The race for two open seats on the state’s Commonwealth Court involves four candidates — two Democrats who survived a crowded May primary and two Republicans who coasted into the November contest unopposed.

The nine-member court has initial jurisdiction in cases involving state government, including litigation against agencies such as the state police, Department of Corrections and Department of Human Services. It also hears appeals of government-related cases that originated in county courts — such as residents’ appeals of zoning, eminent domain and right-to-know rulings.

The top two vote-getters Nov. 7 will serve 10-year terms on a panel that currently leans Republican, 6-1.

The Democratic candidates are Ellen Ceisler, a judge on the Philadelphia Common Pleas Court, and Irene McLaughlin Clark, a former judge on the Pittsburgh Municipal Court. The Republicans are Christine Fizzano Cannon, a judge on the Delaware County Common Pleas Court, and Paul Lalley, an attorney from Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

Judge Ceisler, 60, has been on the Philadelphia court for 10 years, overseeing criminal and civil trials. A 1986 graduate of the Temple University School of Law, she has been an assistant district attorney, an investigative television news producer and director of the Philadelphia Police Department’s Integrity and Accountability Office. She also was director of special investigations in the fraud unit of the Philadelphia controller’s office and legal adviser to the Sheriff's Office of Philadelphia.

She said she looks for Commonwealth Court to be more consistent in handling cases that residents bring without the assistance of attorneys, saying inexperienced litigants are held to varying standards for filing deadlines and other procedures. She also wants the court, which hears cases in Pittsburgh, Harrisburg and Philadelphia, to sit in other counties periodically.

Judge Ceisler has received a “recommended” rating from the state bar.

Ms. Clark, 55, was appointed to Pittsburgh Municipal Court in 1993 by Mayor Sophie Masloff, who recognized her for her three years of work for Jim Ferlo, a city councilman at the time. Ms. Clark’s focus in Mr. Ferlo’s office was on community development, particularly housing and blighted neighborhoods.

A 1988 graduate of the City University of New York School of Law at Queens College, Ms. Clark served 10 years on the Municipal Court until it was reorganized in 2003. She returned to private practice, again focusing on helping municipalities and organizations revitalize rundown communities, experience that she said will help her handle such legal issues on Commonwealth Court.

Advertise with us

Ms. Clark, who now lives in Shadyside, sought election as a district judge in May 2015, but she was unsuccessful. She is the only Commonwealth Court candidate with a “not recommended” rating from the state bar. She said her focus on the Pittsburgh court was too narrow for the bar association’s liking, but she contended that her work on criminal and civil matters qualifies her for Commonwealth Court.

Judge Fizzano Cannon, 48, a former Delaware County councilwoman, was elected to a 10-year term on the Delaware County court in 2011. She currently serves as head of the Civil Trial Section of the court and has presided over 120 trials and more than 1,400 civil cases.

A 1994 graduate of the Widener University School of Law, Judge Fizzano Cannon said she concentrated her practice in business and commercial matters, as well as land-use and estate planning.

“I have presided over tax assessment appeals, matters involving nonprofit corporations, zoning appeals and appeals of decisions rendered by the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board and the Office of Open Records, all matters that fall within the jurisdiction of the Commonwealth Court,” Judge Fizzano Cannon said in a response to the Pennsylvania Bar Association, which labeled her “highly recommended.”

An attorney since 1996, Mr. Lalley, 47, was a candidate for Commonwealth Court in 2015, when he won the Republican primary but was defeated in the general election by Judge Michael Wojick, the only Democrat among the incumbent members. (Democratic Judge Joseph Cosgrove was appointed to an interim term last year by Gov. Tom Wolf, but lost in the May primary and will not be returning.)

Advertise with us

A 1996 graduate of Penn State University Dickinson School of Law in 1996, Mr. Lalley was a law clerk for Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Sandra Schultz Newman from 1997 to 2002. From 2002 to 2009, he practiced with the Levin Legal Group. He currently is an attorney with the Pittsburgh law firm Campbell Durrant Beatty Palombo & Miller, concentrating on labor and employment matters for municipal bodies and public schools.

Mr. Lalley, a resident of Upper St. Clair, said his work with labor arbitrations and collective bargaining agreements has been honed before state and federal courts as well as administrative agencies.

He was attorney for Pittsburgh Public Schools when it sought and won a one-year delay in implementation of the county’s property tax reassessment, and for the West Mifflin Area School District when it challenged a state law that ultimately was overturned before a reassignment plan for Duquesne City Schools students was approved.

The bar association has designated his candidacy “recommended.”

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.