HARRISBURG — The state Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by onetime House Speaker Bill DeWeese of his conviction in a high-profile political corruption case that landed him in state prison for two years.

If successful, DeWeese could get a new trial, which would mark yet another example of a former legislator challenging his conviction in the several criminal cases that grew out of the so-called “Bonusgate” corruption scandal that ensnared legislators and staffers from both political parties.

The Supreme Court in an order Tuesday said it would take up DeWeese’s Post-Conviction Relief Act appeal, which will focus on whether 14 witnesses were inappropriately excluded from testifying at DeWeese’s 2012 trial; and whether his trial attorney, William Costopoulos, failed to properly preserve their testimony, hampering a previous, failed attempt at an appeal.

DeWeese, the longtime Greene County lawmaker who was once the highest-ranking Democrat in the House, was convicted of theft, conspiracy and violating state law on conflicts of interest after prosecutors presented testimony from witnesses who said he “made little to no genuine effort to ensure that staffers campaigned on leave time,” according to court documents.

Advertise with us

The defense called eight witnesses during DeWeese’s trial, but Dauphin County Common Pleas Judge Todd A. Hoover prevented them from calling 14 more witnesses, arguing that their testimony would have been “cumulative,” or repetitive.

DeWeese’s current attorney, Gaetan J. Alfano, argued in the petition for an appeal that those witnesses would have addressed different incidents, providing exculpatory evidence that could have prevented DeWeese’s conviction. He also argued that while Mr. Costopoulos objected to the exclusion of those witnesses at trial, he “failed, however, to present an on the record proffer of the testimony precluded,” hampering a later appeal by DeWeese.

Mr. Costopoulos did not respond to a message left in his office Tuesday evening.

Reached for comment, Mr. Alfano, a partner with Pietragallo Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti, LLP, said: “My client is pleased that the court has decided to hear the issue on the merits.”

Judge Hoover, who presided over at least one other case in the scandal, has since died.

Advertise with us

The state Attorney General’s “Bonusgate” and related investigations led to charges for 25 legislators and staffers who were accused of using taxpayer money and resources to further political campaigns. Two were acquitted; one had the charges against him dropped, and the others were convicted or pleaded guilty.

DeWeese is not the only one to challenge his conviction. In April, a Dauphin County judge granted a new trial for former state Rep. Steve Stetler, D-York, on the grounds that Judge Hoover had improperly spoken to the jury in the deliberation room. State prosecutors are appealing that decision.

Stetler’s case, like DeWeese’s, grew out of the original Bonusgate investigation and involved charges of using taxpayer resources for political purposes.

Also like DeWeese, Stetler had lost on direct appeal. He won a new trial when appealing under the Post-Conviction Relief Act.

The state Supreme Court last year granted Mike Veon, a onetime House Democratic leader, a new trial in one of the two political corruption cases in which he was convicted.

The first case was the original Bonusgate case, in which he was charged with using taxpayer-funded bonuses to reward legislative staffers who had performed political work. The second case involved charges that he had misappropriated funds from a non-profit he co-founded. He was granted a new trial in the latter case.