsetting."

Noting that he was one of the first nationally certified firefighters in the Quaker Valley, Mr. Neff said he brought the fire department to a “whole different level,” helping the community improve its rating in an independent program that classifies fire preparedness.

On council, Mr. Neff said, he has worked with his colleagues to reverse course financially and turn the legislative body away from eventual bankruptcy. The year 2020, he said, is the first time council did not have to take out a tax anticipation note.

Mr. Robinson said his service to the community and to the district already — as well as his three combat tours in Iraq and Afghanistan in the early to mid-2000s — grounds his worldview. Though he didn’t point to specific legislative proposals or policies he would pursue in Harrisburg, he said he would focus on "building a strong economy for all workers, being a watchdog for the citizens and eliminating any type of tax increases that will be an undue burden on the business community here and the people."

If he’s elected to the state Senate, Mr. Neff said, he would fight for transparency in health care, and so people can know what it costs to have an elective surgery before it’s done, for example. He said that would make health care more affordable, and that costs are so high now “not because insurance companies are ripping people [off]” but because hospitals “charge so much for services."

Advertise with us

Mr. Neff said he's a supporter of school choice — a hard sell to the voters of the district, he claimed, because of the quality of their schools. But, he said, there are children in Pittsburgh, Harrisburg and Philadelphia who don’t get the same benefits as those in his district, and parents in those cities should have the choice to put their children in a charter school or another private school.

"As a senator, you have to look at the whole state, not just the 37th," Mr. Neff said.

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.