When Allegheny County Judge Dwayne Woodruff entered the NFL in 1979, about the best thing that could happen to a defensive back was to be drafted by the Pittsburgh Steelers. It’s not a bad place from which to run for state Supreme Court, either: Four of the court’s current seven judges hail from the Steel City, and Judge Woodruff is hoping to be — OK, we’ll say it — one for the thumb.

But he faces a daunting foe in Justice Sallie Ann Mundy, a Republican and former Superior Court judge who has been serving on the high court since 2016. Gov. Tom Wolf appointed her to fill the seat of Justice Michael Eakin, who retired amid an email porn scandal. Justice Mundy has raised more money than Judge Woodruff, a Democrat, and she’s used it to — all right, fine — go on offense with an air game made up of 15-second TV spots.

Both justices are respected, with the state Bar Association rating Justice Mundy as “highly recommended” and Judge Woodruff as “recommended.” The bar’s Judicial Evaluation Commission hailed Judge Woodruff’s “strong work ethic and unquestioned integrity” while saying his opinions were generally “clear and concise.” Justice Mundy’s opinions “are clearly written and well reasoned,” while the justice herself has been “highly regarded” throughout her judicial career.

The candidates have sketched — somewhat hazily — different judicial philosophies. At a Widener University forum last week, Justice Mundy called herself a “strict constructionist” invoking a judicial approach that hews to a highly literal reading of the state Constitution. “When you start to apply your own particular philosophy, then you are being an activist.”

Advertise with us

Judge Woodruff, meanwhile, said he saw the Constitution as “a living and breathing document. We’re not living in the 1700s any more,” and judges were called to decide questions -- on topics like internet bullying -- that the founders couldn’t have imagined. “The foundation remains the same, but we also have to understand the times that we live in.”

Low-wattage judicial elections are typically decided by less subtle distinctions, like party identification or geography. Justice Mundy, who grew up in Tioga County and attended law school at the University of Pittsburgh, told the Widener forum that she would “bring a diverse perspective to the court: geographic diversity.”

Judge Woodruff stressed a different kind of diversity. "We've only had one person of color elected to that bench.” Robert C. Nix was elected nearly a half-century ago. Two other black justices were appointed to the bench, though the last, Cynthia Baldwin, retired in 2008. “The Supreme Court needs to be more inclusive.”

But compared to 2015, when three Supreme Court seats were up for grabs amid a sharply partisan debate, ideology has taken a back seat.

Justice Mundy, for one, has been supported by an unusual constellation of groups ranging from progressive unions like the Service Employees International Union to staunch conservatives like the Pennsylvania Pro-Life Federation. Judge Woodruff, meanwhile, has the backing of Planned Parenthood’s political arm.

Advertise with us

That broad support for Justice Mundy arguably reflects a wide-ranging legal career that includes work as a volunteer public defender, a plaintiff’s attorney -- and a six-year Superior Court stint in which she penned several rulings friendly to trial lawyers. On the Supreme Court, Justice Mundy’s most locally notable opinion was authoring a unanimous decision to scrap Pittsburgh’s rule requiring police officers to live within city limits.

Judge Woodruff, who earned his law degree from Duquesne University while playing football, was elected to Allegheny County’s Common Pleas bench in 2005. He’s worked in the juvenile division of its Family Court ever since. Unlike Judge Mundy, he lacks experience at the appellate level, and ran unsuccessfully for Supreme Court in 2015. But his resume includes work on boards like the statewide Interbranch Commission on Juvenile Justice, convened to recommend reforms after judges were found taking kickbacks from a Luzerne County juvenile detention facility.

And Judge Woodruff’s willingness to work in an often unsung branch of the justice system, some say, reflects a key strength.

“It’s not a position where you are often engaging in novel concepts of the law, but one where law and social science intersect,” said Margaret Joy, a Pittsburgh lawyer who frequently handles cases in Family Court. “And he’s really viewed as a positive addition to the court. It’s a very hard position, and he could have gotten out by now. A lot of judges do. But he cares about those kids.”

***

In addition, two justices are up for retention: Justice Debra McCloskey Todd and Chief Justice Thomas Saylor. Both justices have been rated Recommended for Retention by the Pennsylvania Bar Association.